Recent content by abszero

  1. A

    Physical justification for Uncertainty principle

    The physical justification is that it works. Dave, what you've said would imply that the Uncertainty Principle is a purely experimental phenomena. In fact, it is absolutely necessary for our current formulation of quantum mechanics, and is a consequence of the formal structure, not just some...
  2. A

    How do you a find a Hamiltonian?

    This is not a true statement. It is equivalent to Newton's laws in cases where forces of constraint do no work, which is not every problem. This is an important distinction. Newton's laws deal stupidly with constraints to motion regardless of their form, whereas Lagrange's equations do not...
  3. A

    About an idea concerning collapse

    Your statement is ambiguous, so nobody knows what to say. How can collapse not be "defined"? As I understood it, it's not particularly hard to "define", it's just an experimental result obtained for quantum mechanics.
  4. A

    Is it possible to derive action principle #2 from QM?

    If you have a holonomic constraint, then it means that there is a constraint on the problem of the form f(\overline{q}, t) = 0. Nonholonomic constraints are the rest. The papers I cited mention a few examples. The point is that the calculus of variations coupled with the usual treatment given...
  5. A

    Is it possible to derive action principle #2 from QM?

    I think it's probably important to note that Hamilton's principle does not lead to Newton's equations, it's the other way around. To see an example of the failings of Hamilton's principle to obtain Newton's equations, I recommend reading "Nonholonomic Constraints: A Test Case" in the Am. Jour...
  6. A

    Angular Momentum and the Role of h-Bar in Quantum Mechanics

    In most modern texts I've seen it derived by looking at the generators of rotations, and then concluding the commutation relations [L_\imath, L_\jmath] = \imath \epsilon_{\imath \jmath k} \hbar L_k and then realizing that, like how momentum is the generator of space translations, angular...
  7. A

    EPR paradox revisited, again. hehehe

    Bell's inequality is intimately related to EPR type things, since it declares that quantum mechanics is locally complete. This is clearly related to your "instantaneous transmission of information" idea.
  8. A

    EPR paradox revisited, again. hehehe

    Which means that useful information did not get transmitted faster than light. You can only transmit information faster than light in a way that violates relativity if they can know each other's experimental results without any other communication between them aside from the entangled units...
  9. A

    Spin & the Stern-Gerlach Experiment: Real Answer?

    Objects with spin rotate in different ways. Fermions and bosons pick up different phases with rotations, so it depends on what your real space wave function is producted with in terms of spinors. To get a full rotation, you have to have the rotation operator in both real space and spin space...
  10. A

    What is the restriction for the sine function?

    It's the definition of the inverse of a function f(x). For example, y = 2x and y^-1 = 1/2 x
  11. A

    3 equations, 3 unknowns, how do i solve ?

    Be double careful that you don't multiply by zero and stumble across a solution that actually does not exist.
  12. A

    You cannot derieve Schrödinger Equation .

    The thing is, if you use the symmetry-based deduction, it sets you up quite well for thinking about Noether's Theorem, so in that sense it's quite useful. The Schrodinger equation arises out of some postulates of quantum mechanics, particularly that observables are generators of some sort of...
  13. A

    You cannot derieve Schrödinger Equation .

    The way that you "derive" the Schrodinger equation is that you assume that the hamiltonian is the generator of finite time translations. As for the form of the hamiltonian, it comes from making a classical correspondence and introducing operators that obey the canonical commutation relations, or...
  14. A

    Calculating Entropy Changes in a Rigid Tank with Argon at Different Temperatures

    If it's a thermal reservoir, then the temperature is assumed to remain constant.
  15. A

    Can light be deflected in an electric field

    photon-photon scattering as I understand is a fourth order effect, where you have two pair productions, the pairs interact then annihilate, and the emitted photons appear to be scattered from the original two. Is this correct?
Back
Top