- #1
Maik
- 4
- 0
Member advised to use the provided formatting template when starting a new thread in a homework forum.
Hey,
this is going to be my first post here so I'm not sure how it all works, so just tell me if I do something out of order please. Anyway I have been given this homework assignment and part of it was the question stated below.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The speed (v) of a planet in orbit around a star of mass M is related to its orbital distance (r) and orbital semimajor axis (a) by
v2=GM((2/r)-(1/a))
Use this equation to show that if the Sun instantly lost a fraction f of its mass, reducing its mass from M to M(1 − f), then the Earth’s (originally circular) orbit would have a period of
T =((1 − f)/(1 − 2f))3/2 years
[You may assume Kepler’s Third Law: orbital period is proportional to orbital semimajor
axis to the power 3/2.]
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Equations that I am supposed to use are stated in the problem, however I also considered the equation for the angular momentum and energy relating the kinetic energy and the gravitational potential energy:
L=mvr and E=1/2mv2 -GMm/r
I started off by trying to find an expression for a and the using that in Keplars 3rd rule, however rather than simplifying the whole expression to what they asked it made it more of a mess. I then attempted to solve it for the point at which r=a (initially) and then the same for the new orbit. By then considering the conservation of angular momentum I found an expression on the new a (calling it c) as follows: c= a/(1-f) ( by saying that L2=m2 u2 a2 = m2 v2 c2 (where u is the initial velocity and v is the final velocity) and then putting the expression from the problem in as the v2 and then simplifying it down using the initial velocity of u as squrt.(GM/a)) I then put this in keplars 3rd rule but with no success.
I could have made some mistake here or forgot to consider something but I just can not get my head around it.
It would be great if someone could just hint me where I could have gone wrong or what I should/can consider to stay the same during the mass loss.
Thanks a lot in advance already!
this is going to be my first post here so I'm not sure how it all works, so just tell me if I do something out of order please. Anyway I have been given this homework assignment and part of it was the question stated below.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The speed (v) of a planet in orbit around a star of mass M is related to its orbital distance (r) and orbital semimajor axis (a) by
v2=GM((2/r)-(1/a))
Use this equation to show that if the Sun instantly lost a fraction f of its mass, reducing its mass from M to M(1 − f), then the Earth’s (originally circular) orbit would have a period of
T =((1 − f)/(1 − 2f))3/2 years
[You may assume Kepler’s Third Law: orbital period is proportional to orbital semimajor
axis to the power 3/2.]
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Equations that I am supposed to use are stated in the problem, however I also considered the equation for the angular momentum and energy relating the kinetic energy and the gravitational potential energy:
L=mvr and E=1/2mv2 -GMm/r
I started off by trying to find an expression for a and the using that in Keplars 3rd rule, however rather than simplifying the whole expression to what they asked it made it more of a mess. I then attempted to solve it for the point at which r=a (initially) and then the same for the new orbit. By then considering the conservation of angular momentum I found an expression on the new a (calling it c) as follows: c= a/(1-f) ( by saying that L2=m2 u2 a2 = m2 v2 c2 (where u is the initial velocity and v is the final velocity) and then putting the expression from the problem in as the v2 and then simplifying it down using the initial velocity of u as squrt.(GM/a)) I then put this in keplars 3rd rule but with no success.
I could have made some mistake here or forgot to consider something but I just can not get my head around it.
It would be great if someone could just hint me where I could have gone wrong or what I should/can consider to stay the same during the mass loss.
Thanks a lot in advance already!