Another friction and inclined plane question.

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a physics problem involving a trunk being pushed up an inclined plane with friction. The problem requires participants to analyze forces acting on the trunk, including weight components, applied forces, frictional forces, and the coefficient of friction.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Problem interpretation, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants attempt to calculate the component of the trunk's weight along the incline and question the signs of the forces involved. There is discussion about the equilibrium condition since the trunk is moving at a constant velocity, leading to inquiries about the relationships between the applied force, frictional force, and weight components.

Discussion Status

Participants are actively engaging with the problem, questioning assumptions and clarifying concepts. Some have provided partial calculations and reasoning, while others are exploring the implications of their findings. There is no explicit consensus yet, but guidance has been offered regarding the relationships between the forces.

Contextual Notes

Participants note ambiguity in the problem statement regarding the labeling of forces and the need for clarity in sign conventions. There is also acknowledgment of previous learning experiences influencing current problem-solving approaches.

anonymous820
Messages
23
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



you push a 325 Newton trunk up a 20 degree inclined plane at a constant velocity by exerting a 211 Newton force parallel to the planes surface.

a. what is the component of the trunks weight?
b. what is the sum of all the forces parallel to the planes surface?
c. what are the magnitude and direction of the friction force?
d. what is the coefficient of friction?

Homework Equations



----

The Attempt at a Solution



a. sin 20 = Fx/325 --> Fx = 111.2 N?
b. not quite sure because i don't know if the Fx should be positive or negative.
c. 211 N for magnitude? same for Ff? due to equilibrium?
d. Ff= 111.2, Fn= 305.5, coefficient of friction= ?
--> equation --> Ff= coeff*Fn
--> 111.2= coeff*305.5
--> coeff= 0.36? i think.


physics2.jpg


im not exactly sure what the 211 force should be labeled as (the stuff in red). i thought i was supposed to be the applied force, but i don't think that's right.

key:
Fn= normal force
Ff= frictional force
Fg= force due to gravity
Fx= x component
Fy= y component
 
Physics news on Phys.org
anonymous820 said:

Homework Statement



you push a 325 Newton trunk up a 20 degree inclined plane at a constant velocity by exerting a 211 Newton force parallel to the planes surface.

a. what is the component of the trunks weight?
b. what is the sum of all the forces parallel to the planes surface?
c. what are the magnitude and direction of the friction force?
d. what is the coefficient of friction?

Homework Equations



----

The Attempt at a Solution



a. sin 20 = Fx/325 --> Fx = 111.2 N?
If the questions says "what is the component of the trunk's weight acting along the plane" then yes, this is correct. As it stands, the question is ambiguous.
b. not quite sure because i don't know if the Fx should be positive or negative.
The trunk is moving at constant speed.. what does that tell you about the net force acting on the trunk? FYI, Fx should have the opposite sign to the applied force, and the same sign as the frictional force, whatever you choose the sign conventions to be.
c. 211 N for magnitude? same for Ff? due to equilibrium? [/color]
No. The applied force is balanced by the friction and the component of the weight acting parallel to the plane.

BTW, thanks for setting out your problem clearly! :smile:
 
cristo said:
The trunk is moving at constant speed.. what does that tell you about the net force acting on the trunk? FYI, Fx should have the opposite sign to the applied force, and the same sign as the frictional force, whatever you choose the sign conventions to be.

No. The applied force is balanced by the friction and the component of the weight acting parallel to the plane.

BTW, thanks for setting out your problem clearly! :smile:

it tells you that the normal force and the Fy are equal to 325 N?

then, the applied force is negative and Ff and Fx are negative? so then, Fx and the applied are equal? or Fx and Ff are equal? or Fx and Ff are equal to the applied? lol.

..no problem. i figured it was a much better set up than before. that's only because the other one was my first post or whatever and i learned from that one. =)
 
oh yeah. and is d. right? i found the coefficient the same way i found the cofficient in the other problem about the skiing. except this time, they actually gave me real numbers i could work with.
 
anonymous820 said:
it tells you that the normal force and the Fy are equal to 325 N?
That's correct, but the fact that the trunk is moving at a constant velocity tells us that there is no net force acting on the trunk.
then, the applied force is negative and Ff and Fx are negative? so then, Fx and the applied are equal? or Fx and Ff are equal? or Fx and Ff are equal to the applied? lol.
Well, you've given every possible answer there, so one must be correct! Look at your diagram. I'll take positive as going up the ramp, so then the applied force is positive, and Fx and Ff are negative. So, Fa-Fx-Ff=0 => Fa=Fx+Ff.

..no problem. i figured it was a much better set up than before. that's only because the other one was my first post or whatever and i learned from that one. =)
[/quote]
Exactly! I don't think anyone minds a sloppy first post, but I think I speak for all homework helpers here; we appreciate when someone learns and posts a clear second question!

anonymous820 said:
oh yeah. and is d. right? i found the coefficient the same way i found the cofficient in the other problem about the skiing. except this time, they actually gave me real numbers i could work with.

I left d because your answer to c isn't correct, yet.
 
cristo said:
Well, you've given every possible answer there, so one must be correct! Look at your diagram. I'll take positive as going up the ramp, so then the applied force is positive, and Fx and Ff are negative. So, Fa-Fx-Ff=0 => Fa=Fx+Ff.

I left d because your answer to c isn't correct, yet.

there was no point in b. that was the dumbest question possible. I am so slow. its in equilibrium, so therefore, the sum of all the forces is 0, duh. wow.

lol. yet. but i will be soon =)

i don't quite understand what I am doing for question c. 211 N?
 
Last edited:
c says "what is the magnitude and direction of the frictional force?" You have this: Fa=Fx+Ff => Ff=Fa-Fx, where Fa is the applied force. You know Fa (211) and Fx (111.2), so plug into this equation. This gives the magnitude of the frictional force. Then its direction is, clearly, down the slope.

After you've done this, you can use Ff=(coefficient of friction)Fn to find the coefficient of friction.
 
oh okay. so i pretty much already found c from question b. alright. thank you.
 
anonymous820 said:
oh okay. so i pretty much already found c from question b. alright. thank you.
You're welcome.
 

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
686
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
9K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
5K
  • · Replies 27 ·
Replies
27
Views
4K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
4K