Why ultimate load is less than yield load?

  • Thread starter Thread starter FK123
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Load Yield
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion focuses on calculating the yield load and ultimate load of a fixed-fixed beam subjected to a central load. The ultimate load was determined to be 440 kN using the formula 8Mp/L, where Mp is the plastic moment. The yield load was calculated to be 293.3 kN, based on the bending stress reaching the yield strength of the material, which is 220 N/mm². The nonlinear analysis indicated a maximum load of 306 kN, raising questions about discrepancies between theoretical and software results.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of beam mechanics, specifically fixed-fixed beam behavior.
  • Knowledge of bending stress calculations using σ = My/I.
  • Familiarity with shear stress calculations using τ = VQ/(It).
  • Experience with nonlinear analysis and material modeling, particularly the von Mises criterion.
NEXT STEPS
  • Study the calculation of plastic moments in beam theory.
  • Learn about the von Mises yield criterion in material science.
  • Explore nonlinear analysis techniques in structural engineering software.
  • Investigate the differences between theoretical load calculations and software outputs in beam analysis.
USEFUL FOR

Structural engineers, civil engineering students, and professionals involved in beam design and analysis will benefit from this discussion, particularly those focusing on yield and ultimate load calculations.

FK123
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
i have made a beam with both ends fixed. when I apply load at center then the ultimate load will be 8Mp/L=8fyz/L which came to be 440KN

My question is how to calculate the load at which beam starts yielding?

I have used E=200000N/mm2 and initial yield strength=220N/mm2
 
Last edited:
Engineering news on Phys.org
FK123 said:
i have made a beam with both ends fixed. when I apply load at center then the ultimate load will be 8Mp/L=8fyz/L which came to be 440KN

My question is how to calculate the load at which beam starts yielding?

I have used E=200000N/mm2 and initial yield strength=220N/mm2
We'll need a lot more information than you've given us to figure out what you've done.

First, tell us the length of the beam.

Second, tell us what you mean when you write "8Mp/L=8fyz/L". About all I can guess is that L = length of the beam. Everything else, who knows?

For a fixed-fixed beam with a central load P, the max. bending moment is MMAX = PL / 8, which occurs at the ends of the beam and in the center.

beam.h48.jpg
beam.h47.gif


While the bending stress remains below the yield stress, then the bending stress σ is calculated by

σ = M y / I,

where M = bending moment,
y = distance from the neutral axis of the beam
I = second moment of area of the beam cross section.

shear stress τ is calculated by

τ = VQ / (I * t)

where V = shear force,
I = second moment of area of the beam cross section (same value used above)
Q = first moment of area
t = span of the cross section in way of the shear stress location.

As you can see, you need to know something about the beam cross section in order to calculate the stresses created when the beam is loaded.

Because of the nature in which a fixed-fixed beam is supported, there will be additional shear stresses created at the locations where the maximum bending moment occurs, so these shear stresses must be calculated and combined with the bending stress to give the proper stress value at those locations, so that one can determine the load at which yielding of the material in the beam occurs.

Once the stress in the outer fibers of beam exceeds the yield stress of the material, the formula above no longer applies and a plastic analysis must be performed.
 
Thankyou
Length of beam=1000mm Width of beam=100mm height of beam=100mm
Ultimate load = 8* Plastic Moment/ length
where Plastic moment = Yield stress * plastic section modulus

I was supposed to do non linear analysis of beam. so i have used the von mises model to define the beam material property. where E=200000N/mm2 and initial yield strength=220N/mm2 and poison ratio=0.28
my professor told me to calculate manually the load at which plastic hinge will be created and the load at which material starts yielding. Therefore i have used Ultimate load = 8* Plastic Moment/ length to calculate load at which plastic hinge created.

But i didnt know how to calculate load at yield?
 
FK123 said:
Thankyou
Length of beam=1000mm Width of beam=100mm height of beam=100mm
Ultimate load = 8* Plastic Moment/ length
where Plastic moment = Yield stress * plastic section modulus

I was supposed to do non linear analysis of beam. so i have used the von mises model to define the beam material property. where E=200000N/mm2 and initial yield strength=220N/mm2 and poison ratio=0.28
my professor told me to calculate manually the load at which plastic hinge will be created and the load at which material starts yielding. Therefore i have used Ultimate load = 8* Plastic Moment/ length to calculate load at which plastic hinge created.

But i didnt know how to calculate load at yield?
Finding the load at yield is simple. When the beam bends elastically, the outer fibers see the highest bending stresses. Find the load P such that the bending stress in the outer fiber of the beam reaches the yield stress of the material.

Assuming that the cross section of this beam is rectangular, the maximum bending stress at the outer fibers will be

σ = M y / I = 220 N/mm2, where y = depth of the beam / 2 and I = bh3/12. Solve for M, which is also M = P*L/8.
 
thankyou
 
I have calculated the load at plastic hinge i.e 440KN
and the load at yield is 293.3KN

when i do nonlinear analysis it shows the maximum load of 306KN. why does not the software runs till 440KN since 440 is ultimate load where plastic hinge will be created? the graph below shows the maximum load 306KK. the graph is between load and displacement
upload_2015-7-7_13-55-8.png
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
90K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K