Banked curve: question about friction and normal force

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the dynamics of a car negotiating a banked curve, specifically focusing on the roles of friction and normal force at different speeds. Participants explore the conditions under which friction acts and how the normal force varies with speed, examining both theoretical and conceptual aspects of the problem.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest that a car on a banked curve at a specific speed (V0) does not experience friction, while at speeds above or below V0, friction acts in different directions to either assist in turning or prevent sliding.
  • It is noted that kinetic friction is relatively constant, whereas static friction adjusts as necessary until it reaches a limit defined by the coefficient of static friction and normal force.
  • Participants discuss how the normal force changes when driving on a banked curve, with some asserting that it is dependent on speed due to the need to balance various forces acting on the car.
  • One participant outlines the four forces involved in the scenario: gravitational weight, centripetal reaction force, normal force, and the force parallel to the road surface, indicating that these forces interact differently at varying speeds.
  • There is a question raised about the nature of the centripetal force and whether it should be considered in calculations, with some participants debating the concept of fictitious forces.
  • Requests for visual aids, such as free body diagrams, are made to clarify the interactions of these forces.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express varying views on the nature of friction and the normal force, leading to an unresolved discussion regarding the exact relationships and dependencies of these forces on speed. No consensus is reached on the interpretation of the centripetal force.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight the complexity of the forces involved and the conditions under which they change, indicating that assumptions about the system may affect the analysis. The discussion remains open to interpretation and further exploration.

swell9
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Hello,

From what I understand a car negotiating a banked cruve of angle \theta at a speed V0 does not experience a force of friction.

But if the car goes to a speed higher than V0, then friction acts in the direction of the cruve. i.e. inwards
And if the car goes at a speed lower than V0, then friction acts in the opposite direction of the incline.
i.e. up the incline thus preventing the car from sliding inwards.

How does friction change? is it not it a constant force? To me this all seems like friction knows what's happening and thus acts accordingly to help the car make it around the curve or prevent it from sliding


Thanks a lot
swell9
 
Physics news on Phys.org
swell9 said:
How does friction change? is it not it a constant force?

Kinetic (sliding) friction is constant (more or less). Static friction adjusts itself as necessary to keep the two surfaces stuck together, until it reaches the limit given by \mu_s F_N. It changes the same way as when you push harder against a stationary wall, the reaction force the wall exerts on you also increases.

Friction between tires and road is static friction until you spin out and the tires start to skid.
 
jtbell said:
Kinetic (sliding) friction is constant (more or less). Static friction adjusts itself as necessary to keep the two surfaces stuck together, until it reaches the limit given by \mu_s F_N. It changes the same way as when you push harder against a stationary wall, the reaction force the wall exerts on you also increases.

Friction between tires and road is static friction until you spin out and the tires start to skid.



Thank you.. I see.. but then, why does the normal force change?
does that mean it is speed dependent?

thanks
 
The normal force is also a reaction force, keeps the car from falling through the ground. So it is going to change if you drive a banked curve (centripetal force: F = m*v2/r).
 
log0 said:
The normal force is also a reaction force, keeps the car from falling through the ground. So it is going to change if you drive a banked curve (centripetal force: F = m*v2/r).

thanks for the help.
So the normal force is dependent upon speed in this case. I guess I cannot see how speed changes the normal force...
 
There are 4 forces involved:

the weight of the car due to gravity (downwards)
the reaction force from the car related to centrpetal acceleration of the car (outwards)
the force from the road perpendicular to the road's surface (always away from the road)
the force from the road parallel to the road's surface (could be downwards+inwards or upwards+outwards)

At V0 the force parallel to the road's surface is zero, because the force from the road perpendicular to the surface of the road is equal and opposing to the vector sum of forces related to the weight of the car and the cars reaction to centripetal acceleration.

At speeds other than V0, then a component of force parallel to the surface is involved. At speeds less than V0, an upwards (and outwards force) parallel to the surface is required to counter a component of weight (gravity). At speeds greather than V0, an inwards (and downwards) force parallel to the surface is required counter the reaction force related to centripetal acceleration of the car. The force perpendicular to the road will be also be affected by speed, smaller at speeds lower than V0, greater at speeds above V0.

Note that the reaction force is just that, a reaction to acceleration. The rate of acceleration is the vector sum of the other 3 forces divided by the mass of the car.
 
Last edited:
Jeff Reid said:
There are 4 forces involved:

the weight of the car due to gravity (downwards)
the reaction force from the car related to centrpetal acceleration of the car (outwards)
the force from the road perpendicular to the road's surface (always away from the road)
the force from the road parallel to the road's surface (could be downwards+inwards or upwards+outwards)

At V0 the force parallel to the road's surface is zero, because the force from the road perpendicular to the surface of the road is equal and opposing to the vector sum of forces related to the weight of the car and the cars reaction to centripetal acceleration.

At speeds other than V0, then a component of force parallel to the surface is involved. At speeds less than V0, an upwards (and outwards force) parallel to the surface is required to counter a component of weight (gravity). At speeds greather than V0, an inwards (and downwards) force parallel to the surface is required counter the reaction force related to centripetal acceleration of the car. The force perpendicular to the road will be also be affected by speed, smaller at speeds lower than V0, greater at speeds above V0.

Note that the reaction force is just that, a reaction to acceleration. The rate of acceleration is the vector sum of the other 3 forces divided by the mass of the car.

Thanks a lot.
I never knew there were so many forces.

the weight of the car due to gravity (downwards)
>> This would be the weight, correct?
the reaction force from the car related to centrpetal acceleration of the car (outwards)
>> isn't this force the centrifugal force and thus is a fictitious force? meaning we should not consider it in our calculations...
the force from the road perpendicular to the road's surface (always away from the road)
>> This is just the normal force, correct?
the force from the road parallel to the road's surface (could be downwards+inwards or upwards+outwards)
>> and this would be static friction?

If you could show me a FBD, that would be great too :)

agains thank for your time
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
5K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 35 ·
2
Replies
35
Views
5K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 73 ·
3
Replies
73
Views
11K
  • · Replies 24 ·
Replies
24
Views
5K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K