Algebra and Calculus in three dimensions

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the challenges of setting up three-dimensional integrals in the context of Coulomb's law and electric fields. The original poster expresses difficulty in visualizing and formulating integrals for spherically symmetric charge distributions, particularly when applying the superposition principle. They seek recommendations for books that focus on algebra and geometry in three dimensions, ideally including multivariable and vector calculus. Suggestions include "Div, Grad, Curl and all that" by Schey, noted for its relevance to electromagnetism. The poster confirms a solid background in single and multivariable calculus, real and complex analysis, abstract algebra, and linear algebra but emphasizes their struggle with three-dimensional integral setups, particularly in physics applications.
Avatrin
Messages
242
Reaction score
6
Hi

I have realized that I am horrible at setting up integrals in three dimensions when working with Coulomb's law (F = k q*∫r-2dq ). I don't have the vaguest idea how I can solve this using it and the superposition principle:
An electric charge +Q is distributed with a p(r) which does not depend on θ or ϕ throughout the volume of a sphere of radius R; i.e., it is spherically symmetric. Find the force it produces on an electron (charge -e) located at an outside point r meters from the center of the sphere. Let i point from the origin, at the center of the sphere, to the electron.

I am not asking for a solution to this exercise. I want a good books that can teach me algebra and geometry in three dimensions (a lot of books seem to teach trigonometry in two dimensions and just give you the three dimensional equations without explaining them). If the book also has some multivariable and vector calculus, that will be even better.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Use Gauss' Theorem is the traditional approach ... unless you are very traditional, then you can use Newton's "Shell Theorem" from gravitational theory.
 
Like I wrote in my earlier post; I am not looking for a solution to that particular exercise. I just need to become better with geometry and multivariable calculus. I do not have much problem with problems in two dimensions, but setting up integrals in three dimensions dimensions is something I am struggling too much with.
 
The problem you wrote is essentially one-dimensional. Have you taken a course on single-variable calculus? Are you familiar with different coordinate systems? What E&M textbook are you using?

It's hard to recommend something if we do not know what level you are at.
 
Mmm_Pasta said:
The problem you wrote is essentially one-dimensional. Have you taken a course on single-variable calculus? Are you familiar with different coordinate systems? What E&M textbook are you using?

It's hard to recommend something if we do not know what level you are at.

Yes, I have taken both single and multivariable calculus (there was too little vector calculus in that course). I have also taken real and complex analysis, abstract algebra and linear algebra.

The thing I am struggling most with happens to be what I need most in physics (I regret I didn't go for programming instead of physics).

My example was obviously a bad one considering it can be solved using Gauss's theorem, but the point was that I struggle with setting up integrals for problems in three dimensions (distances between a point and any point on a sphere and the like). I have no problems solving them when I have set them up.
 
For the following four books, has anyone used them in a course or for self study? Compiler Construction Principles and Practice 1st Edition by Kenneth C Louden Programming Languages Principles and Practices 3rd Edition by Kenneth C Louden, and Kenneth A Lambert Programming Languages 2nd Edition by Allen B Tucker, Robert E Noonan Concepts of Programming Languages 9th Edition by Robert W Sebesta If yes to either, can you share your opinions about your personal experience using them. I...
Hi, I have notice that Ashcroft, Mermin and Wei worked at a revised edition of the original solid state physics book (here). The book, however, seems to be never available. I have also read that the reason is related to some disputes related to copyright. Do you have any further information about it? Did you have the opportunity to get your hands on this revised edition? I am really curious about it, also considering that I am planning to buy the book in the near future... Thanks!
I’ve heard that in some countries (for example, Argentina), the curriculum is structured differently from the typical American program. In the U.S., students usually take a general physics course first, then move on to a textbook like Griffiths, and only encounter Jackson at the graduate level. In contrast, in those countries students go through a general physics course (such as Resnick-Halliday) and then proceed directly to Jackson. If the slower, more gradual approach is considered...

Similar threads

Replies
16
Views
10K
Replies
12
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
11
Views
4K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Back
Top