Can capillary action lift water to 10 meters?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Yuri B.
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Capillary Limit
AI Thread Summary
Capillary action alone cannot lift water to a height of 10 meters; instead, it is the negative pressure created at the top of trees that facilitates this elevation. Water reaches the tops of 100-meter tall trees due to a combination of capillary action in tiny leaf pores and tension in the thicker xylem tubes. The tiny pores (2-5 nm) allow sufficient capillary action to counterbalance the weight of the water column below. The xylem tubes, which are much wider (20000-200000 nm), cannot solely achieve this height through capillary action. Understanding this phenomenon involves recognizing the role of negative pressure and the metastable state of water at great heights.
Yuri B.
Messages
137
Reaction score
0
Is it feasible to achieve elavation of water to, let's say, 10 m height due to the capillary action effect ? Or the capillary diameter for that to achieve should be less than the water molecules themselves ?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I do not believe that it is pure capillary action, but water does reach the top of 100m tall trees.
 
Integral said:
I do not believe that it is pure capillary action, but water does reach the top of 100m tall trees.

That happens due to negative pressure at the top of the tree (otherwise known as tension). You might think a liquid cannot have negative pressure but that would be wrong. Water is actually in a metastable supercooled state at the top of the tree and would boil (due to negative pressure) if a nucleation seed was provided.

Watch Veritassium's youtube video titled "The Most Amazing Thing About Trees" for a clear explanation.
 
Integral said:
I do not believe that it is pure capillary action, but water does reach the top of 100m tall trees.
The pores of the leaves (where the water evaporates) are indeed so tiny (2-5 nm), that capillary action is strong enough to balance the weight of the sap column below, within which the force is transmitted as tension (negative pressure) in the much thicker xylem-tubes (20000-200000 nm).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BickMFHAZR0
 
I meant artificial material.
 
:
"...venerable question of why sap rises in tall trees [32]. We
hope to address this problem in future work"
 
Yuri B. said:
:
"...venerable question of why sap rises in tall trees [32]. We
hope to address this problem in future work"

See post #4. The xylem tubes in the tree stem are too wide to pull the water 100m by capillary action. But the much smaller pores in the leaves provide enough capillary action to balance the weight of the fluid column below, which is under tension.
 
Back
Top