Are there really only 4 grains of salt in the entire universe?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ilikedogs
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Atoms
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on a curiosity about the number of atoms in a grain of salt, estimated at around 10^18, compared to the estimated total number of elementary particles in the universe, around 10^80. The original poster questions the compatibility of these figures, suggesting that if taken literally, it would imply the universe contains only about four grains of salt. A chemist's input confirms Sagan's estimate of atoms in salt is accurate, while also noting that the universe contains vastly more atoms than just those in a grain of salt. The conversation highlights confusion around exponential notation and the interpretation of these scientific estimates. Overall, the thread explores the relationship between these numbers and clarifies misconceptions regarding the scale of the universe.
Ilikedogs
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
What's up everybody,

I have a curiosity that struck me today and I figure some people here could probably provide some insight on. Today I was reading the book Broca's brain by Carl Sagan, and in it he pegs the number of atoms in a grain of salt to be around 1018. However, in the same passage, he provides the number of "elementary particles" to be around 1080. I think he may have meant atoms by that, since I've seen numbers very close to that considered to be the number of atoms in the OU. I'm not extremely adept at math, but how are these two numbers compatable? Wouldn't the universe then necessarily be comprised of only about 4 grains of salt?

I know that this book was written about 30 years ago or so, and that a lot has changed in the interim, but I asked my dad (who works as a chemist for AstraZeneca), and he said that Sagans estimate of atoms in salt was basically on point. The 1080 estimate is also found here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Observable_universe (last paragraph in the intro). So, what gives?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I may have mis-understood what you said, but if you're suggesting that 1018 * 4 = 1072, this isn't true at all. By Sagan's estimation, and if the number of atoms in the universe is 1080, then the universe has 1062 more atoms than there are in a grain of salt.
 
Last edited:
Nah, you understood. Exponential notation is strange animal to me, lol.
 
Back
Top