Register to reply 
Prove Orthogonality Condition For Sines (Integral) 
Share this thread: 
#1
Oct510, 02:28 PM

P: 261

1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data
I need to prove the equation attached. I also have to describe why the integrals vanish. 2. Relevant equations 3. The attempt at a solution I am not sure how to begin. Our teacher told us this equation is known as the orthogonality condition for sines. I also know that n' is a positive integer. I think if I get help starting this I will be able to proceed. 


#3
Oct510, 05:29 PM

P: 261

I worked through the integral, but I kept getting zero for all cases. I have attached my work. Any help is appreciated.



#4
Oct510, 09:11 PM

P: 849

Prove Orthogonality Condition For Sines (Integral)
If n=n' you simply have sine squared blah blah... If you integrate it, you will not get zero. This can be intuitively seen from the fact that the graph of sine squared is strictly greater than or equal zero.
If you keep getting zero then something is wrong. 


#5
Oct510, 09:12 PM

P: 261

Right I understand that completely. I just can't seem to find my mistake. I went over it several times



#6
Oct510, 09:19 PM

P: 849

For the case n=n' don't convert the product to a sum. Just integrate sine square whatever by using the half angle identity for cosine.
EDIT Double angle not half angle. 


#7
Oct510, 09:21 PM

P: 261

But in order to prove that, don't I have to integrate regardless? I feel like it's not the right way to do it if I use the idea of n=n' beforehand.



#8
Oct510, 09:27 PM

P: 849

What you have done ,thus far, is valid when n'=/=n. If you look at your solution, when you converted the product to a sum if you let n=n' one of the cosine terms vanish before you integrate. You cannot just plug in n=n' into your final solution because of division by zero :). Those constants you have in the final step or your solution become infinity when n=n'. So you have to consider the cases separatly. 


#9
Oct510, 09:41 PM

P: 261

Hmm I see what you are saying. Well I suppose I will ask the professor if this method is acceptable, and let you know tomorrow. Thanks.



#11
Oct510, 09:51 PM

P: 261

It just kind of seems to me that the teacher phrased the question in a way such that he wants us to completely simplify the left hand side of the equation before we use any of the knowledge on the left. I hope that makes sense in the way I explained it.



#12
Oct510, 09:59 PM

P: 849

That is what we are doing.
The only thing is that if n=n' the method you are using won't work directly. The reason is what I already pointed out. In your result of your integration you have a 1/(blah(nn')). If you make n=n' you have a problem with dividing by zero. This is why we have to consider different cases. 


#13
Oct510, 10:00 PM

P: 261

Ohhhh I think I see what you are saying now. Ok I will work on it and post what I have done either tonight or tomorrow. Thanks.



#15
Oct710, 10:24 AM

P: 261

Got it now. Thanks.



#16
Feb311, 09:50 AM

P: 7

aargghh why haven't you posted the solution
EDIT: nevermind, I found it here: http://www.mathreference.com/laxffour,orth.html and I'm copying it below for reference: Consider two functions f = sin(mx) and g = sin(nx). Here m and n are distinct positive integers. What is the integral of f×g, as x runs from 0 to 2π? Use the angle addition formula to write the following trig identity. sin(mx)×sin(nx) = ˝ ( cos(mxnx)  cos(mx+nx) ) Integrate the right side from 0 to 2π and get 0. Here are two more identities to demonstrate the orthogonality of cos(mx)×cos(nx) and sin(mx)×cos(nx). cos(mx)×cos(nx) = ˝ ( cos(mxnx) + cos(mx+nx) ) sin(mx)×cos(nx) = ˝ ( sin(mx+nx) + sin(mxnx) ) 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Legendre Polynomial Orthogonality Integral Limits  Calculus & Beyond Homework  0  
Transversality Condition with right end point free, subject to integral constraints  Calculus  1  
Prove Equality given a condition  Precalculus Mathematics Homework  7  
Integral of exponential involving sines and cosines  Calculus  1  
Prove this integral  General Math  4 