Atomic radius by dimensional analysis

areyouserious
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Hi,
So according to the Thomas-Fermi theory, the formula for atomic radius is
R=Z^(-1/3)*(hbar ^2)/m*e^2. (in other words Z^(-1/3) times the Bohr radius)

While the total energy has a Z^(7/3) dependence.

I need to get this from dimensional analysis. I can get the dependence on h, m, and e easily, but the Z^(-1/3) is a mystery to me. I understand that the Z, being unitless, must be tacked on to another unit, and working backwards, I can see that it works out if I attach a Z term to h and to e, and attaching a Z^(1/3) term to m. But how can I justify this? Why only 1/3 power for m, but first power for e and h? Please help, I am completely stuck.
Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
OK, Z means what? It's the nuclear charge, as well as the number of electrons. So where might you see Z's? The combination Ze makes sense in a way Zh does not, no? You can also see Z's appear if you are counting something - like electrons.

I hope this points you in the right direction.
 
From the BCS theory of superconductivity is well known that the superfluid density smoothly decreases with increasing temperature. Annihilated superfluid carriers become normal and lose their momenta on lattice atoms. So if we induce a persistent supercurrent in a ring below Tc and after that slowly increase the temperature, we must observe a decrease in the actual supercurrent, because the density of electron pairs and total supercurrent momentum decrease. However, this supercurrent...
Hi. I have got question as in title. How can idea of instantaneous dipole moment for atoms like, for example hydrogen be consistent with idea of orbitals? At my level of knowledge London dispersion forces are derived taking into account Bohr model of atom. But we know today that this model is not correct. If it would be correct I understand that at each time electron is at some point at radius at some angle and there is dipole moment at this time from nucleus to electron at orbit. But how...
Back
Top