Alternating current circuit with transformer

12 replies · 2K views · last reply
David331
Messages
31
Reaction score
1
Homework Statement
Find the voltage u(t) in the circuit.
Relevant Equations
?
Hi, I don't understand how to solve the problem below for (a).
First I transform the cirucuit to direct current problem using jw method. Now i see that U=-I2Z. Z=R2+Zc3=R2+1/jwC3=4,5+1/[j(1000)(10^-3*0,25)]. Then I use impedance transformation to get rid of the transformator(using Z0), but then I don't really know what to do. None of my lectures have shown how to actually solve such a problem with tranformators. Is the current through Z0 I1 or have I even approached the problem in a right way?
Basically what it says in swedish is that the source inner impedance is Zi and that for the Transformator N1/N2=10.

Circuit schematic with an ideal transformer, in Swedish: source i0(t) feeding R1 = 1.8k, parallel L1 = 2.5H and C1 = 1.75u, C2 = 0.75u, transformer N1/N2, and load R2 = 4.5 ohm in series with C3 = 0.25m, output voltage u(t) across terminals.
Handwritten circuit diagrams: top, a current source i0(t) feeding R1, series C1 and L1, shunt C2, then an ideal transformer to R2 and C3 with output u(t); middle, the jw-method equivalent with impedances Zi, Z1, Z2, Zc1, Zc2, Zc3, N1 and N2, and Z0 = (N1/N2)^2 Z; bottom, a simplified equivalent with Io, Zi, R1, Z2, Zc2 and Z0.
 
Last edited:
Now, continuing with this I firstly use KCL to get an expression for V1:
Handwritten KCL node equation at node V1: -I0 + V1/Zi + V1/R1 + V1/(Zc1+Z2) + V1/Zc2 + V1/Z0 = 0, then V1 = I0 divided by the sum of reciprocal impedances, with Zi = 100e^(j pi/4) and Z2 = 50 root2 + j50 root2 written beside it.

Handwritten derivation on lined paper headed 'The denominator', showing complex-number arithmetic with fractions and j terms, leading to expressions for V1, I1 and I2 with the ratio I1/I2 = -N2/N1 = -0.1.

Is it correct or?? There are many numbers involved that can easily be computed wrong, but if the idea is correct then these wrongly made computations should not be a problem to find.
 
Your method looks good to me. The equations are OK, but I haven't checked the last page where you substituted the values.
 
Oh okay, thanks for the answer! Then it should be some errors when i substitute and compute. Because when I run it in simulator I get:
Screenshot of an interactive circuit simulator in Split view: a schematic with a 10A current source, R1 1.8kΩ, C1 1.75µF, C2 0.75µF, L1 2.5H, a transformer T1, and R2 4.5Ω, beside a grapher plotting PR2 voltage and PR1 current over time.

Meaning that the topvalue of for example I1 is 7.4 A which is not what I get when i take the absolute value of the expression I got for I1.
 
Now I have cleaned the expressions a bit. I also noticed I forgot the inner impedance in my simulation. Now I for example get the topvalue of I1 in my simulation to 1.400... but in my calculation I get 1.5726... I have checked the computations many times, but see nothing wrong. Can anyone notice some fault?

Screenshot of a circuit simulator showing a schematic with a current source, capacitors, an inductor, a transformer and resistors, beside a plot of current in amperes against time from 3 to 4.25 seconds with a dense green oscillating trace between about -1.4 and 1.4 A.

Handwritten derivation of a current I1 in a transformer circuit: V1 = I0 over a sum of reciprocal impedances, then I1 = V1/Z0 = (N1/N2)^2 (R2 + Z_C3) = 100(R2 + Z_C3), followed by substituted numeric expressions ending with abs() ≈ 1.57261.
 
The problem statement shows that io(t) is in milliamperes, but you seem to used units of amperes. Where you calculated v1 you have 10 in the numerator, but it seems to me that it should be .01
Your simulation doesn't show anything labeled Zi, but it does have R3 which is not in the original circuit. Is R3 the stand-in for Zi in the simulation? If so, there are some numbers in the vicinity of R3 in the simulation schematic that I can't make out; do you have the correct value for Zi in the simulation?

My calculations get the same result as yours if I use 10 for the value of io rather than .01

Here's what I get if io = .01
Mathematica notebook input defining Zin as a nested fraction of Zi, R1, R2, C1, C2, C3, L1 and N1N2 with complex s, followed by numeric values and results 0.946837 and 0.00157261.
 
Last edited:
Yes, so here is the updated figure, with 10mA. R3 resembles Zi and I use 100 ohm, which I guess is right? And yes now I also get I2's topvalue to be 0,00157261A, but this is not the same as the simulation, maybe it is the figure that is wrong?
Screenshot of a circuit simulation with a transformer T1 and components C1, C2, L1, R1, R2, R3 and current source I1, with probe readings i 809.38 µA and i -8.0938 mA, next to a graph of current in A against time in s showing a near-zero green trace with a marker at 3.7709 s, 1.4005 mA.
 
You can't use a value of 100 ohms for Zi (R3) in your simulation and expect to get the same result as your calculation which uses a value for Zi of 70.7 + j 70.7.

In your calculation temporarily change Zi to 100 and see what results you get. Do the results nearly match the simulation results? In the simulation you must replace R3 with a series combination of a resistor and an inductor with values chosen so that the impedance of that combination is 70.7 + j 70.7 (at the frequency of the current source) if you want to get the same result as your calculation.
 
Now I understand, of course can I not replace 100 ohms for Zi. I guess I tried to simulate something I yet do not have enough knowledge of and overcomplicate the problem. And yes when I replace 100 ohms for 70.7+j70.7 in my expression I get almost the identical current I1. Thanks for explaining and using your time to help me! And now it is pretty straightforward to calculate u(t), if I am doing it correct:
Handwritten AC circuit working: I2 = -10 I1 from the turns ratio, then U = -I2 Z2 with Z2 = 4.5 + 1/(j0.25), a simplified expression, then numeric results -0.0767499 - 0.0525752i, and u(t) = 0.0930 sin(1000t - 2.54) V.

Does it seem right?
 
David331 said:
I guess I tried to simulate something I yet do not have enough knowledge of and overcomplicate the problem.
This! This is exactly what I dislike about simulations. They really aren't great for teaching about how things work. They just tell you what will happen, not why.

When I have used simulators, sometimes extensively, most of the work isn't in getting the answers. The real work is in properly defining things, setting up the simulator, verifying the models are good enough, running test cases where you know the answers, etc. Then you know you can trust the answer.

This is roughly the equivalent of teaching arithmetic to an 8 year old versus giving them a calculator.
 
David331 said:
Now I understand, of course can I not replace 100 ohms for Zi. I guess I tried to simulate something I yet do not have enough knowledge of and overcomplicate the problem. And yes when I replace 100 ohms for 70.7+j70.7 in my expression I get almost the identical current I1. Thanks for explaining and using your time to help me! And now it is pretty straightforward to calculate u(t), if I am doing it correct:
View attachment 289911
Does it seem right?
I think you have made some arithmetic mistakes, but I don't have the desire to track them down. Let's go back to post #2 where you have an expression for V1. If I replace the mistaken numerator of 10 with the correct value of .01, you get:

Mathematica-style output: v1 = .01 divided by (sqrt(2)/200 + 469/261000 + i(-sqrt(2)/200 + 4181/3132000)), then // N, Abs[%], giving 0.795017 + 0.514245 i and 0.946837.


This is the same value I get. Since the transformer is ideal, V2 =V1/10 with appropriate sign. You can redo your calculations for the phase angle.
 
Last edited:
I see, so V2 is the voltage on the secondary side of the transfomer. But is V2=U? Because I actually just got (when doublechecking on another calculator website) U=-0.07950...-0.005142...j which is the same as V2 for you. But with wrong signs, so there is just some wrong minus somewhere, I will check for it :)