Interaction between two point charges

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on analyzing the interaction between two ideal point charges, one approaching the other with a relative velocity. Participants express the complexity of mathematically modeling this scenario, particularly concerning electric fields in non-inertial frames. They reference Heaviside's and Feynman's equations for calculating electric fields but highlight challenges in determining these fields for moving charges. The conversation suggests that in the non-relativistic limit, the problem can be simplified to a one-body motion around the center of mass, akin to the Kepler problem, while acknowledging that relativistic speeds complicate the analysis. Participants seek accessible references for understanding the two-body problem involving point charges at relativistic speeds.
universal_101
Messages
324
Reaction score
3
Let's suppose, we have two ideal point charges q_{1}, m_{1} and q_{2}, m_{2}.

One of them comes from almost infinite distance with relative velocity v_{0}, w.r.t another charge. I'm curious how can we analyze this situation mathematically, i.e the equations of the motions of these particles.

Please post some references too.

Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What are your thoughts on the dynamics of the situation?
 
Studiot said:
What are your thoughts on the dynamics of the situation?

I think it is fairly hard situation to analyse mathematically,

We know how to calculate the Electric Field produced by a moving charge, but this Electric field is w.r.t a fixed point.

For example we have Heaviside's equation for uniform motion as

E = \frac{q}{4\pi\epsilon_{0} r^3} \frac{\left(1- v^2/c^2\right)}{\left(1- \left(v^2/c^2\right)sin^2\theta\right)^{3/2}} r

and Feynman's equation for all motion as

E = \frac{q}{4\pi\epsilon_{0}}\left(\frac{e_{r^\acute{}}}{{r^\acute{}}^2} + \frac{r^\acute{}}{c} \frac{d}{dt}\left(\frac{e_{r^\acute{}}}{{r^\acute{}}^2}\right) - \frac{1}{c^2} \frac{d^2}{{dt}^2}\left({e_{r^\acute{}}}\right) \right)

where all the symbols have their usual meaning, but since these Electric Field values are only for observing from an inertial system or stationary system, I don't know how to proceed for non-inertial system, i.e a simple two point charge problem.
 
I don't know how to proceed for non-inertial system, i.e a simple two point charge problem.

Your original question had mass so why is it non inertial?
 
Studiot said:
Your original question had mass so why is it non inertial?

Non-inertial as in SR frame of reference Non-inertial

Obviously, both charges would accelerate/ decelerate as they start interacting with each other, I posted equations for calculating Electric Field in order to get the force on each other, and then dividing by mass we can always get the acceleration.

That is multiplying E by q/m should give the acceleration, but i don't know how to get E at the first place.

Since, we are looking for the dynamics of the situation, we need to have the accelerations of each to calculate their speed or position after some time.
 
In the non-relativistic limit, you can reduce the problem to a 1-body-motion around the common center of mass, and you get the Kepler problem. If that is not precise enough, you can try to add correction terms for relativistic mechanics.

With relativistic velocities, it is still possible to reduce the problem, but the formulas are not as simple as in the Kepler problem. You get radiation and so on.
 
mfb said:
In the non-relativistic limit, you can reduce the problem to a 1-body-motion around the common center of mass, and you get the Kepler problem. If that is not precise enough, you can try to add correction terms for relativistic mechanics.

With relativistic velocities, it is still possible to reduce the problem, but the formulas are not as simple as in the Kepler problem. You get radiation and so on.

Thanks mfb,

I would really appreciate some easy to get references, for the two body problem with relativistic speeds for point charges.
 
Back
Top