What is Lagrangian: Definition and 1000 Discussions

Introduced by the Italian-French mathematician and astronomer Joseph-Louis Lagrange in 1788, Lagrangian mechanics is a formulation of classical mechanics and is founded on the stationary action principle.
Lagrangian mechanics defines a mechanical system to be a pair



(
M
,
L
)


{\displaystyle (M,L)}
of a configuration space



M


{\displaystyle M}
and a smooth function



L
=
L
(
q
,
v
,
t
)


{\displaystyle L=L(q,v,t)}
called Lagrangian. By convention,



L
=
T

V
,


{\displaystyle L=T-V,}
where



T


{\displaystyle T}
and



V


{\displaystyle V}
are the kinetic and potential energy of the system, respectively. Here



q

M
,


{\displaystyle q\in M,}
and



v


{\displaystyle v}
is the velocity vector at



q


{\displaystyle q}




(
v


{\displaystyle (v}
is tangential to



M
)
.


{\displaystyle M).}
(For those familiar with tangent bundles,



L
:
T
M
×


R


t




R

,


{\displaystyle L:TM\times \mathbb {R} _{t}\to \mathbb {R} ,}
and



v


T

q


M
)
.


{\displaystyle v\in T_{q}M).}

Given the time instants




t

1




{\displaystyle t_{1}}
and




t

2


,


{\displaystyle t_{2},}
Lagrangian mechanics postulates that a smooth path




x

0


:
[

t

1


,

t

2


]

M


{\displaystyle x_{0}:[t_{1},t_{2}]\to M}
describes the time evolution of the given system if and only if




x

0




{\displaystyle x_{0}}
is a stationary point of the action functional






S


[
x
]





=


def









t

1





t

2




L
(
x
(
t
)
,



x
˙



(
t
)
,
t
)

d
t
.


{\displaystyle {\cal {S}}[x]\,{\stackrel {\text{def}}{=}}\,\int _{t_{1}}^{t_{2}}L(x(t),{\dot {x}}(t),t)\,dt.}
If



M


{\displaystyle M}
is an open subset of





R


n




{\displaystyle \mathbb {R} ^{n}}
and




t

1


,


{\displaystyle t_{1},}





t

2




{\displaystyle t_{2}}
are finite, then the smooth path




x

0




{\displaystyle x_{0}}
is a stationary point of





S




{\displaystyle {\cal {S}}}
if all its directional derivatives at




x

0




{\displaystyle x_{0}}
vanish, i.e., for every smooth



δ
:
[

t

1


,

t

2


]



R


n


,


{\displaystyle \delta :[t_{1},t_{2}]\to \mathbb {R} ^{n},}





δ


S







=


def







d

d
ε






|



ε
=
0




S



[


x

0


+
ε
δ

]

=
0.


{\displaystyle \delta {\cal {S}}\ {\stackrel {\text{def}}{=}}\ {\frac {d}{d\varepsilon }}{\Biggl |}_{\varepsilon =0}{\cal {S}}\left[x_{0}+\varepsilon \delta \right]=0.}
The function



δ
(
t
)


{\displaystyle \delta (t)}
on the right-hand side is called perturbation or virtual displacement. The directional derivative



δ


S




{\displaystyle \delta {\cal {S}}}
on the left is known as variation in physics and Gateaux derivative in Mathematics.
Lagrangian mechanics has been extended to allow for non-conservative forces.

View More On Wikipedia.org
  1. shounakbhatta

    Is the Lagrangian Invariant Under Coordinate Transformations?

    Can you please tell me whether I am right or wrong? Lagrangians are scalars. They are NOT invariant under coordinate transformations[ the simplest example is when you have a gravitational potential(V=mgz) and you translate z by "a"(some number)...
  2. D

    Electromagnetic Lagrangian

    If you don't have any charges or currents, the electromagnetic Lagrangian becomes ##\mathcal{L}=-\frac{1}{4}F_{\alpha\beta}F^{\alpha\beta}##. The standard way to derive Maxwell's equations in free space is to replace ##F_{\alpha\beta}## by ##\partial_\alpha A_\beta -\partial_\beta A_\alpha## and...
  3. binbagsss

    What is the significance of the displacement in this system?

    The question is that a mass m of weight mg is attached to a fixed point by a light linear spring of stiffness constant k and natural length a. It is capable of oscillating in a vertical planne. Let θ be the angle of the pendulum wrt to the vertical direction, and r the distance between the mass...
  4. D

    Lagrangian density for continuous distribution of matter

    The Lagrangian for a point particle is just L=-m\sqrt{1-v^2}. If instead we had a continuous distribution of matter, what would its Lagrangian density be? I feel that this should be very easy to figure out, but I can't get a scalar Lagrangian density that reduces to the particle Lagrangian in...
  5. M

    Lagrangian Mechanics - Non Commutativity rule

    Hi there, I am reading about Lagrangian mechanics. At some point the difference between the temporal derivative of a variation and variation of the temporal derivative is discussed. The fact that the two are the same is presented in the book I am reading as a rule, commutativity, and...
  6. D

    Solving Lagrangian Derivation - Classical Mechanics by John R. Taylor

    I have been reading Lagrangian from Classical Mechanics by John R. Taylor. I have adoubt in a derivation which invloves differential calculus. I have attached snapshot of the equation , can someone please explain. Here y,η are functions of x but α is s acosntant. Please let me know if I...
  7. N

    What is the Lagrangian of interaction of photon and spin zero scalar?

    What is the Lagrangian of interaction of photon and spin zero charge scalar?The vertex of photon and spin 1/2 charge fermion is proportional with e multiplied vertor gamma matrix,but I do not know what is the vertex of photon and charge scalar.I hear that a vertex is proportional with polynomial...
  8. M

    Stress-Energy Tensor from Lagrangian: Technical Question II

    This thread is supposed to be a continuation of the discussion of this thread: (1) https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=88570. The previous thread was closed but there was a lot of things I did not understand. This is also somewhat related to a recent thread I created: (2)...
  9. J

    Adding a total derivative to the Lagrangian

    I recently posted another thread on the General Physics sub forum, but didn't get as much feedback as I was hoping for, regarding this issue. Let's say I have two Lagrangians: $$ \mathcal{L}_1 = -\frac{1}{2}(\partial_\mu A_\nu)(\partial^\mu A^\nu) + \frac{1}{2}(\partial_\mu A^\mu)^2 $$ $$...
  10. J

    Calculating derivatives of a Lagrangian density

    Hey everyone, I wasn't really sure where to post this, since it's kind of classical, kind of relativistic and kind of quantum field theoretical, but essentially mathematical. I'm reading and watching the lectures on Quantum Field Theory by Cambridge's David Tong (which you can find here), and...
  11. AJKing

    Lagrangian and its derivatives

    Question 1 When I take the derivatives of the Lagrangian, specifically of the form: \frac{\partial L}{ \partial q} I often find myself saying this: \frac{\partial \dot{q}}{ \partial q}=0 But why is it true? And is it always true?
  12. shounakbhatta

    Lagrangian and quantum field theory

    Hello, I understand the classical Lagrangian which follows the Principle of Least Action(A) A=∫L dt But what is Lagrangian density? Is it a new concept? A=∫Lagrangian density dx^4 Here 4 is the four vector? One time-like and 3 space-like co-ordinates? QFT uses Lagrangian to...
  13. L

    Typical Lagrangian Problem

    Homework Statement A Particle of mass m is threaded on a frictionless rod that rotates at a fixed angular frequency Ω about a vertical axis. A spring with rest length Xo and spring constant k has one of it's ends attached to the mass and the other to the axis of rotation. Let x be the length...
  14. M

    Calculating energy from the Lagrangian

    Homework Statement While doing a problem I have found the Lagrangian to be L=\frac{1}{2}m \dot{r}^2 \left( 1 + 4a^2r^2 \right) + \frac{1}{2}mr^2 \dot{\theta}^2 -mgar^2. I have also shown that the angular momentum l is constant and is equal to l=mr^2 \dot{\theta}. I want to calculate the energy...
  15. H

    Solve Lagrangian Homework: Bead on Rotating Bicycle Wheel

    Homework Statement Consider a bead of mass m moving on a spoke of a rotating bicycle wheel. If there are no forces other than the constraint forces, then find the Lagrangian and the equation of motion in generalised coordinates. What is the possible solution of this motion?Homework Equations...
  16. S

    Derive Equation of motion using Lagrangian density?

    Homework Statement [/b] The attempt at a solution[/b] I have done the first bit but don't know how to show that phi(r,t) is a solution to the equation of motion.
  17. L

    Simple Lagrangian for constrained motion - please give your input

    Hello fellow PF members I was wondering how one would go about finding the lagrangian of a problem like the following: A particle is constrained to move along the a path defined by y = sin(x). Would you simply do this: x = x y = sin(x) x'^2 = x'^2 y'^2 = x'^2 (cos(x))^2...
  18. shounakbhatta

    Lagrangian and degrees of freedom

    Hello, I have a very basic question: Degrees of freedom for a particle describes the formal state of a physical system. Like a particle in 3 dimension space has 3 co-ordinates and if it moves in 3 velocity components, then it has 6 degrees of freedom. Lagrangian also measures this, right?
  19. D

    Inclined plane with atypical axes/ Lagrangian

    Homework Statement I'm asked to solve the typical intro level box on an inclined plane problem but I need to do it using the lagrangian. My difficulty with it is that the axis I am required to use are not the typical axes used when solving this using Newtonian mechanics. Instead of the...
  20. S

    Why is the Lagrangian density for fields treated as a functional in QFT?

    This is probably a minor point, but I have seen in some QFT texts the Euler-Lagrange equation for a scalar field, \partial_{\mu} \left(\frac{\delta \cal{L}}{\delta (\partial_{\mu}\phi)}\right) - \frac{\delta \cal L}{\delta \phi }=0 i.e. \cal L is treated like a functional (seen from the...
  21. D

    Lagrangian where time is a dependent coordinate

    Homework Statement I don't know why I'm having trouble here, but I want to show that, if we let t = t(\theta) and q(t(\theta)) = q(\theta) so that both are now dependent coordinates on the parameter \theta , then L_{\theta}(q,q',t,t',\theta) = t'L(q,q'/t',t) where t' =...
  22. J

    Lagrangian in cartesian and polar

    Homework Statement Consider the following Lagrangian in Cartesian coordinates: L(x, y, x', y') = 12 (x^ 2 + y^2) -sqrt(x^2 + y^2) (a) Write the Lagrange equations of motion, and show that x = cos(t); y =sin(t) is a solution. (b) Changing from Cartesian to polar coordinates, x = r...
  23. M

    Can we treat non-conservative forces in the Lagrangian formulation?

    In Lagrangian mechanics, the Euler-Lagrange equations take the form $$\frac{\partial L}{\partial x} = \frac{\mathbb{d}}{\mathbb{d}t}\frac{\partial L}{\partial \dot{x}}$$ From this, we can define the left side of the equation as force, and by carrying out the actual derivative, we get $$F =...
  24. I

    Why is the Kinetic Energy Equation Different in Polar Coordinates?

    a particle of mass m is attracted to a center force with the force of magnitude k/r^2. use plan polar coordinates and find the Lagranian equation of motion. so i thought for the kinetic energy it would be.. K=\frac{1}{2}m(r2\dot{θ}2) since v2 = r2\dot{θ}2 but no.. the kinetic energy...
  25. I

    How to Find ∂L/∂q: A Simple Guide for Calculating Lagrangian Equations

    hi, silly question but would someone please show me how \frac{∂L}{∂q}=\dot{p}? L being the lagrangian, p being the momentum, and q being the general coordinate.
  26. P

    Penalty and Lagrangian methods

    Hi Can somebody please explain fundamentally what is the difference between these two methods of modelling contact interfaces? I would prefer a more qualitative explanation (physics concept based ) rather than a more mathematical description.
  27. C

    Bead sliding on a rotating rod Lagrangian

    Homework Statement A bead of mass m slides under gravity on a smooth rod of length l which is inclined at a constant angle ##\alpha## to the downward vertical and made to rotate at angular velocity ##\omega## about a vertical axis. The displacement of the bead along the rod is r(t)...
  28. W

    Fierz Identity Substitution Into QED Lagrangian

    Hi all, I've been playing around with spin 1/2 Lagrangians, and found the very interesting Fierz identities. In particular for the S x S product, (\bar{\chi}\psi)(\bar{\psi}\chi)=\frac{1}{4}(\bar{\chi} \chi)(\bar{\psi} \psi)+\frac{1}{4}(\bar{\chi}\gamma^{\mu}\chi)(\bar{\psi}\gamma_{\mu}...
  29. B

    Lagrangian, Hamiltonian coordinates

    Dear All, To give a background about myself in Classical Mechanics, I know to solve problems using Newton's laws, momentum principle, etc. I din't have a exposure to Lagrangian and Hamiltonian until recently. So I tried to read about it and I found that I was pretty weak in coordinate...
  30. D

    Lagrangian Mechanics, bead on a hoop

    Homework Statement This is the problem: http://i.imgur.com/OJyzfhz.png?1 Homework Equations $$\frac{dL}{dq_i}-\frac{d}{dt}\frac{dL}{d\dot{q_i}}=0$$ $$ L=\frac{1}{2}mv^2-U(potential energy)$$ The Attempt at a Solution This is my attempt at question A): http://i.imgur.com/IeJVGm3.jpgDoes...
  31. Z

    Euler-Lagrange equation on Lagrangian in generalized coordinates

    Homework Statement I need some help understanding a derivation in a textbook. It involves the Lagrangian in generalized coordinates. Homework Equations The text states that generalized coordinates {q_1, ..., q_3N} are related to original Cartesian coordinates q_\alpha = f_\alpha(\mathbf r_1...
  32. S

    What is the Lagrangian Interpolation Formula for Approximating Functions?

    Homework Statement Consider the Lagrange Polynomial approximation p(x) =\sum_{k=0}^n f(x_k)L_k(x) where L_k(x)=\prod_{i=0,i\neq k}^n \frac{x-x_i}{x_k-x_i} Let \psi(x)=\prod_{i=0}^n x-x_i. Show that p(x)=\psi(x) \sum_{k=0}^n\frac{f(x_k)}{(x-x_k)\psi^\prime(x)} Homework Equations None...
  33. K

    Infinitesimal SUSY transformation of SYM lagrangian

    I tried to verify that the SYM lagrangian is invariant under SUSY transformation, but it turned out there is a term that doesn't vanish. The SYM lagrangian is: \mathscr{L}_{SYM}=-\frac{1}{4}F^{a\mu\nu}F^a_{\mu\nu}+i\lambda^{\dagger a}\bar{\sigma}^\mu D_\mu \lambda^a+\frac{1}{2}D^a D^a the...
  34. S

    Zero lagrangian and induced gravitation

    Hello, Does anyone know what "induced gravity" is and where can one read (something not too technical) about it? I am trying to understand how a system with zero Lagrangian has something to do with gravity. Could someone explain perhaps? Thanks
  35. A

    Book for Hamiltonian and Lagrangian mechanics

    I am learning Hamiltonian and Lagrangian mechanics and looking for a book that starts with Newtonian mechanics and then onto Lagrangian & Hamiltonian mechanics. It should have some historical context explaining the need to change the approaches for solving equation of motions. Also it should...
  36. P

    Lagrangian: q and q-dot independence

    Hello! I've read thousand of explanations about how q and q-dot are considered independent in the Lagrangian treatment of mechanics but I just can't get it. I would really appreciate if someone could explain how is this so and (I've seen something about an a-priori independence but I couldn't...
  37. Philosophaie

    Lagrangian for the Kepler Problem

    In a two-body solution ( Kepler Problem) how do you find the Lagrangian, L, if the position vector is: x = (v_x * t + x_0, v_y * t + y_0, v_z * t + z_0) Action from Wikipedia is: S = \int_{t_1}^{t_2} L * dt
  38. C

    Lagrangian explicitly preserves symmetries of a theory?

    How are the Hamiltonian and Lagrangian different as far as preserving symmetries of a theory? Peskin and Schroeder write that the path integral formalism is nice because since it's based on the action and Lagrangian it explicitly preserves all the symmetries, but I'm wondering how/why the...
  39. A

    Lagrangian equation for motion

    A few doubts regarding lagrnagian method to deal with motion of particles: 1) It seems like a heuristic method of solving for motion of a particle. In Newtonian mechanics, you carefully consider all the forces and find out the particle's motion. In this, based on intuition you guess the...
  40. R

    Scalar field lagrangian in curved spacetime

    Homework Statement I am studying inflation theory for a scalar field \phi in curved spacetime. I want to obtain Euler-Lagrange equations for the action: I\left[\phi\right] = \int \left[\frac{1}{2}g^{\mu\nu}\partial_\mu\phi\partial_\nu\phi + V\left(\phi\right) \right]\sqrt{-g} d^4x Homework...
  41. L

    Find the velocity of a particle from the Lagrangian

    Homework Statement Consider the following Lagrangian of a relativistic particle moving in a D-dim space and interacting with a central potential field. $$L=-mc^2 \sqrt{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}} - \frac{\alpha}{r}\exp^{-\beta r}$$ ... Find the velocity v of the particle as a function of p...
  42. P

    Linear Gravity Field - Lagrangian

    Another Exercise... Ohanian Exercise 6 The Euler-Lagrange Equation given: ##\frac{\partial}{\partial x^\mu} \frac{\partial \mathcal{L}}{\partial (\partial_\mu h^{\alpha\beta})} - \frac{\partial \mathcal{L}}{\partial h^{\alpha\beta}} = 0## ##\frac{\partial \mathcal{L}}{\partial...
  43. P

    Electromagnetic Field Lagrangian - Field Equations

    I was working on an exercise in Ohanian's book. [Appendix A3, page 484, Exercise 5] I guess he means charge conservation, but wrote ##j^\nu = 0##. The Lagrangian was given by ##\mathcal{L}_{em} = -\frac{1}{16\pi} \left( A_{\mu ,\nu} - A_{\nu ,\mu} \right) \left( A^{\mu ,\nu} - A^{\nu...
  44. SamRoss

    Why does the Lagrangian have negative potential energy?

    I am watching Susskind's derivation of Newton's F=ma from the Euler-Lagrange equations (53 minutes in) here for which he uses the Lagrangian of kinetic energy minus potential energy. I have seen this done elsewhere as well. As far as I can tell, and please correct me if I'm wrong, the only...
  45. C

    Why is the lagrangian extremized

    I've been reading a lot about path integrals lately, and I've found it fascinating to see at the quantum level how the extremal values of the lagrangian are basically the only ones that contribute when the action is large and therefore we get the classical path. Something that continues to...
  46. S

    Lagrangian with one constraint

    Hello, I have the functional J = ∫ L(ψ, r, r') dψ, where r'=dr/dψ. L is written in polar coordinates (r,ψ). Now I want to constrain the motion to take place on the polar curve r = r(ψ). Can I write the constrained lagrangian as Lc=L(ψ, r, r') - λ(r - r(ψ)) and then solve the...
  47. V

    Lagrangian question - rough ball on moving wedge

    Homework Statement (context: I'm studying for a test, and this is a question from a past exam paper.) "A wedge of mass M with angle \phi is free to slide on a frictionless horizontal table. A solid ball of radius a and mass m is placed on the slope of the wedge. The contact between the ball...
  48. J

    Constrained Lagrangian equetion (barbell)

    Hi! I tried to compute an ideal barbell-shaped object's dynamics, but my results were wrong. My Langrangian is: ## L = \frac{m}{2} ( \dot{x_1}^2 + \dot{x_2}^2 + \dot{y_1}^2 + \dot{y_2}^2 ) - U( x_1 , y_1 ) - U ( x_2 , y_2 ) ## And the constraint is: ## f = ( x_1 - x_2 )^2 + ( y_1 -...
  49. G

    Derivative of Lagrangian with respect to momentum

    I'm trying to figure out when is \frac{\delta L}{\delta p}=\dot{q} . From L=p\frac{\delta H}{\delta p}-H I get that \frac{\delta L}{\delta p}=p\frac{\delta^2 H}{\delta p^2}=p \frac{d}{dp}\dot{q} . For this to equal just \dot{q} , it must obey the dfe \frac{d}{d ln p}\dot{q}=\dot{q}...
  50. lfqm

    QED Interaction Lagrangian with two different fermions

    Let say I want to study electron-proton scattering (without considering proton's quarks, i.e. no QCD), which is the Lagrangian? I've seen two different answers to this question :confused: First one: L=\bar{ψ}e(i∂-me)ψe+\bar{ψ}p(i∂-mp)ψp-\frac{1}{4}Fμ\nuFμ\nu-e\bar{ψ}eγμψeAμ+e\bar{ψ}pγμψpAμ...
Back
Top