Thread Closed

Limit - which result is correct?

 
Share Thread Thread Tools
Jan15-05, 12:07 PM   #1
 

Limit - which result is correct?


Hi all,

I've been practising for the exam and did some limits from our master's collections:

[tex]
\lim_{x \rightarrow \frac{\pi}{3}} \frac{\tan^{3} x - 3\tan x}{\cos \left( x + \frac{\pi}{6} \right) }
[/tex]

I got the result -24, but there is written -12. Which one is correct? I tried to prove the result in Maple and Mathematica, but in neither I'm not able to get anything but symbolic result.

Thank you.
PhysOrg.com
PhysOrg
science news on PhysOrg.com

>> Bird's playlist could signal mental strengths and weaknesses
>> Minus environment, patterns still emerge: Computational study tracks E. coli cells' regulatory mechanisms
>> Bacterium uses natural 'thermometer' to trigger diarrheal disease, scientists find
Jan15-05, 12:18 PM   #2
 
Blog Entries: 9
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Help
Science Advisor Science Advisor
HINT:Bring your function to anither form,so that the limit can be put under the "conventional" form "->0".That requires a change of variable.

Daniel.

P.S.Can as in do you know how to apply L'Hôspital's rule??
Jan15-05, 12:34 PM   #3
 
Ok, so now I put the "L'Hospitaled" function to the Maple and it still gives me symbolic result...
Jan15-05, 01:31 PM   #4
 
Blog Entries: 9
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Help
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Question

Limit - which result is correct?


Can Maple compute limits??Can u compute derivatives??CAN U BOTH SOLVE THIS SIMPLE PROBLEM?????

Daniel.
Jan15-05, 03:29 PM   #5

Homework Helper 2012
 
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Help
Quote by twoflower
I got the result -24, but there is written -12. Which one is correct?
Your result is correct.

Just try to choose some value for x close enough to pi/3 and calculate the replacement value. You will see that it is far away from -12.

ehild
Jan15-05, 03:45 PM   #6
 
Quote by dextercioby
Can Maple compute limits??Can u compute derivatives??CAN U BOTH SOLVE THIS SIMPLE PROBLEM?????

Daniel.
I don't understand. Using L'Hospital I got the result I wrote here. But the "official" result is different to mine. I was just asking how to prove it in Maple.
Jan15-05, 05:20 PM   #7
 
Recognitions:
Gold Membership Gold Member
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Retired Staff Staff Emeritus
The point was: Why use MAPLE?? You can't PROVE the MAPLE calculation is correct by using MAPLE!
It's easy to calculate that the derivative of
tan3(x)- 3tan(x) is 3tan(x)sec2(x)- 3sec2(x) and certainly you should know that [itex]tan(\frac{\pi}{3})= \sqrt{3}[/itex] and that [itex]sec(\frac{\pi}{3}})= 2[/itex]. Of course, the derivative of [itex]cos(x+\frac{\pi}{6}[/itex] is [itex]-sin(x+\frac{\pi}{6})[/itex] and [itex]-sin(\frac{\pi}{2}})= -1[/itex].

The limit, by L'Hopital, is (3*3*4- 3(22)/-1= -(36-12)= -24.
Jan16-05, 01:39 AM   #8
 
Quote by HallsofIvy
The point was: Why use MAPLE?? You can't PROVE the MAPLE calculation is correct by using MAPLE!
I didn't want to prove the MAPLE calculation, I was trying to prove the teacher's calculation...
Jan16-05, 12:41 PM   #9
 
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Help
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Quote by HallsofIvy
The point was: Why use MAPLE?? You can't PROVE the MAPLE calculation is correct by using MAPLE!
It's easy to calculate that the derivative of
tan3(x)- 3tan(x) is 3tan(x)sec2(x)- 3sec2(x) and certainly you should know that [itex]tan(\frac{\pi}{3})= \sqrt{3}[/itex] and that [itex]sec(\frac{\pi}{3}})= 2[/itex]. Of course, the derivative of [itex]cos(x+\frac{\pi}{6}[/itex] is [itex]-sin(x+\frac{\pi}{6})[/itex] and [itex]-sin(\frac{\pi}{2}})= -1[/itex].

The limit, by L'Hopital, is (3*3*4- 3(22)/-1= -(36-12)= -24.
That's indeed correct (notice that there's a typo, it should obviously be

"It's easy to calculate that the derivative of
tan3(x)- 3tan(x) is 3tan2(x)sec2(x)- 3sec2(x)"

i.e. there is a square in the first tan in the derivative but it's obviously a typo because HallsofIvy gave the correct numerical answer.

Just a thought: if someone forgets to square the sec(x), they will get -12. So that could be the origin of the incorrect answer -12.

Pat
Jan16-05, 04:39 PM   #10

Homework Helper 2012
 
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Help
The limit can be obtained even without L'Hopital's rule.

[tex]
\lim_{x \rightarrow \frac{\pi}{3}} \frac{\tan^{3} x - 3\tan x}{\cos \left( x + \frac{\pi}{6} \right) }=
\lim_{x \rightarrow \frac{\pi}{3}} \frac{\tan(x)(\tan^{2} x - 3)}{\cos ( x )\cos (\pi/6)-\sin(x)\sin(\pi/6)}=[/tex]

[tex]\lim_{x \rightarrow
\frac{\pi}{3}}\frac{\tan(x)(tan(x)-\sqrt(3))(\tan(x)+\sqrt(3))}{1/2\cos(x)(\sqrt(3)-\tan(x))}=
\lim_{x \rightarrow \frac{\pi}{3}}\frac{-2\tan(x)(\tan(x)+\sqrt(3))}{\cos(x)}=\frac{-2\sqrt(3)(2\sqrt(3)}{1/2}=-24
[/tex]

ehild
Jan16-05, 04:59 PM   #11
 
Quote by ehild
The limit can be obtained even without L'Hopital's rule.
ehild
Nice ehild, I thought this is one of the limits which can't be solved without L'Hospital's rule...Thank you.
Thread Closed
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: Limit - which result is correct?
Thread Forum Replies
Limit problem - Correct? Calculus & Beyond Homework 4
Multivariable Limit, is my reasoning correct? Calculus & Beyond Homework 2
why is the limit 2025? a simple plug and chug limit! gone wrong! Calculus & Beyond Homework 3
time dilation(correct/not correct) Introductory Physics Homework 1
How to prove a limit is correct Calculus 10