Change in total kinetic energy in a conservation of momentum problem?by erikthered Tags: conservation, energy, kinetic, momentum 

#1
Oct705, 09:30 AM

P: 89

Question:
On a frictionless, horizontal air table, puck A (with mass [tex]m_1[/tex]) is moving toward puck B (with mass [tex]m_2[/tex]), that is initially at rest. After the collision, puck A has a velocity of [tex]v_1[/tex] to the left, and puck B has velocity [tex]v_2[/tex] to the right. 1. What was the speed of puck A before the collision? My answer to this part of the question was correct. It is [tex](m_2*v_2)/(m_1)  (v_1)[/tex]. 2. Calculate the change in the total kinetic energy of the system that occurs during the collision. I think this depends on the first part of the question. So, I'm thinking: [tex]\Delta K= K_f  K_i[/tex] [tex](1/2)(m)(v_f^2  v_i^2)[/tex] I should sum up the velocities, right? [tex](1/2)(m_1+m_2)((v_2  v_1)^2  ((m_2*v_2)/(m_1)  (v_1))^2)[/tex] But, that is not correct. 



#2
Oct705, 09:42 AM

HW Helper
P: 661

I'm not very clear with what was meant by your last equation. In anycase, you basically do:
Change in kinetic energy = Kinetic energy of puckA before collision  Kinetic energy of puckA after collision  kinetic energy of puckB after collision. KE is a function of only mass and velocity. Since all are known, carefully plugging in the numbers should do the trick. 



#3
Oct705, 10:07 AM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 1,322

erikthered,
When calculating kinetic energy, you first square the velocity of each particle, multiply by the particles mass divided by two and then add. You have added the final velocities first and then squared and this is wrong. 



#4
Oct705, 12:24 PM

P: 89

Change in total kinetic energy in a conservation of momentum problem?
I inputed [tex](1/2)(m_1)((m_2*v_2)/(m_1)  (v_1))^2  (1/2)(m_1)(v_1)^2  (1/2)(m_2)(v_2)^2[/tex] and it was incorrect.
My understanding of change in total kinetic energy, [tex]\Delta K[/tex], is the difference between the final and initial kinetic energies. Physics Monkey, you told me to add. Why is this so? 



#5
Oct705, 12:32 PM

Mentor
P: 40,907

[itex]\Delta K = K_f  K_i[/itex], not [itex]K_i  K_f[/itex].




#6
Oct705, 12:33 PM

Admin
P: 21,637

Try applying conservation of momentum and kinetic energy.
Consider the momentum of the masses to left and right. Remember momentum is proportional to velocity, so it is a vector quantity. Energy is a scalar. 



#7
Oct705, 02:58 PM

HW Helper
P: 661

From the looks of it, the problem now isn't with the physics, but rather the math. Try cleaning it up, do things step by step and plug in the numbers. Like what Physics Monkey said, you are doing some incorrect operations by trying to rush the calculation. One by one,
[tex]KE_1 = \frac{1}{2}m_1v_1^2[/tex] 



#8
Oct1005, 07:56 PM

P: 89

It looks like I definitely did [tex]K_i  K_f[/tex], which obviously is not correct.
So, I decided to analyze [tex]K_f[/tex] first. I got [tex]K_f = (1/2)(m_1)(v_1)^2 + (1/2)(m_2)(v_2)^2[/tex]. Then, I decided to analzye [tex]K_i[/tex]. I got [tex]K_i = (1/2)(m_1)((m_2*v_2)/(m_1)  v_1)[/tex] This simplifies to [tex](1/2)(m_2*v_2  m_1*v_1)[/tex]. I took the difference [tex]K_f  K_i = (1/2)(m_1)(v_1)^2 + (1/2)(m_2)(v_2)^2  (1/2)(m_2*v_2  m_1*v_1)[/tex] and it was not correct. I really think I did everything right this time. ? 



#9
Oct1005, 08:02 PM

Mentor
P: 40,907





#10
Oct1005, 08:15 PM

P: 89

Thanks so much, Doc Al. I wanted to simplify my answer, but I forgot that it's [tex]v^2[/tex].



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
conservation of momentum vs conservation of kinetic energy  Introductory Physics Homework  18  
looking for deltaK, change in total kinetic energy  Introductory Physics Homework  5  
Conservation of Momentum and Dissipation of Kinetic Energy  AP Problem  Introductory Physics Homework  13  
"Simple" part of a hard problem involving momentum/kinetic energy conservation  Introductory Physics Homework  3  
Change of momentum and kinetic energy  Introductory Physics Homework  4 