Windows 10 made a brick out of my laptop

AI Thread Summary
A laptop purchased 1.5 years ago for academic purposes has failed just weeks before graduation, leading to significant frustration. The user experienced issues after multiple reboots between Linux and Windows, culminating in an "unmountable" error in Windows. Attempts to access the BIOS were unsuccessful, resulting in a black screen, and hardware support at the university could not resolve the issue. There is suspicion that a Windows update may have corrupted the BIOS or firmware, causing the failure. The user expresses a strong distrust of Windows, labeling it as unreliable for serious tasks, and plans to remove Windows from their current slower laptop. Discussions reveal a broader sentiment against Windows 10, with many users sharing experiences of forced updates and system issues, particularly in multi-boot configurations. Some believe the problems stem from hardware rather than software, suggesting that BIOS settings may have been inadvertently altered. The conversation highlights a growing dissatisfaction with Windows among users who prefer more stable operating systems, such as Linux, for their computing needs.
  • #51
jim hardy said:
... i have no patience with overautomated ingratiating machines that do things i did not tell them to do.
Boy, howdy, +1 on that. Plus several actually since it annoys me enough to cover annoyance for at least twins if not triplets.
 
  • Like
Likes ProfuselyQuarky, ing_it and jim hardy
Computer science news on Phys.org
  • #52
There is nothing more aggravating than an op system that does not fallow your commands, and puts features in that you do not want or need, that you can not disable, or changes the BIOS in any way. If any thing is going to tweak my firmware it is going to be Dell and not Microsoft.

Eimacman
 
  • Like
Likes ing_it and jim hardy
  • #53
amusing to read someone say he was told even windows 10 is better than a mac. i have been a mac user since 1987 and for most of that time could count the number of crashes on one hand, most of them with microsoft word, the company responsible for windows. my son the tech expert told me years ago windows is just a clunky version of the mac. i have been listening to microsoft users crying the blues for literally decades, all the while cruising with an easy mac computer interface. but to each his own. I am still using my 10 year old macbook that still does what I want, in spite of being outdated in many ways. Forgive me, I am not gloating, just puzzled at the post disparaging the (to me obviously) better system. Good luck with the problem.
 
  • #54
I thought DOS was jut fine ..
 
  • #55
For those who are interested, Microsoft has a page describing how to 'manage' Windows 10 notification and upgrade options. It has several options for disabling the attempts to auto-install the software through the updater. I chose the registry option. I'll see how well it works the next time that I check for updates.
To block the upgrade to Windows 10 through Windows Update, specify the following registry value:

Subkey: HKLM\SOFTWARE\Policies\Microsoft\Windows\WindowsUpdate
DWORD value: DisableOSUpgrade = 1
 
  • Like
Likes Tom.G and 1oldman2
  • #56
Borg said:
For those who are interested, Microsoft has a page describing how to 'manage' Windows 10 notification and upgrade options. It has several options for disabling the attempts to auto-install the software through the updater. I chose the registry option. I'll see how well it works the next time that I check for updates.
doesn't work for my Windows 7; regedit can't find the specified subkey and they moronically don't say where to look for it manually.
 
Last edited:
  • #57
phinds said:
doesn't work for my (Window 7). Regedit can't find the specified subkey and they moronically don't say where to look for it manually.
You have to create it yourself. Go to the specified directory and in the right side window, right-click and select new DWord. Create it with the specified values.
BTW, HKLM is short for HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE.

Another DWord that I added years ago to that directory is NoAutoRebootWithLoggedOnUsers. Guess what that does. :oldwink:
 
Last edited:
  • #58
Borg said:
You have to create it yourself. Go to the specified directory and in the right side window, right-click and select new DWord. Create it with the specified values.
BTW, HKLM is short for HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE.
Aha. Didn't realize that. Thanks.

Regedit gets me as far as HKLM\SOFTWARE\Policies\Microsoft\Windows but there is no WindowsUpdate. Am I supposed to create that and then create a key inside it? I've almost never done registry edits and none for a very long time.
 
  • #59
phinds said:
Regedit gets me as far as HKLM\SOFTWARE\Policies\Microsoft\Windows but there is no WindowsUpdate. Am I supposed to create that and then create a key inside it?
Yes. I've got 3 entries in the WindowsUpdate folder and they are all ones that I added. It's been so long that I forgot.
phinds said:
I've almost never done registry edits and none for a very long time.
As long as you're just making an addition, you should be fine.
 
  • #60
Borg said:
Yes. I've got 3 entries in the WindowsUpdate folder and they are all ones that I added. It's been so long that I forgot.

As long as you're just making an addition, you should be fine.
OK, thanks. I put it in and I'll see if it works next time I reboot.
 
  • #61
Borg said:
For those who are interested, Microsoft has a page describing how to 'manage' Windows 10 notification and upgrade options. It has several options for disabling the attempts to auto-install the software through the updater. I chose the registry option. I'll see how well it works the next time that I check for updates.

Is there a page that explains how to disable sending back data? In regedit i mean, i think i disabled everything in control panel as it is.

Thanks for any answers
 
  • #62
Rocco the Stiff said:
Is there a page that explains how to disable sending back data? In regedit i mean, i think i disabled everything in control panel as it is.

Thanks for any answers
Here is one article on the subject, telemetry control on 10 is a very popular subject a quick search will reveal much more.
http://windowsitpro.com/windows-10/control-telemetry-information-windows-10
 
  • #63
@Borg it didn't work. Waaaa. I want that $&#*@&!%^ Windows 10 Update GONE, but no joy on this method.
 
  • Like
Likes 1oldman2
  • #64
phinds said:
@Borg it didn't work. Waaaa. I want that $&#*@&!%^ Windows 10 Update GONE, but no joy on this method.
Ditto
 
  • #65
phinds said:
@Borg it didn't work. Waaaa. I want that $&#*@&!%^ Windows 10 Update GONE, but no joy on this method.
Are you talking about the update to windows 10 icon in the system tray? I got rid of mine last year by uninstalling update KB3035583. However, to prevent it from coming back I had to switch my windows update from auto to manual. Now when I get a new list of updates I uncheck all updates except for the security updates. I don't know if it's true, but I've read (from unreliable sources) that MS will try and sneak the windows 10 stuff in with the other updates. So if that's true then just uninstalling that one may not work now.
 
  • Like
Likes jim hardy
  • #66
TurtleMeister said:
I got rid of mine last year by uninstalling update KB3035583.

I've been searching for hours for that number. It worked for me with Win7

'windows updates' at very bottom of control panel has a 'change settings' button where i selected 'let me choose'...
But Win10 is lurking there just waiting for me to make one wrong click . Proverbial wolf in mouse's clothing...
 
Last edited:
  • #67
TurtleMeister said:
Are you talking about the update to windows 10 icon in the system tray? I got rid of mine last year by uninstalling update KB3035583. However, to prevent it from coming back I had to switch my windows update from auto to manual. Now when I get a new list of updates I uncheck all updates except for the security updates. I don't know if it's true, but I've read (from unreliable sources) that MS will try and sneak the windows 10 stuff in with the other updates. So if that's true then just uninstalling that one may not work now.

see posts #111 and #116 in the thread "discussions on win10" They are particularly relative to what your speaking of here. (Don has a great point with the GWX control panel) :smile:
 
  • #68
jim hardy said:
Win10 is lurking there just waiting for me to make one wrong click . Proverbial wolf in mouse's clothing...
This is a very accurate description in my experience, "lurking wolves". Win10 has a lot of surprises in store for you when you get looking closer, A good start would be don't link 10 to a windows account rather the "Local account" is the way to go or the lids off your cookie jar from the very start. It would be a good plan to spend a little time searching "win10 telemetry control" before setting up 10 after installing it.
 
  • #69
1oldman2 said:
This is a very accurate description in my experience, "lurking wolves". Win10 has a lot of surprises in store for you when you get looking closer, A good start would be don't link 10 to a windows account rather the "Local account" is the way to go or the lids off your cookie jar from the very start. It would be a good plan to spend a little time searching "win10 telemetry control" before setting up 10 after installing it.
Better still would be just stick with Window 7 :smile:
 
  • #70
phinds said:
@Borg it didn't work. Waaaa. I want that $&#*@&!%^ Windows 10 Update GONE, but no joy on this method.
Sorry to hear that. I will see what my home computer does when I am on it next.
 
  • #71
Bad news for me. The store where I sent the laptop told me they don't know what's wrong with the laptop and that they would change the motherboard + hard disk if I pay about 250 dollars, without any guarantee that this would fix the problem.
I decided not to do anything, of course. I paid the minimum fee and went to another store. I explained during 20 minutes the whole story. The guy said he will try to retrieve the data on my hard disk during the next week while the laptop would be sent to a specialized place where technicians will try to fix any problem related to video card/motherboard and power button. If I understood him well, they will run some software that analyze deeply whether the hardware is behaving normally, and that they will try 3 times at most. If this doesn't fix anything I'll have to pay the minimum fee. If this fixes things out, I'd have to pay a bit less than 100 dollars. But I have to wait about 3 weeks.
I'll keep you guys updated...
 
  • #72
I really enjoyed this rant of yours from post #1 :

I must say that I truly believe that Windows is a cheap-toy OS not serious enough to be trusted for serious matters. I can't count on it... . I feel like Windows should disappear from being sold by default in most places, and should be replaced by other more serious and solid OS'es .

Boring Anecdote Alert :

I had opportunity to vent in a similar vein before some company VIP's ... a Windows update erased an important Powerpoint slideshow i'd prepared for the meeting . In fact all my files disappeared.

I said , when asked why we had no presentation :
" Gentlemen,
Last night's Windows update completely destroyed everything i have ever done on that computer ,
it is all 'Gone With the E-Wind'
including today's presentation and its backup.
I can have it for you by this time next week. It will be on 35mm slides and my 1960 Kodak Carousel projector."
Then i looked the IT guy right in the eye and continued:
"Windows is simply not suitable for a serious industrial environment."
Pulling a compact slide rule from my shirt pocket and waving it over my head i went on , still looking IT in the eye:
"I intend never again to log on to the company system and request that you delete my account. I have kept this slide rule which does all the computing i need to do and is reliable. "

The poor IT guy turned red and stomped out of the room.

I rather expected to be in trouble
but right as the meeting adjourned our top manager walked up, shook my hand & said "That was Great - Thanks !"

Maybe i wasn't the only one frustrated.
old jim
 
  • #73
Hmmm

maybe Microsoft overheard my last post

Windows Security Essentials now refuses to update
gives the
OX80004004
error


oh well.
 
  • #74
I vote possible virus, and would pursue removal programs, or a "factory reset"... Do you have a backup file?

Otherwise I've decided to trust MS computer scientists; that their best efforts are focused on their latest platform... Their income depends on customer's satisfaction!... They are profoundly more knowledgeable than myself in fixing OS problems.

I also think they may announce a date after which older windows OS won't be updated by them!
 
Last edited:
  • #75
jim hardy said:
Hmmm

maybe Microsoft overheard my last post

Windows Security Essentials now refuses to update
gives the
OX80004004
erroroh well.
Same here. After reinstalling Windows 7, I disabled Windows Update, returned to Windows Defender (can be updated without Windows Update), and just for good measures, installed GWX Control Panel. :approve:
 
  • Like
Likes jim hardy
  • #76
It's very curious...

if i start Security Essentials first thing after restarting the computer without opening a browser,
it will update once, and i can run a scan, and it reports itself up-to-date.
But once i open the browser, a bit someplace gets set that blocks update.
My guess is two different programmers used the same name in two different programs for two different somethings, and first program to execute changes that something for the second .

Just one more Windows quirk to live with.

About same time a hitherto unseen sound manager appeared
upload_2016-4-25_23-56-7.png


and it's unpredictable which one appears when i click the speaker icon.
"I dream of Linux ..."

not going to fight it. When this one dies i'll have more time to fix outboard motors.

old jim
 
  • Like
Likes 1oldman2
  • #77
I have been "assimilated."
 
  • Like
Likes ProfuselyQuarky
  • #78
Bystander said:
I have been "assimilated."
Grin and bear it. :smile:
 
  • Like
Likes ProfuselyQuarky
  • #79
Way back fluidistic said:
fluidistic said:
Linux can do it with a single command (see http://thenextweb.com/insider/2016/...-permanently-brick-laptops-from-inside-linux/), that command would break laptops and make them unrecoverable. But at least it's under the user's hands, unlike Windows OS which is in both the users and Microsoft's heavy hands.
It looks like Extensible Firmware Interface is located on the hard drive and takes up where BIOS firmware leaves off between the firmware (BIOS) and OS (Windows, Mac, Lunix, Solstice, etc) and if this is so any OS that has a tendency to overwrite the directory that contains the EFI could 'brick' a laptop. The thing that cheeses me off is why they can't put this on the mother board as a EPROM instead of on the hard drive where it can't be messed up by stupidity.

If this is the case, replace the deleted EFI directory on the hard drive and the 'bricked' laptop should come back to life, one would have to replace the MBR and OS as well. Now I haven't got a foggiest idea how to replace the EFI so your are on your own there.
 
  • #80
"Good news", they fixed my laptop. Though they didn't tell me what they've done. I notice that it doesn't have uefi support anymore. It seems to have the same specs as before, so I won't complain.
I've installed linux as only OS for the first time in my life.
Never Windows again.
 
  • Like
Likes ProfuselyQuarky, jim hardy and 1oldman2
  • #81
fluidistic said:
I've installed linux as only OS for the first time in my life.

how hard is that ? I soooooo want shed of Microshaft...
 
  • Like
Likes fluidistic
  • #82
jim hardy said:
how hard is that ? I soooooo want shed of Microshaft...
It depends on how much you use Windows. I was forced to use it for 1 program only so I didn't use it for months and quitting Windows is a breeze for me.
 
  • #83
well i tried to download Ubuntu with something named Rufus,
it said plug in a 32gigabyte all i had was a 16 so of course it didnt go

will be back for advice
 
  • #84
Win 7 and XP were not bad. I really like Win 2000 when it first came out. I believe it was a mutant NT but it was actually very very stable. However, nothing beats Linux especially these days with all the choices of GUI's available. Ubuntu being my favourite.
 
  • Like
Likes jim hardy
  • #85
fluidistic said:
"Good news", they fixed my laptop. Though they didn't tell me what they've done. I notice that it doesn't have uefi support anymore. It seems to have the same specs as before, so I won't complain.
I've installed linux as only OS for the first time in my life.
Never Windows again.
So - an obvious bug in the firmware of your laptop ("I notice that it doesn't have uefi support anymore") made you decide to stay away from Windows?
 
  • #86
jim hardy said:
well i tried to download Ubuntu with something named Rufus,
it said plug in a 32gigabyte all i had was a 16 so of course it didnt go

will be back for advice
Check out https://distrowatch.com/. There are a ton of Linux distributions that do not require that much space. Observe that Linux Mint is on the top of the "popular" list.
 
  • #87
Svein said:
So - an obvious bug in the firmware of your laptop ("I notice that it doesn't have uefi support anymore") made you decide to stay away from Windows?
Not really. When it worked, I had a triple dual boot windows 10 and 2 other linux distros, in uefi mode. Now I cannot install Linux in uefi mode and some command of efibootmgr (if I remember well) tells me my computer does not support uefi. So I don't know how they fixed the hardware but it seems they removed uefi mode (I don't see any switch in the BIOS about uefi alghouth I see "uefi" as possible 1st option to boot from). Maybe they installed a new firmware, I have no idea. The options in the BIOS are slightly different than what they used to be, I believe.
The guy in the store doesn't know the details either because he just sent the computer to another place, so he didn't tell me anything about what they've done to fix it. And it took them more than 2 months...
The thing is that I got my degree and right now I am not forced anymore to use any Windows-only software. As that OS broke my laptop, I have decided to stay away from it. I have 0 reason to use Windows.
 
  • #88
Svein said:
Check out https://distrowatch.com/. There are a ton of Linux distributions that do not require that much space. Observe that Linux Mint is on the top of the "popular" list.
Distrowatch is nice to get an idea about different linux distros but the rankings are not representative at all about the number of people using the distros. For example, everybody knows Ubuntu is more popular than Mint. Everybody knows Arch is way more popular than Manjaro (which is based on Arch). Just check the activity in their forums and IRC channels. It is much more reliable (albeit not entirely of course) than what distrowatch displays.
 
  • #89
Heinlein quotes (http://www.aeriagloris.com/Resources/quotes/heinleinquotes.htm):

If "everybody knows" such-and-such, then it ain't so, by at least ten thousand to one.
-Lazarus Long

The phrase "we (I) (you) simply must --" designates something that need not be done. "That goes without saying" is a red warning. "Of course" means you had best check it yourself. These small-change cliches and others like them, when read correctly, are reliable channel markers.
-Lazarus Long

Be wary of strong drink. It can make you shoot at tax collectors -- and miss.
-Lazarus Long
 
  • Like
Likes jim hardy
  • #90
https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/2t5us7/why_is_there_such_a_huge_difference_between_the/

From distrowatch itself:
The Almighty Distrowatch said:
The DistroWatch Page Hit Ranking statistics are a light-hearted way of measuring the popularity of Linux distributions and other free operating systems among the visitors of this website. They correlate neither to usage nor to quality and should not be used to measure the market share of distributions. They simply show the number of times a distribution page on DistroWatch.com was accessed each day, nothing more.
. I would not pay any attention that Mint is on the top. It is not the most popular distro. What I would pay attention to, are the names of the distros and I'd google them to see if they could suit me.
 
  • #91
Well Rufus has been formatting that USB stick for 24 hours now and reports 77% .

It is discouraging fiddling with pc's hardly anything works as described
 
  • #92
jim hardy said:
Well Rufus has been formatting that USB stick for 24 hours now and reports 77% .

It is discouraging fiddling with pc's hardly anything works as described
If it takes more than a few minutes, something is very wrong. Hmm I don't see why it would need to format the USB stick.
Did you follow these steps? http://www.ubuntu.com/download/desktop/create-a-usb-stick-on-windows ?
Anyway, it would be better if you started a new thread in case you're having problems putting the ISO onto the USB stick. You'd get better help.
 
  • #93
fluidistic said:
I thought i had. Downloaded and ran Rufus
it said "Scan the USB (forget exact noun)

so i scanned it and it reported zero errors
then i clicked 'make a bootable disk' because that's what i though was the objective and it's been formatting ever since, at 81% doing 2% per hour.
About 27 hours so far. First few % went quickly.

will start new thread later today.
 
  • Like
Likes fluidistic
  • #94
Bystander said:
I have been "assimilated."
... and to top it all off? It appears to have given the damned thing narcolepsy ... it goes to sleep in the middle of anything requiring more than a couple minutes typing.
 
  • #95
Svein said:
Check out https://distrowatch.com/. There are a ton of Linux distributions that do not require that much space. Observe that Linux Mint is on the top of the "popular" list.
OK, you're trying to put an Ubuntu on a USB stick so you need Rufus or the like. I don't know why this is because when you DL the CD/DVD version it's easy as pie. I did the Rufus thing once as well and had trouble. I got my 23 year old son to show me (when did he get better than me?) and the next time I loaded Ubuntu to a USB it worked OK. I can't remember what I screwed up the first time but it is very unforgiving if you don't do it perfectly the first time. You'll need to reformat the USB if you screwed Rufus up and need to do it again. Don't know if that will help but it is more complicated with a USB boot.
 
  • #96
@Svein ,@jim mcnamara , @ anybody who's done it ---

so if i go to Linux Mint
can i put all my saved pdf's and pictures on a USB stick and reload them ? Will Mint recognize them ?
Is there a "Paint" clone for Cinnamon ?
I see there's a Firefox for Linux

It'll be a lot of work i have tons of Fukushima stuff
I would buy a new hard drive for Linux if it can read files on the other two in this machine rather than wipe them.
??

old jim
 
  • #97
jim hardy said:
so if i go to Linux Mint
can i put all my saved pdf's and pictures on a USB stick and reload them ? Will Mint recognize them ?
I am fairly sure that you can mount a USB stick in Mint. I am also sure that Acrobat (.pdf) readers exist in the Linux world.
jim hardy said:
It'll be a lot of work i have tons of Fukushima stuff
I would buy a new hard drive for Linux if it can read files on the other two in this machine rather than wipe them.
It should be possible, see https://community.linuxmint.com/software/view/ntfs-config.
 
  • #98
5/21/18/: Just got a notification of an "update" that may require "extra" time to download and install; I chose "remind me later." Heads up.
 
  • #99
Time to try stuffing a Raspberry Pi into a junkshop Imac G4 for that retro look.
R2D2 anyone?

NeverTRustaComputer.jpg


old jim
 

Attachments

  • NeverTRustaComputer.jpg
    NeverTRustaComputer.jpg
    8.8 KB · Views: 404
  • #100
Bystander said:
"extra"
Hour and thirty for a four year old Toshiba C55-A.
 
Back
Top