What does Causality really mean?

In summary, the term "universe" is often used to mean "observable universe" in cosmology, as we can never know anything by direct experimentation about any part of the universe that is causally disconnected from Earth. This means that even though the universe may be much bigger than our observable universe, we can only observe and study what is within our observable universe. Any events or influences from outside of our observable universe cannot reach us fast enough to be observed. Additionally, when discussing causality, it is important to think in terms of events rather than just location, as an event outside of our observable universe may have already influenced something within our observable universe without us being able to see evidence of it until the light from that event reaches us.
  • #1
InfiniteMonkey
5
0
In the wikipedia article of the observable universe I have read the following:
"Both popular and professional research articles in cosmology often use the term "universe" to mean "observable universe". This can be justified on the grounds that we can never know anything by direct experimentation about any part of the universe that is causally disconnected from the Earth"

Im confused about the term causally disconnected, I get the main idea but:
When we define the universe as beeing much bigger then the observable universe, then every point in space has his own observable universe which is presumably as big as ours. Isnt then anything inside our observable universe and outside our viewpoint influenced by (for example radiation) from a different observable universe, therefore indirectly we get influenced from the outside of our observable universe too because of cause and effect?
Which of my assumptions is wrong.
 
Space news on Phys.org
  • #2
InfiniteMonkey said:
therefore indirectly we get influenced from the outside of our observable universe too because of cause and effect?
It does not follow.

You can have an event that lies within the past lightcones (i.e. observable universes) of two causally disconnected observers, and that event will have influenced both observers. But no event at either observer's location could have influenced the other.

E.g. let's imagine two observers A and B, today separated by twice the radius of the observable universe (same for both). A flash of light emitted when the universe was very young from point C, located midway between A and B, can by now be observed by both A and B. But neither observer could have ever sent a flash of light to be observed by the other. Both A and B can say something about the state the point C was in long ago, i.e. about the edges of their respective observable universes. Neither can say anything about the state of the other's location. They couldn't have used the existence of point C to communicate anything to, or otherwise influence, one another.
 
  • #3
Causality, a genetic connection between individual states of types and forms of matter in the processes of its movement and development. The emergence of any objects and systems and the change in their characteristics (properties) in time have their defining grounds in the previous states of matter. These reasons are called causes, and the changes they cause are called effects (sometimes actions).
 
  • #4
InfiniteMonkey said:
Isnt then anything inside our observable universe and outside our viewpoint influenced by (for example radiation) from a different observable universe, therefore indirectly we get influenced from the outside of our observable universe too because of cause and effect?
No, because the effects can't propagate to us fast enough to ever be seen.
 
  • Like
Likes DaveE
  • #5
diezir said:
Causality, a genetic connection between individual states of types and forms of matter in the processes of its movement and development. The emergence of any objects and systems and the change in their characteristics (properties) in time have their defining grounds in the previous states of matter. These reasons are called causes, and the changes they cause are called effects (sometimes actions).
Do you have a link to where you got this text from? It's best to post a link in order to avoid copyright violations. Thanks.
 
  • #6
Think in terms of events, not just location. An event outside of your light cone may “have already” influenced something within your light cone, but you can’t see any evidence of that until the light from that intermediate point reaches you. By this time, ignoring the expansion of space, the original event will be within your light cone!
 
  • #7
geshel said:
Think in terms of events, not just location. An event outside of your light cone may “have already” influenced something within your light cone, but you can’t see any evidence of that until the light from that intermediate point reaches you. By this time, ignoring the expansion of space, the original event will be within your light cone!
By definition - where you have A (here), B (there) and C (there there) - if C influenced B which is subsequently observable by A, then C was within A's observable universe when the influence left C to go to B.
 
  • Like
Likes geshel
  • #8
hmmm27 said:
By definition - where you have A (here), B (there) and C (there there) - if C influenced B which is subsequently observable by A, then C was within A's observable universe when the influence left C to go to B.
Event C is in event A’s observable universe.

“Location” C is not in “location” A’s observable universe at the ill-defined “when the influence left C”.
 

1. What is causality?

Causality refers to the relationship between cause and effect, where one event (the cause) leads to another event (the effect).

2. How is causality studied?

Causality is studied through experiments, observations, and statistical analyses. Scientists manipulate one variable (cause) and observe the changes in another variable (effect) to determine if there is a causal relationship.

3. Can correlation imply causation?

No, correlation does not necessarily imply causation. Just because two variables are related does not mean that one caused the other. Other factors, known as confounding variables, may be responsible for the observed relationship.

4. What is the difference between causality and correlation?

Causality refers to a direct cause-and-effect relationship between two variables, while correlation refers to a relationship between two variables that may or may not be directly related.

5. How do scientists determine causality?

Scientists use a combination of methods, such as experiments and statistical analyses, to determine causality. They also consider other factors and potential confounding variables to strengthen their conclusions.

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
958
  • Cosmology
Replies
15
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
17
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
15
Views
1K
Back
Top