Why is the RC circuit homework statement giving different results than expected?

7 replies · 2K views · last reply
cupid.callin
Messages
1,130
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


Circuit problem text on the left reads: Consider the circuit shown in the figure. Capacitors A and B, each have capacitance C = 2 F. Circuit diagram on the right shows capacitor A shorted by a wire, capacitor B with charge +Q on its left plate, resistor R, and a battery E = 4Q/C with a switch.


The Attempt at a Solution



As at t=0 the capacitor behaves as a wire ... so the circuit at t=0 will be like:

Circuit schematic of a series RC loop: a 4 C capacitor labelled 2F, a 1 Ω resistor, and an 8 V battery.


q at any time for this circuit will be,

[tex]q \ = \ CE(1-e^{-t/\tau}) + Q_oe^{-t/\tau}[/tex]

differentiating it will give current,

[tex]i \ = \ \frac{Ee^{-t/\tau}}{R} \ - \ \frac{Q_oe^{-t/\tau}}{\tau}[/tex]

putting values give 6

but answer is 7
 
Attachments
  • Circuit problem text on the left, with a diagram on the right showing capacitors A and B, a 1 ohm resistor R, a battery labelled E = 4Q/C, a switch, and a charge +Q marked on one plate.
    01275.jpg
    23.8 KB · Views: 545
  • Schematic of a series RC circuit: a 4 C capacitor marked 2 F in the top branch, a 1 Ω resistor in the bottom left, and an 8 V battery on the bottom right.
    Untitled.png
    1.1 KB · Views: 533
Is the 1Ω shorting wire temporary? -- that is to say: is it removed before the switch is closed?
 
No ... but the question asks use for t=0 ... i.e. when capacitor behaves as a wire ... so it will short circuit the resistor ... :)
 
Yup, at t=0, capacitor A has zero potential across it.

At time t=0, what's the potential across capacitor B ?
 
Sorry for the delay. The problem is written in an unfamiliar way (at least for me).

I also came up with 6 amps @ t=0.
 
so that means that the answer in book is wrong?