A somewhat easier liar/truther puzzle

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jimmy Snyder
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Puzzle
AI Thread Summary
To determine the correct road to Gandor at the fork, one effective strategy is to point behind you and ask the person if that is the road to Gandor. If they answer "yes," they are the liar; if they answer "no," they are the truth-teller. This method allows you to identify the nature of the person you are speaking to, enabling you to ask about the other roads confidently. The discussion emphasizes that both the liar and the truth-teller could potentially be from the same city, which adds complexity to the scenario. The focus remains on the single question format allowed, reinforcing the importance of strategic questioning in solving the riddle.
Jimmy Snyder
Messages
1,122
Reaction score
22
As you travel from Rodnag to Gandor, you encounter a fork in the road. There is someone standing there who is either one who always lies or one who always tells the truth and you don't know which. You can point to any road and ask "Is this the road to Gandor?" as many times as you like, but that is the only question you can get an answer to. How to do find the correct road to Gandor?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
white: you point behind you and ask if that's the road to Gandor, if he says yes, he's a liar, no, he's a truther... then you ask about the other roads.
 
That's right, Gale17.
 
what a fun ^^
 
Isn't the answer to ask him to point at the road that goes to his city? The liar points to truth and so does the truth teller.
 
Alkatran said:
Isn't the answer to ask him to point at the road that goes to his city? The liar points to truth and so does the truth teller.
No.
jimmysnyder said:
You can point to any road and ask "Is this the road to Gandor?" as many times as you like, but that is the only question you can get an answer to.
Also, it doesn't say that the liar and truth-teller come from different cities. They could both be from Gandor.
 
edit: aaaaaaaaaand then i read the post
 
Last edited:
Back
Top