Register to reply 
Spivak Calc on Manifolds, p.85 
Share this thread: 
#1
Jan1208, 10:30 AM

P: 491

Please forgive any stupid mistakes I've made.
On p.85, 45: If [tex]c: [0,1] \rightarrow (R^n)^n [/tex] is continous and each [tex](c^1(t),c^2(t),...,c^n(t)) [/tex] is a basis for [tex] R^n [/tex], prove that [tex]c^1(0),...,c^n(0) = c^1(1),...,c^n(1) [/tex]. Maybe I'm missing something obvious, but doesn't [tex] c(t) = ((1+t,0),(0,1+t)) [/tex] provide a counterexample to the statement when n=2? 


#2
Jan1208, 12:33 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 9,453

have you read the section preceding the problem, specifically the definition of the notation [v1,...vn]? the bracket notation refers to the orientation defined by the basis. so the problem is to prove that a continuously varying basis cannot change orientation. this is easy since the determinant cannot change sign without being zero in between.
you have misrepresented the bracket notation as absolute value, at least according to my copy of spivak. 


#3
Jan1208, 01:00 PM

P: 491

I see. I have a (poor) photocopy of this section, and I can't distinguish between absolute value and the brackets you mentioned. Thank you for clarifying.



#4
Jan1308, 09:50 AM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 9,453

Spivak Calc on Manifolds, p.85
i suggest you buy one. then the author makes a few bucks, or maybe a nickel, i believe he told me once.



#5
Jan1408, 06:22 PM

P: 206

Spivak most definitely deserves some of your money. Possibly most of it.



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Apostol or Spivak?  Science & Math Textbooks  24  
Spivak volume 2  Differential Geometry  1  
Spivak calculus on manifolds solutions? (someone asked this b4 and got ignored)  Differential Geometry  6  
Spivak on 1cubes  Calculus  0  
Supplement to spivak's calc on manifolds  Calculus  4 