Calculating area of an annulus

  • Thread starter Thread starter ShizukaSm
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Area
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
5 replies · 5K views
ShizukaSm
Messages
85
Reaction score
0
My physics book when providing proof of the electric potential of a disk tells me that the area of a ring with radius [itex]R'[/itex] and width [itex]dR'[/itex] is [itex]2 \pi R'dR'[/itex]
ringofcharge.JPG

The problem is, I have no idea how he arrives at this conclusion. Here is my attempt:
[itex]A = \pi (R'+dR')^2 - PiR'^2\\ A = \pi(R'^2 + dR'^2 + 2R'dR') - \pi R'^2 \\ A = \pi dR'^2 + 2 \pi R' dR'[/itex]
Which is, of course, different from what my book says:
[itex]A = \pi dR'^2 + 2 \pi R' dR' \neq 2 \pi R'dR'[/itex]
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Notice that [itex]dR'^2[/itex] is the square of an infinitesimal quantity, which we take to be zero. So your derivation works out.
 
When doing infinitesimal proofs like this any squared terms are negligible - for example your [itex]dR'^2[/itex] should be thrown out.

An alternate way to see the result is if you cut the ring and lay it out flat it's a rectangle (almost) with side lengths easily calculated.
 
I will drop the primes so as not to confuse with the derivative. What your text is using is the differential approximation to the annulus area. You have a circle of area ##A=\pi R^2##. The approximate change in area when ##R## is changed by an amount ##dR## is the differential ##A'dR = 2\pi R dR## which approximates the exact change, which you have calculated. For small ##dR## you can ignore the ##dR^2## term.

[Edit] Wow! Two other answers just while I was typing. That's life in PF.
 
Ohh, I see ! Thanks to you three, that perfectly cleared my doubt.
 
A disk of radius R has area [itex]\pi R^2[/itex]. A disk of radius R+ dR has area [itex]\pi(R+ dR)^2= \pi R^2+ 2\pi RdR+ \pi(dR)^2[/itex]. The area of the annulus between them is [itex]2\pi RdR+\pi (dR)^2[/itex]. If dR is much smaller than R, that is approximatelyu [itex]2\pi RdR[/itex].