Why there is minus sign in my tablet phone signal strength?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the interpretation of signal strength readings in dBm on tablet phones, specifically addressing the presence of a minus sign in the measurements. Participants explore the implications of these readings in terms of signal reception and amplification, as well as the technical definitions and conversions related to dBm.

Discussion Character

  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant notes that a reading of -82 dBm indicates a weak signal received from the cell tower, questioning why it is presented with a minus sign.
  • Another participant explains that dBm stands for "dB referenced to 1 mW," and that a negative value indicates the signal strength is less than 1 mW, specifically converting -82 dBm to approximately 8 pW.
  • A participant discusses the relationship between signal strength and distance from the transmitter, referencing the inverse-square law and how signal strength diminishes quickly with distance.
  • There is mention of receiver sensitivity, with a participant stating that most receivers can detect signals down to -110 to -120 dBm, which is considered very weak.
  • Participants discuss the concept of "S" meters used in communications, explaining that these meters indicate signal strength in a different format than dBm.
  • One participant expresses interest in using signal strength readings to estimate the distance to the nearest cell tower.
  • Another participant shares a method to check signal strength on different phone models, including Android and BlackBerry devices.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express various interpretations of the signal strength readings and the significance of the minus sign. While some explanations are provided, there is no consensus on the implications of these readings or the best way to interpret them.

Contextual Notes

The discussion includes technical definitions and assumptions about signal strength measurements, but does not resolve the complexities of how these measurements relate to practical signal reception and performance.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals interested in telecommunications, signal processing, or those seeking to understand mobile device signal strength metrics may find this discussion informative.

xugi
Messages
12
Reaction score
0
I have tablet phone samsung galaxy tab...
when I check the signal strength, it shows -82 dbm...

I thought it is produced by the Signal PA (Power Amplifier) on the PCB...

According to what I know, the signal from the handphone is so weak to reach the nearest terrestrial station on the earth, so it is amplified by the Power Amplifier...

But when it show -82dbm, it means deamplified...

Any correction for this? What is the purpose making it with minus sign?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
xugi said:
I have tablet phone samsung galaxy tab...
when I check the signal strength, it shows -82 dbm...

I thought it is produced by the Signal PA (Power Amplifier) on the PCB...

According to what I know, the signal from the handphone is so weak to reach the nearest terrestrial station on the earth, so it is amplified by the Power Amplifier...

But when it show -82dbm, it means deamplified...

Any correction for this? What is the purpose making it with minus sign?

That is most likely showing the received signal strength ( that's is the signal level received from the cell tower transmitter)

thats not a particulatly strong signal, but most receivers would have a sensitivity down to ~ -110 to -120 dBm

interestlingly, I haven't seen a cellphone giving an actual signal level report like that
usually just the usual "S" meter 1 - 4 bars etc Tho I am used to working with RF test equip that does give that type of indication

cheers
Dave
 
davenn said:
That is most likely showing the received signal strength ( that's is the signal level received from the cell tower transmitter)

thats not a particulatly strong signal, but most receivers would have a sensitivity down to ~ -110 to -120 dBm

interestlingly, I haven't seen a cellphone giving an actual signal level report like that
usually just the usual "S" meter 1 - 4 bars etc Tho I am used to working with RF test equip that does give that type of indication

cheers
Dave

Oh that is receiving signal...
Yeah it's quite interesting to have the setting in Samsung Galaxy Tab to know the signal strength in numbers...

What do you mean usual "S" meter?

N when it signs minus, does it mean the signal power is decreased when coming to the receiver?
 
dBm is short for "dB referenced to 1 mW".
Now, whenever something is given in dB, a minus sign simply means that the number which was converted to dB was smaller than 1; simply because 0.1=10^(-1)

Hence, -82 dBm is just another way of writing 8 pW (p=pico)
 
f95toli said:
dBm is short for "dB referenced to 1 mW".
Now, whenever something is given in dB, a minus sign simply means that the number which was converted to dB was smaller than 1; simply because 0.1=10^(-1)

Hence, -82 dBm is just another way of writing 8 pW (p=pico)

Oh I see, so It means the receiving signal to the receiver is about 8pW...

Does it mean when the 8pW becomes higher then the signal is better to receive data/phone?
 
xugi said:
Oh I see, so It means the receiving signal to the receiver is about 8pW...

Does it mean when the 8pW becomes higher then the signal is better to receive data/phone?

a -40dBm signal is 40 dB stronger than -80dBm
The level of a transmitter signal drops off very quickly as it moves away from the antenna
have a look in wikipedia under Inverse square law ... the first few lines...

"In physics, an inverse-square law is any physical law stating that a specified physical quantity or strength is inversely proportional to the square of the distance from the source of that physical quantity."

so by the time you get even a few 100 metres away from the antenna, the signal strength has already dropped to a few microWatts
There are formula to work it all out, I won't confuse you with all that at the moment.
But for radio comms activities I do I need to be abe to work those signal levels out at a given frequency so I can work out what is called a "Link Budget" ... briefly...

I have a certain transmitter power out, a loss in the coax cable, gain in the antenna, loss in the path between the TX antenna and the RX antenna coax loss again at the receive end
and then gain in the receiver circuit. I can work out if I am going to successfully hear a signal over a given distance path.

in that last post of mine I commented about receiver sensitivity usually down to ~ -110 to -120 dBm ... that is a VERY weak signal.

the usual "S" meter 1 - 4 bars etc

"S" meter = Signal strength meter on communications radios, the signal is given in S points
each "S" point on the meter is supposed to be an increase of 6dB. In reality it is never that good ... very few comms receivers have accurately calibrated meters.

In communications, like amateur radio, we give readibility and signal strength reports eg 5 x 9 ... that's readibilty 5 signal strength (S meter reading) of 9
A mobile phone's S meter is usually a bargraph display that you would be familiar with ... 1 bar weak signal, 2 bars medium strength signal, 3 bars full signal ...

Hopefully you find that useful and not too confusing... just ask Q's for clarification :)

cheers
Dave
 
Very complete explanation...
It's cool, means if I know the signal strength, in ideal condition I can estimate the nearest tower surround me!
What an amazing Physics!

Thank you very much to davenn and f95toli :D
 
if you have an android phone go to:

setting > about phone > status

to find your signal strength, mine at the time of writing this is "-97dBm" and "8 asu"

ASU is ACTIVE SET UPDATES or the rate at which your phone is able to update its location to the towers/radios.

on a BlackBerry hold down the "ALT" key on your BlackBerry and type the letters NMLL in this order to see your dBm