Are You an Engineer? A few questions

  • Thread starter Thread starter Seeknay25
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Engineer
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around a student seeking insights from experienced engineers for an interview project related to the field of engineering. The questions cover various aspects of engineering careers, including education, work experience, project involvement, and job satisfaction.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants share their current fields, including internal combustion engine development and offshore oil and gas exploration.
  • Responses vary regarding whether the current field aligns with their high school expectations.
  • Degrees obtained by participants include Mechanical Engineering and Electromechanical Engineering, among others.
  • Some participants decided on their fields before attending college, while others did not.
  • Work experience ranges from 2 to 8 years, with specialties such as IC engine performance and subsea systems mentioned.
  • Project durations reported by participants vary, with some stating 6-24 months and others averaging around 3 years.
  • Specific tools and equipment required for jobs include software for analysis and instrumentation for monitoring parameters.
  • Working styles differ, with some preferring team-based work while others work alone, citing advantages and disadvantages for both approaches.
  • Participants discuss the distribution of employers, noting concentrations in industrial areas and specific regions like the Gulf states.
  • Salary expectations vary widely, with reported figures for entry-level, average, and top pay across different fields of engineering.
  • Work hours reported range from 37 to 50 hours per week, with further education opportunities mentioned by some participants.
  • Advice for entering civil engineering is limited, with some participants suggesting personal research and reflection on career choices.
  • Participants express varying levels of job satisfaction, with ratings and personal reflections shared.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

There is no consensus on many aspects, as participants provide differing experiences and perspectives on their fields, work styles, and job satisfaction.

Contextual Notes

Responses are based on individual experiences and may not represent broader trends or norms in engineering fields. Variability in job roles, project types, and personal satisfaction is evident.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for students considering a career in engineering, professionals seeking insights into different engineering fields, or anyone interested in the experiences of engineers in various specialties.

Seeknay25
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Are You an Engineer? A few questions...

Hello everybody, I'm a current student going into electrical engineer and as a first task I'm being told to interview a skilled engineer., and I'm hoping I can find one here :)

I just got a some questions that would help me greatly with this project and it would be great if a few people could spend a minutes answering them. It would be nice if you left an email address after you answer the questions, but you don't have to. If you want to add any additional information feel free to do so. Also it would be best if you just quoted my thread and answered the questions that way. Your few minutes will be greatly appreciated. Also, if its a yes or no answer, such as the second one, it would be nice if you elaborated with your answer, but its not needed.

Q1: What current field are you in?

Q2: Is this what you thought you were going to do in high school?

Q3: What degree did you get in college?

Q4: Did you decide on this field before attending your college?

Q5: How long have you worked in your profession?

Q6: What is your specialty in your field of engineering?

Q7: What are some of the projects you've worked on?

Q8: How much time do most projects take?

Q9: Are there any specific tools or equipment required for your job?

Q10: Do you generally work alone or in a group of two or more?

Q11: What advantages/ disadvantages do you find while working alone, or in a group.

Q12:Do most people in you field work the same as you (In a group or alone)?

Q13:Are employers evenly distributed or are they concentrated in certain areas of the country?

Q14: What are the beginning, average, and top pay one could expect to earn in you field of engineering?

Q15: How many hours do you work per week?

Q16: Is there further education offered where you work?

Q17: Do you have any advice for someone looking to go into civil engineering?

Q18: What do you feel your biggest accomplishment is, involving your work, or how you got there?

Q19: How happy are you with what you do?

Email: (Not needed, but it would be nice for reference)

-Thank you very much​
 
Last edited:
Engineering news on Phys.org
I'm not able to spend much time on your questions at the moment (sorry -- tight schedules right now), but here's a link to a similar interview that I did have time for a couple months back. Hope it helps some.

https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=186089
 
Q1: What current field are you in?
Internal combustion engine development

Q2: Is this what you thought you were going to do in high school?
Probably not too far off what I hoped I'd be doing.

Q3: What degree did you get in college?

Bachelors degree in Mechanical Engineering

Q4: Did you decide on this field before attending your college?
Yes.

Q5: How long have you worked in your profession?
2 years.

Q6: What is your specialty in your field of engineering?
IC engine performance.

Q7: What are some of the projects you've worked on?
Development and support of large industrial Diesel and gas engines.

Q8: How much time do most projects take?
6-24 months typically.

Q9: Are there any specific tools or equipment required for your job?
A PC with various bits of software, and all kinds of pieces of instrumentation for monitoring engine operating parameters.

Q10: Do you generally work alone or in a group of two or more?

It's all team-based work split into tasks to be carried out by individuals.

Q11: What advantages/ disadvantages do you find while working alone, or in a group.
Working alone gives freedom to solve problems how I wish, and I enjoy owning my own projects and being responsible for all aspects of them. Team working (if done properly) gets you at an optimum solution a lot quicker.

Q12:Do most people in you field work the same as you (In a group or alone)?
Yes.

Q13:Are employers evenly distributed or are they concentrated in certain areas of the country?
Tend to be concentrated around traditionally industrial areas.

Q14: What are the beginning, average, and top pay one could expect to earn in you field of engineering?
In the UK, an engineering intern would earn around £14k, a graduate somewhere between £20k and £30k, and a Chartered Engineer (working directly as an engineer) between £40k and £60k. Obviously if you own your own business things can be different.

Q15: How many hours do you work per week?
Contracted to 37, but typically 45 or 50.

Q16: Is there further education offered where you work?
Yes.

Q17: Do you have any advice for someone looking to go into civil engineering?
Not really, I looked at this field for a few years before I changed my mind and decided on mechanical. It's a personal choice. The main thing is to do your research and make sure engineering (and civil engineering) is what you think it is.

Q18: What do you feel your biggest accomplishment is, involving your work, or how you got there?
Doing the work. Getting the job is just a means to an end.

Q19: How happy are you with what you do?
9 out of 10.

Email: (Not needed, but it would be nice for reference)
Sorry, any more info you want just ask.
 
Q1: What current field are you in?
Offshore Oil and Gas Exploration (Ultra Deep Water - 5,000 to 12,000 feet).

Q2: Is this what you thought you were going to do in high school?
No.

Q3: What degree did you get in college?
1st: BS Business Admin., 2nd: BS Electromechanical Engineering.

Q4: Did you decide on this field before attending your college?
Yes.

Q5: How long have you worked in your profession?
8 years.

Q6: What is your specialty in your field of engineering?
Subsea Systems.

Q7: What are some of the projects you've worked on?
Design and construction of Mobile Offshore Drilling Units.

Q8: How much time do most projects take?
Average is about 3 years.

Q9: Are there any specific tools or equipment required for your job?
Lot's of analysis software that the company isn't will to buy!

Q10: Do you generally work alone or in a group of two or more?
Alone.

Q11: What advantages/ disadvantages do you find while working alone, or in a group.
Working alone is good if you are a self-starter, I find it less distracting.

Q12:Do most people in you field work the same as you (In a group or alone)?
Yes.

Q13:Are employers evenly distributed or are they concentrated in certain areas of the country?
Concentrated in the Gulf states.

Q14: What are the beginning, average, and top pay one could expect to earn in you field of engineering?
Just straight salary without bonus or anything,
Begining - $80K
Average - $120K
Top - $180K (not sure about this one).

Q15: How many hours do you work per week?
40.

Q16: Is there further education offered where you work?
Yes.

Q17: Do you have any advice for someone looking to go into civil engineering?
No.

Q18: What do you feel your biggest accomplishment is, involving your work, or how you got there?
Never really thought about it.

Q19: How happy are you with what you do?
I'm content.
 
Thanks a bunch guys
 

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
4K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
5K