Algebraic Rate Problem: Finding Time for Bob to Reach Charlie

  • Thread starter Thread starter daigo
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Rate
AI Thread Summary
In this algebraic rate problem, Andy starts 100 feet from Bob and 300 feet from Charlie, moving at constant speeds. After 6 minutes, Andy reaches Bob, and after another 6 minutes, he reaches Charlie, totaling 12 minutes for Andy to cover the entire distance. The discussion focuses on establishing the relationships between their speeds and distances traveled, with equations derived from their movements. There is confusion regarding the distances covered by Bob and Charlie during Andy's travel, particularly how Bob's distance is accounted for in the calculations. Ultimately, the problem requires determining how long it takes for Bob to reach Charlie, factoring in their relative speeds and distances.
daigo
Messages
27
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Andy is 100 feet from Bob and Bob is 300 feet from Charlie and they are all facing the same direction on the same line.
They all begin to move in the same direction that they are facing at relative constant speeds.
In 6 minutes, Andy reaches Bob, and in another 6 minutes, Andy reaches Charlie.
How many minutes will it take for Bob to reach Charlie?

Homework Equations



d = r * t

The Attempt at a Solution



So I've drawn the initial problem like this:

Code:
A ---------- B ------------------------------ C
      100                    300

So A -> C = 400.

In 6 minutes, all A, B, and C will have moved a certain distance, so Andy's distance traveled = Bob's distance traveled + 100:

(R_A = Rate of Andy, R_B = Rate of Bob):

(R_A)(6) = 100 + (R_B)(6)

But Charlie has also traveled another 6 minutes worth of distance so I have to keep that in mind.

So in another 6 minutes, Since Andy was in the same position as Bob but is now up to Charlie (Charlie has traveled 12 minutes now also):

(R_A)(6+6) = (R_C)(12) + 400

I think. I'm not even sure if this is the correct distance traveled so far.

How do I find how far Bob traveled in 12 minutes?

(R_B)(12) = ?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
daigo said:

Homework Statement



Andy is 100 feet from Bill and Bill is 300 feet from Charlie and they are all facing the same direction on the same line.
They all begin to move in the same direction that they are facing at relative constant speeds.
In 6 minutes, Andy reaches Bill, and in another 6 minutes, Andy reaches Chelsea.
How many minutes will it take for Bill to reach Chelsea?
What happened to Charlie?

Homework Equations



d = r * t

The Attempt at a Solution



So I've drawn the initial problem like this:

Code:
A ---------- B ------------------------------ C
      100                    300

So A -> C = 400.

In 6 minutes, all A, B, and C will have moved a certain distance, so Andy's distance traveled = Bob's distance traveled + 100:
And now Bill has changed to Bob?

(R_A = Rate of Andy, R_B = Rate of Bob):

(R_A)(6) = 100 + (R_B)(6)
So you have R_A= (6R_B+ 100)/6

[quogter]But Charlie has also traveled another 6 minutes worth of distance so I have to keep that in mind.

So in another 6 minutes, Since Andy was in the same position as Bob
I have noi idea what you mean by that.
but is now up to Charlie (Charlie has traveled 12 minutes now also):

(R_A)(6+6) = (R_C)(12) + 400
Good. And so R_C= (12R_A- 400)/12. Now replace R_A with (6R_B+100)/6 to get a relation between R_C and R_B.

I think. I'm not even sure if this is the correct distance traveled so far.

How do I find how far Bill traveled in 12 minutes?

(R_B)(12) = ?
Frankly, the switch from "Charlie" to "Chelsea" and back again and the change from "Bill" to "Bob" makes me wonder how much attention you gave to this problem.
 
Sorry, I fixed the problem. I have been working on it since yesterday and I still don't understand any of it, even when looking at the solution so I'm a little frustrated.
 
The solution process says that:

(12)R_A = (12)R_C + 400

So in 12 minutes when Andy reaches Charlie, doesn't Andy need to cross: 100 ft + Bob's covered distance + 400 ft. + Charlie's covered distance? How come Bob's distance is omitted entirely? It seems like Andy just skipped over Bob and only covers the distance to reach Charlie, since Charlie didn't travel the distance Bob did at all, so Andy has to travel that first to cover Charlie's distance as well.
 
I picked up this problem from the Schaum's series book titled "College Mathematics" by Ayres/Schmidt. It is a solved problem in the book. But what surprised me was that the solution to this problem was given in one line without any explanation. I could, therefore, not understand how the given one-line solution was reached. The one-line solution in the book says: The equation is ##x \cos{\omega} +y \sin{\omega} - 5 = 0##, ##\omega## being the parameter. From my side, the only thing I could...
Back
Top