
#1
Feb1207, 07:07 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
PF Gold
P: 4,768

My topology teacher appears to call a monoid a set with an associative binary operation, but with no identity element. According to wiki, this is the definition of a semigroup, although they remark that some authors define semigroups as having an identity (i.e. synonymously to monoid). But they don't say on the monoid article that some authors take monoid to mean an associative magma(groupoid) with no identity.
So, does my teacher simply has the definitions mixed up or do some authors effectively call 'monoid' an associative magma(groupoid)? I wanted to ask here before throwing the "Sir professor, according to wikipedia, you're wrong" at him. I'm sure that's understandable. 



#2
Feb1307, 12:26 AM

P: 11

IMOH, arguments over terminology are politically dangerous, only attempt this if you are on good terms with your professor, or want to start a fight.
In my experience, semigroup means associative binary operation, and monoid means associative binary operation with identity element. Wolfram's mathworld agrees: http://mathworld.wolfram.com/Monoid.html, I usually trust Wolfram for ORTHODOX definitions, wikipedia is good at bringing in side issues and lesser known usage (ok, that's my subjective opinion). 



#3
Feb1307, 12:33 AM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 2,020

Yeah, I wouldn't recommend telling him he's "wrong", but you might want to tell him that you've seen it mean something else in (many) other standard references. Like, for example, in Rotman's Theory of Groups.




#4
Feb1307, 03:37 AM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 9,398

semigroups and monoids
You could tell him. Though he's likely to be unimpressed that you used Wiki as a source, and even less impressed that you're worrying about this than actually learning the course.
It's just a name, and mostly unimportant. It is the definition that is important. Ok, it might cause you some confusion when looking in other textbooks. 



#5
Feb1307, 05:59 AM

P: 406




Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
More algebra...MONOIDS, etc  Calculus & Beyond Homework  10  
couple questions involving monoids/isomorphisms  Calculus & Beyond Homework  8  
centers of groups and products of groups  Calculus & Beyond Homework  1  
Wallpaper Groups, Free Groups, and Trees  Introductory Physics Homework  13  
references on monoids and applications?  General Math  0 