- #1
KevinFan
- 47
- 0
For example, NaBr can dissolve in water but will it react with water?
I apologize if it is an oversimplistic question.
I apologize if it is an oversimplistic question.
How to tell if two compounds will react?
- Thread starter KevinFan
- Start date
-
- Tags
- Compounds
In summary, NaBr dissolves in water but it won't react with water. It does this because it has hydrogen bonds between the sodium and bromine ions. These bonds are strong and take a lot of energy to break. If there are hydrogen bonds present, it may be harder for the reaction to occur.
- #2
Borek
Mentor
- 28,951
- 4,245
It is not a trivial question, unfortunately, there is no good - as in "reasonably easy and useful" - answer.
Basically predicting what will happen is what people learn for all these years they study chemistry. Predictions are based on the properties of the compounds and on the thermodynamics. And then you mix everything and - sometimes - it reacts as predicted.
Basically predicting what will happen is what people learn for all these years they study chemistry. Predictions are based on the properties of the compounds and on the thermodynamics. And then you mix everything and - sometimes - it reacts as predicted.
- #3
self_service
- 2
- 0
Let's start with your example. NaBr is an ionic compound. Sodium carries a positive charge and bromine carries a negative charge. NaBr dissolves in water because water is a polar molecule. You can think of one "side" of the water molecule being positive and one side being negative.
Here's where it gets interesting. When you put the NaBr into the water, the water molecules will begin orienting themselves based on their attraction to the sodium/bromine in the molecule. While one water molecule wouldn't be enough to rip the NaBr apart, when you have all of them together, that total attractive force is enough to break the ionic bond between the sodium and the bromine. This leaves a sodium ion and a bromine ion. Once released, these ions don't react; they just float around.
There is a limit though. Like I said, you need more than the force from one water molecule to break the NaBr apart. You may have noticed that if you've ever dumped table salt in water, after a certain point, no more will dissolve. The measure of how much of a substance will dissolve in water is called the solubility.
For the second part of your question, the biggest reason NaBr won't react with water is because of intermolecular forces. Specifically, there is a force called hydrogen bonding, which occurs when a hydrogen atom bonds to nitrogen, oxygen, or fluorine. Water is hydrogen bound to oxygen.
To analyze this potential reaction, think of a chemical reaction as the process of breaking bonds between some molecules (the reactants) and then forming new bonds (the products). You're essentially rearranging atoms.
Hydrogen bonding is the strongest type of intermolecular force. That means that it takes a lot of energy to break the bonds within a water molecule. H2O wants to stay H2O, and that's why no reaction occurs.
Here's where it gets interesting. When you put the NaBr into the water, the water molecules will begin orienting themselves based on their attraction to the sodium/bromine in the molecule. While one water molecule wouldn't be enough to rip the NaBr apart, when you have all of them together, that total attractive force is enough to break the ionic bond between the sodium and the bromine. This leaves a sodium ion and a bromine ion. Once released, these ions don't react; they just float around.
There is a limit though. Like I said, you need more than the force from one water molecule to break the NaBr apart. You may have noticed that if you've ever dumped table salt in water, after a certain point, no more will dissolve. The measure of how much of a substance will dissolve in water is called the solubility.
For the second part of your question, the biggest reason NaBr won't react with water is because of intermolecular forces. Specifically, there is a force called hydrogen bonding, which occurs when a hydrogen atom bonds to nitrogen, oxygen, or fluorine. Water is hydrogen bound to oxygen.
To analyze this potential reaction, think of a chemical reaction as the process of breaking bonds between some molecules (the reactants) and then forming new bonds (the products). You're essentially rearranging atoms.
Hydrogen bonding is the strongest type of intermolecular force. That means that it takes a lot of energy to break the bonds within a water molecule. H2O wants to stay H2O, and that's why no reaction occurs.
- #4
Borek
Mentor
- 28,951
- 4,245
self_service said:
Intramolecular bonds between hydrogen and oxygen, present in water molecule, do not classify as hydrogen bonding.
Sure, in large conglomerates of water molecules, especially in acidic/basic solutions, things can get complicated and it may be not entirely clear which hydrogen is bound to which oxygen, but it still doesn't justify calling bonds in water molecule "hydrogen bonds".
- #5
self_service
- 2
- 0
In a container of water, the molecules share a mutual attraction. After looking at my previous post though, I worded it very poorly. The bonds occur not within the individual atom itself but within the water molecules as a group. Instead of saying "within a water molecule," I should've said "between water molecules." Thanks for pointing that out.
Source:
https://manoa.hawaii.edu/exploringo...erties-water/hydrogen-bonds-make-water-sticky
Source:
https://manoa.hawaii.edu/exploringo...erties-water/hydrogen-bonds-make-water-sticky
- #6
KevinFan
- 47
- 0
If hydrogen bonding is the strongest intermolecular force, can I just assume that reaction would have a larger tendency not occur if hydrogen bonding is present?Can you give me an example of a compound capable of breaking such of bond?self_service said:
- #7
Borek
Mentor
- 28,951
- 4,245
KevinFan said:
Some reactions are made easy by the existence of hydrogen bonding.
Told you it doesn't want to be simple.
1. How do you determine if two compounds will react?
There are several factors to consider when determining if two compounds will react. These include the chemical structures of the compounds, the presence of functional groups, and the reaction conditions (temperature, pressure, etc.). Additionally, performing a literature search or consulting a database of known reactions can also provide insight into potential reactions.
2. Can physical properties be used to predict chemical reactivity?
While physical properties such as boiling point and solubility can give some indication of chemical structure, they are not reliable predictors of reactivity. It is important to consider the chemical structures and functional groups present in the compounds to determine their potential for reaction.
3. Are there any tools or resources available to help predict reactions between compounds?
Yes, there are several tools and databases available that can assist in predicting reactions between compounds. These include software programs, such as ChemDraw, and online databases like Reaxys and SciFinder. These resources allow for structure-based searching and can provide information on known reactions and their conditions.
4. Can two compounds with similar structures react differently?
Yes, two compounds with similar structures can react differently depending on the specific functional groups present and the reaction conditions. Small changes in the chemical structure can greatly affect the reactivity of a compound.
5. Is it possible to predict the products of a reaction between two compounds?
In most cases, it is not possible to predict the exact products of a reaction between two compounds. However, understanding the chemical structures and functional groups involved can provide insight into the potential products. Experimental data and literature searches can also help in predicting the products of a reaction.
Similar threads
-
Chemistry
-
Chemistry
-
Chemistry
-
Chemistry
-
Chemistry