Recent content by hellfire

  1. H

    Spin-2 exchange particle and GR

    The metric tensor has 10 independent components that reduce to 6 if one imposes local conservation of energy and momentum. The graviton, on the other hand, only has two degrees of freedom. Given this, how does it then that a theory of the graviton can be equivalent to general relativity at least...
  2. H

    How many stars in the Solar neighbourhood

    Go to this site: http://www.solstation.com/index.html and try the links under "Maps" and the link "Stars" and "Orbits" under "Support".
  3. H

    Status of Gravity & Net Energy of Universe: Is Theory Viable?

    This was recently discussed here: https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=285100
  4. H

    Graininess of Space-Time found at GEO600?

    If the indeterminacy in the transverse position of null geodesics goes as \sqrt{L \, l_P}, shouldn't this have been already detected in applications of optics? Why do gravitational waves have any special significance here?
  5. H

    Is Inertia Truly Uniform in All Directions?

    I had argued above with a somewhat obscure argument that anisotropic inertia might be a matter of convetion, but your argument is great, very clear and convincing.
  6. H

    Configuration space vs physical space

    Thanks for your answer to my question, it clarified more to me what you have in mind. I actually was thinking of that lagrangian with the constraint - \dot q^{\mu} \dot q_{\mu}=1 and I still do not see how the problem arises (that condition removes the 4 particle interpretation as you said). I...
  7. H

    Configuration space vs physical space

    Consider the lagrangian of a free relativistic particle \mathcal L = m \sqrt{- \dot q^{\mu} \dot q_{\mu}}. How does the problem arise in such a case?
  8. H

    Configuration space vs physical space

    May be it is meaningful to ask first about the relativistic theory. Shouldn't be a constraint between the components of the linear momentum in case that you are talking about one single particle?
  9. H

    Is Inertia Truly Uniform in All Directions?

    If inertia is anisotropic, so is the propagation of light. It is not difficult to show that there exists a relation between the convention of a simultaneity definition and the isotropic and anisotropic propagation of light. Only the Einstein simultaneity definition leads to an isotropic...
  10. H

    Origin of Universe: Exploring Current Scientific Theories

    I agree with marcus that the claim of a zero energy universe is not rigorous. Specially because we do not have a definition of gravitational energy in a FRW universe. As far as I know, this idea is suggested by an argument similar to this one: Assume that the zero energy balance between energy...
  11. H

    Accelerating Expansion Threshhold

    The topic is quite complex and the answer depends heavily on the cosmological model. See In an expanding universe, what doesn't expand?.
  12. H

    Universal Constants: Books for Laymen about Observable Effects

    Lisa Randall's "Warped Passages".
  13. H

    Gravity Leaking = Dark energy increasing

    There is no inmediate - or intuitive - link between leaking of gravity and accelerated expansion. Leaking of gravity will arise in models of a 3D-brane embedded in 5D spacetime, with afaik some general assumptions about the quantum behavior of gravity. However, for cosmological models derived...
  14. H

    Mysterious Motion of Galaxy Clusters Detected

    Interesting, thanks wolram.
  15. H

    Mysterious Motion of Galaxy Clusters Detected

    I am aware of that paper, but it does not answer my quetion. They do not relate this to any other postulated inconsistency in the large scale WMAP data, do they?