A mass sliding down the inclined plane -- Will it stop?

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
14 replies · 3K views
rudransh verma
Gold Member
Messages
1,067
Reaction score
96
Homework Statement
The upper half of an inclined plane with inclination ##\phi## is perfectly smooth,while the lower half is rough. A body starting from rest at the top will again come to rest at the bottom, if the coefficient of friction for the lower half is
Relevant Equations
##Fnet=ma##
##v^2=u^2+2as##
For lower half ,$$Fnet=-\mu F_N+mg\sin \phi$$
For upper half,
$$v^2=u^2+2as$$ (s is half of the total slant distance)
$$v^2=0+2\frac{mg\sin \phi}ms$$
$$v=\sqrt{2g\sin \phi s}$$
again for lower half,
$$v^2=u^2+2as$$
$$0=2g\sin \phi s+2\frac{-\mu F_N+mg\sin \phi}ms$$
$$\mu=\frac{2gm\sin \phi}{F_N}$$
$$\mu=2\sin \phi$$
 
Physics news on Phys.org
kuruman said:
You cannot get rid of ##F_N## in the denominator by setting it equal to the weight. What is ##F_N##?
Normal force which will be equal to weight mg. I don't think i have done anything wrong here.
 
Last edited:
rudransh verma said:
Normal force which will be equal to weight mg. I don't think i have done anything wrong here.
If it makes sense to you that the normal force is equal to the weight no matter what the angle of the incline, leave it at that but it is wrong. I will not suggest a method for finding the correct normal force because you have ignored such advice by numerous people on numerous occasions in other threads. I am out of this particular thread.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: SammyS, Doc Al and jbriggs444
rudransh verma said:
Normal force which will be equal to weight mg. I don't think i have done anything wrong here.
Only on level ground.
 
rudransh verma said:
Normal force which will be equal to weight mg.
What do you think the word "normal" means here? Have you tried solving for the normal force?
 
rudransh verma said:
Normal force which will be equal to weight mg. I don't think i have done anything wrong here.
You have an impressive rate of posting to this forum. Unfortunately it does not seem to be leaving you time to think in between.
 
  • Skeptical
Likes   Reactions: rudransh verma
haruspex said:
You have an impressive rate of posting to this forum. Unfortunately it does not seem to be leaving you time to think in between.
##F_N=mg\cos \phi##. By mistake I did that. ##\mu= 2\tan \phi## is coming.
 
Would the work done by friction be equal to the work done by gravity?
 
haruspex said:
Yes.
Thanks. I would assume that would be the way to solve it, but not enough information given.
 
haruspex said:
Really? Looks enough to me.
Oh... I misunderstood the question. It is trying to solve for the coefficient of friction vs the angle of the ramp, given that the coefficient changes from zero to some value after half the length of the ramp?
 
valenumr said:
Oh... I misunderstood the question. It is trying to solve for the coefficient of friction vs the angle of the ramp, given that the coefficient changes from zero to some value after half the length of the ramp?
Yes.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: valenumr