Windows 10 made a brick out of my laptop

Click For Summary
A laptop purchased 1.5 years ago for academic purposes has failed just weeks before graduation, leading to significant frustration. The user experienced issues after multiple reboots between Linux and Windows, culminating in an "unmountable" error in Windows. Attempts to access the BIOS were unsuccessful, resulting in a black screen, and hardware support at the university could not resolve the issue. There is suspicion that a Windows update may have corrupted the BIOS or firmware, causing the failure. The user expresses a strong distrust of Windows, labeling it as unreliable for serious tasks, and plans to remove Windows from their current slower laptop. Discussions reveal a broader sentiment against Windows 10, with many users sharing experiences of forced updates and system issues, particularly in multi-boot configurations. Some believe the problems stem from hardware rather than software, suggesting that BIOS settings may have been inadvertently altered. The conversation highlights a growing dissatisfaction with Windows among users who prefer more stable operating systems, such as Linux, for their computing needs.
  • #31
YesMam said:
Thank you for reminding me that - yet again - I must unsubscribe.
Have a nice day. :smile:
 
  • Like
Likes ing_it, davenn, Tom.G and 3 others
Computer science news on Phys.org
  • #32
I've had no problems with Windows 10 to date, since I got this laptop with it pre-installed boxing day (26 Dec) last year. Nor did I have trouble with it when I upgraded from Windows 8.1 to 10 on my previous laptop (except fixing an issue with Outlook, which took about 5 mins).
 
  • #33
My wife also loves Chromebook. It's like it was custom-made for her uses. So it's a great machine and system - for her. I can't project my preferences onto her preferences. Unless she wanted to be my clone or hand-maiden or ouch!... "I was just kidding, honey. Get back to your murder mystery horror chiller theatre." Can't understand why she loves those murder shows especially the ones where the wife plots to kill her husband - the Black Widows... hmmmm.
But, I will never use Win 10 (I hope - although I'm sure MS will build something somehow that I will HAVE to own which will be completely dependant on Win 10 but I would still really need to judge whether it would be worth my pain. Usually their trick is to 'support' a kickass new graphics card that only comes with a Windows driver (hmmmmm) so I'll need to install Windows or keep salivating until the Linux crew can make a driver that'll work.
W7 was good but since the sneaky Windows Update Win 10 Trojan Horse installation began, I have poured all my energy into Ubuntu 15.10. Don't even have anything from Windows and it's been a month or so and so far everything is OK. A few minor bugs at the start but all learning experience. And, really folks, there's nothing wrong with brushing up on Linux again. The day will come pretty quick when Billy Gates will be standing in the unemployment line.
Oh, and the OP?? I think you have a boot drive starting to go on you or theirs a break in your motherboard. Sounds like hardware. Go find a good laptop which is good to go with all Linux drivers and go for it. Find out the specs on the laptop of your dreams then go home and run each piece of hardware through Google and check if there are any issues with Linux. If not, get it and don't look back.
 
  • Like
Likes ProfuselyQuarky
  • #34
ebos said:
Can't understand why she loves those murder shows especially the ones where the wife plots to kill her husband - the Black Widows... hmmmm.
She's on to you, man! Run! :biggrin:
 
  • #35
YesMam said:
So, here, like in thousands of places across the internet, we have people complaining about Windows 10. Making accusations, providing opinions. Average people - which is to say, people who do not maintain their computers, know little about computers, software, hardware, malware. People who have allowed all kinds of junk to inhabit their computers. People who never did - and never could - figure out how to program their VCRs. People who do not wash their hands after using the toilet. These mark the behaviors of average people.

Sometime, somewhere, there may exist a parallel internet - a parallel universe - where people will be self-aware enough to restrain themselves from expressing opinions about things they know zero about.

Unfortunately, this is not that place. Rather, it is a world of borderline idiots, lurching along and supporting one another - the blind leading the blind.

Thank you for reminding me that - yet again - I must unsubscribe.
Don't let the door hit you in the butt on the way out. Perhaps you work for Microsoft, makers of the wonderful Windoze OS. This is a science website/forum and I choose to come here for the intelligent conversation and advice. Science - Physics, Math, etc - requires a strong ability at computer use including hardware, software and networking which is usually quite close to cutting edge whether we can afford them or not because this ability is important for our continued successes and achievements. You may be visiting us from another dimension, or time or region of space. But, sadly and most likely, you are a bot trolling for some bot-approval from your superiors - us.
 
  • Like
Likes ing_it, Psinter and Tom.G
  • #36
What is upsetting about Win 10 is that I never asked for it nor approved the installation. Suddenly it was just there! I have always used the Google Chrome browser for years with many useful extensions. Every time I turn off my I7 quad core HP computer, I find upon rebooting that Win 10 has completely cleared Chrome from the Program Files. To use Chrome I have to use the Win 10 browser and re-download Chrome. Win 10 will not allow Chrome as the default browser in settings. I now leave my laptop in sleep mode and plugged into avoid this. How do I downgrade back to Win 7?? BTW, auto updates also erase Chrome as part of the update process.
 
  • #37
Thread closed temporarily for Moderation...
 
  • #38
Thread re-opened. The troll has been shown the door (this was not his only troll post).
 
  • Like
Likes 1oldman2, jim hardy, Psinter and 1 other person
  • #39
So what OS would turn a brick unto a laptop?
 
  • Like
Likes ing_it and 1oldman2
  • #40
cosmicthinker said:
Every time I turn off my I7 quad core HP computer, I find upon rebooting that Win 10 has completely cleared Chrome from the Program Files. To use Chrome I have to use the Win 10 browser and re-download Chrome. Win 10 will not allow Chrome as the default browser in settings. I now leave my laptop in sleep mode and plugged into avoid this. How do I downgrade back to Win 7?? BTW, auto updates also erase Chrome as part of the update process.

I have an HP with Win10 too and this just isn't happening to me. :O
 
  • #41
  • #42
@fluidistic I still think that you're being a wee bit harsh on Windows. If it was so bad, then so many people would not being using it. My parent works at a government agency where very confidential documents and information are handled. They use Windows and everything's always fine. Just because you had some problems, doesn't mean that every PC with Windows OS has the same issues.
 
  • #43
I tried Ten twice. Once for several days. It frustrated me because it changed how i get to stuff like my pictures - and i have no patience with overautomated ingratiating machines that do things i did not tell them to do.
So i went back to 7 both times.
Third time Ten installed itself without asking , but by clicking the "go back to 7" button it gracefully uninstalled itself even to the point of opening same Internet windows i'd had open when it hijacked me. I gave Microsoft's feedback survey an attaboy for that but told them in no uncertain terms ".. if i wanted an Apple clone i'd buy one. Don't take over my computer and Never ever again move my cheese."

Son has Ten and says he found buttons during installation to keep it from moving his cheese. I didn't notice anything like that.
I was however tipped off to the buttons that keep Ten from reporting everything you do to Microsoft and from stashing your stuff on the "Cloud".
I've heard Ten called a huge Trojan. Horse or prophylactic?

I just didn't like it. But old folks don't handle drastic change so well
 
  • Like
Likes krater, Tom.G, ing_it and 3 others
  • #44
my win10 new computer does not work with diablo cam-will not recognize it and will not accept driver for it !
 
  • #45
ProfuselyQuarky said:
@fluidistic I still think that you're being a wee bit harsh on Windows. If it was so bad, then so many people would not being using it. My parent works at a government agency where very confidential documents and information are handled. They use Windows and everything's always fine. Just because you had some problems, doesn't mean that every PC with Windows OS has the same issues.
I am fully aware I am a case in a million or even unluckier. I use Windows in less than 1% of the time, and when I use it it's just for running 1 program (okay, add firefox to this, but only wikipedia/PF and some other "secure" websites.). But I am not being harsh at all. A compagny should not be able to realize deep changes in the system without my approvement (though I probably clicked on a button that approved to give my full hardware handling to Microsoft Windows in order to being able to use MW). I understand that most people use more common hardware with better known brands and that Windows updates don't break their computers.
Anyway today I got the verdict, the guy who knows how to fix computers couldn't find any hardware problem. He doesn't know what's wrong and he said that I'm unlucky that the brand which made the laptop exists only here (in a single country), which is a problem if I want to change say the motherboard. The warranty is off by a few months so it's over, I'm not going to fight to "save" this laptop even though it took me a full year to pay it (over 800 dollars for a core i3 3rd gen. 3217u, I am unlucky to live in a country where the hardware is one of the most expensive on Earth).
I got my degree 2 days ago, and that's all what matters to me.
So long Windows, so long to my laptop.
 
  • Like
Likes 1oldman2
  • #46
fluidistic said:
Anyway today I got the verdict, the guy who knows how to fix computers couldn't find any hardware problem. He doesn't know what's wrong and he said that I'm unlucky that the brand which made the laptop exists only here (in a single country), which is a problem if I want to change say the motherboard. The warranty is off by a few months so it's over, I'm not going to fight to "save" this laptop even though it took me a full year to pay it (over 800 dollars for a core i3 3rd gen. 3217u, I am unlucky to live in a country where the hardware is one of the most expensive on Earth).
I got my degree 2 days ago, and that's all what matters to me.
So long Windows, so long to my laptop.
Sorry ‘bout that :frown: What country do you live in and what brand is the laptop, out of curiosity?
 
  • Like
Likes 1oldman2
  • #47
jim hardy said:
Son has Ten and says he found buttons during installation to keep it from moving his cheese. I didn't notice anything like that.
I was however tipped off to the buttons that keep Ten from reporting everything you do to Microsoft and from stashing your stuff on the "Cloud".
I've heard Ten called a huge Trojan. Horse or prophylactic?

I just didn't like it. But old folks don't handle drastic change so well
If that's not enough, MS is releasing an army of "bots" in the system to "help us".
 
  • #48
For anyone who has had enough of Microsoft especially due to the Windows 10 "upgrade" I would strongly suggest surfing on over to download your favourite version of Linux (I like Ubuntu). They're basically all GUI's now and very friendly as well (Ubuntu actually has 2 GUI's to choose from several versions - just go there.). Many even offer a 'live CD (USB)' version, which allows you to try out the version you have downloaded before installing it. Then if you decide this version is for you - for example; all the drivers, etc work out fine with your model and make of computer - you can go ahead and install it.
There's a slight learning curve but remember the alternative.
 
  • #49
ebos said:
For anyone who has had enough of Microsoft especially due to the Windows 10 "upgrade" I would strongly suggest surfing on over to download your favourite version of Linux (I like Ubuntu). They're basically all GUI's now and very friendly as well (Ubuntu actually has 2 GUI's to choose from several versions - just go there.). Many even offer a 'live CD (USB)' version, which allows you to try out the version you have downloaded before installing it. Then if you decide this version is for you - for example; all the drivers, etc work out fine with your model and make of computer - you can go ahead and install it.
There's a slight learning curve but remember the alternative.
Forgot to add: there's also an easy-as-pie dual boot alternative so you can continue to use Windows if you still want until you get proficient.
 
  • #50
If I understand this correctly, the "bricked laptop" has suffered a MBR corruption. there are several BIOS Boot loaders controlled by the MBR that make it possible to boot multiple operating systems. The BIOS Boot Loaders may be intact but with an MBR corruption the the computer can not select which Boot Loader to use so it sits an does nothing. Low BIOS core can not be touched by any program, if so equipped, because it is flashed by higher voltages usually 28V at the factory. There is usually a nondescript pin or pad next to the BIOS ROM for this. If this was the problem your laptop is, indeed, toast. The higher BIOS Flash ROM could have been corrupted by Windows 10, but that is unlikely, it would require a BIOS loader specific to your main-board. If this happened you might be able to recover by getting a BIOS loader with an BIOS upgrade that would have to come from the company that you got your laptop from, as all BIOS Loaders are propitiatory. Finally there is the volatile BIOS RAM or CMOS, an easy fix, just remove the BIOS/CMOS battery which will erase any corruption. Give it a few seconds though, about 10 or 15 seconds should do the trick. If the MBR is corrupted the only thing you can do is, install your drive in another computer as a slave, or use an exterior drive/USB interface. If it is PATA you will need an adapter if SATA you should be able to plug it into any SATA cable. If the FAT or NTFS is intact recover as many files as possible. Zero the drive, reformat, reinstall the MBR with the appropriate BIOS Boot loader that is compatible for the operating system you wish to install.

Your results may vary.

Eimacman
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes fluidistic
  • #51
jim hardy said:
... i have no patience with overautomated ingratiating machines that do things i did not tell them to do.
Boy, howdy, +1 on that. Plus several actually since it annoys me enough to cover annoyance for at least twins if not triplets.
 
  • Like
Likes ProfuselyQuarky, ing_it and jim hardy
  • #52
There is nothing more aggravating than an op system that does not fallow your commands, and puts features in that you do not want or need, that you can not disable, or changes the BIOS in any way. If any thing is going to tweak my firmware it is going to be Dell and not Microsoft.

Eimacman
 
  • Like
Likes ing_it and jim hardy
  • #53
amusing to read someone say he was told even windows 10 is better than a mac. i have been a mac user since 1987 and for most of that time could count the number of crashes on one hand, most of them with microsoft word, the company responsible for windows. my son the tech expert told me years ago windows is just a clunky version of the mac. i have been listening to microsoft users crying the blues for literally decades, all the while cruising with an easy mac computer interface. but to each his own. I am still using my 10 year old macbook that still does what I want, in spite of being outdated in many ways. Forgive me, I am not gloating, just puzzled at the post disparaging the (to me obviously) better system. Good luck with the problem.
 
  • #54
I thought DOS was jut fine ..
 
  • #55
For those who are interested, Microsoft has a page describing how to 'manage' Windows 10 notification and upgrade options. It has several options for disabling the attempts to auto-install the software through the updater. I chose the registry option. I'll see how well it works the next time that I check for updates.
To block the upgrade to Windows 10 through Windows Update, specify the following registry value:

Subkey: HKLM\SOFTWARE\Policies\Microsoft\Windows\WindowsUpdate
DWORD value: DisableOSUpgrade = 1
 
  • Like
Likes Tom.G and 1oldman2
  • #56
Borg said:
For those who are interested, Microsoft has a page describing how to 'manage' Windows 10 notification and upgrade options. It has several options for disabling the attempts to auto-install the software through the updater. I chose the registry option. I'll see how well it works the next time that I check for updates.
doesn't work for my Windows 7; regedit can't find the specified subkey and they moronically don't say where to look for it manually.
 
Last edited:
  • #57
phinds said:
doesn't work for my (Window 7). Regedit can't find the specified subkey and they moronically don't say where to look for it manually.
You have to create it yourself. Go to the specified directory and in the right side window, right-click and select new DWord. Create it with the specified values.
BTW, HKLM is short for HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE.

Another DWord that I added years ago to that directory is NoAutoRebootWithLoggedOnUsers. Guess what that does. :oldwink:
 
Last edited:
  • #58
Borg said:
You have to create it yourself. Go to the specified directory and in the right side window, right-click and select new DWord. Create it with the specified values.
BTW, HKLM is short for HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE.
Aha. Didn't realize that. Thanks.

Regedit gets me as far as HKLM\SOFTWARE\Policies\Microsoft\Windows but there is no WindowsUpdate. Am I supposed to create that and then create a key inside it? I've almost never done registry edits and none for a very long time.
 
  • #59
phinds said:
Regedit gets me as far as HKLM\SOFTWARE\Policies\Microsoft\Windows but there is no WindowsUpdate. Am I supposed to create that and then create a key inside it?
Yes. I've got 3 entries in the WindowsUpdate folder and they are all ones that I added. It's been so long that I forgot.
phinds said:
I've almost never done registry edits and none for a very long time.
As long as you're just making an addition, you should be fine.
 
  • #60
Borg said:
Yes. I've got 3 entries in the WindowsUpdate folder and they are all ones that I added. It's been so long that I forgot.

As long as you're just making an addition, you should be fine.
OK, thanks. I put it in and I'll see if it works next time I reboot.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
8K