Banked road (find the minimum radius)

2 replies · 3K views · last reply
farleyknight
Messages
143
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Physics problem text about banking a curved road, with a cyan diagram of a car at rest on an inclined ramp, angle theta marked between the incline and a dashed horizontal line.


I've already answered the first part. The second part is what's giving me trouble.

Homework Equations



Here's how I solved #10:

Since the car is at rest, we're only worried about the force of friction and the parallel component of gravity:

F_f = F_g * sin(theta) = m * g * sin(theta)

Since F_f = mu_s * F_N = mu_s * F_g * cos(theta) = mu_s * m * g * cos(theta)

Then:

mu_s * m * g * cos(theta) = m * g * sin(theta)

Solving for theta, we get:

mu_s = tan(theta)

Or arctan(mu_s) = theta

The Attempt at a Solution



The second situation is different. We need to know the radius, and that is only involved when we have the centripetal force (F_C).

In this case, we are worried about having enough F_C to keep the car from veering off. Now the force of friction is equal, but going in the opposite direction (the same direction as the parallel component of gravity):

F_C * cos(theta) = F_f + F_g * sin(theta)

We already have F_f = mu_s * m * g * cos(theta), and F_g * sin(theta) = m * g * sin(theta). Also, since we're dealing with centripetal force, the proper equation for acceleration is:

m * a = m * (v^2 / R)

So that gives:

F_C * cos(theta) = m * (v^2 / R) = mu_s * m * g * cos(theta) + m * g * sin(theta)

Cancelling m and dividing by cos(theta):

(v^2 / R) = mu_s * g + g * tan(theta)

Since tan(theta) = mu_s:

(v^2 / R) = 2 * mu_s * g

This equation makes sense, to me, because previously we requires the parallel gravitation component to be equal (and opposite) to force of friction. Now we require that both of those forces act together to keep the car on the road, thus giving 2 * mu_s * g.

Solving for R:

R = v^2 / (2 * mu_s * g)

Which is dimensionally correct. Punching the values into my calculator gives:

v^2 / (2 * mu_s * g) = (50/3)^2 / (2 * 0.15 * 9.81) = 94.38592517

But this was rejected :(

Any idea where my mistake is at?
 
farleyknight said:

Homework Statement



Physics problem page showing a cyan car parked on a banked ramp with angle theta marked at its base, above the text of parts 1 and 2 about banking a curved road with ice and friction.


I've already answered the first part. The second part is what's giving me trouble.

Homework Equations



Here's how I solved #10:

Since the car is at rest, we're only worried about the force of friction and the parallel component of gravity:

F_f = F_g * sin(theta) = m * g * sin(theta)

Since F_f = mu_s * F_N = mu_s * F_g * cos(theta) = mu_s * m * g * cos(theta)

Then:

mu_s * m * g * cos(theta) = m * g * sin(theta)

Solving for theta, we get:

mu_s = tan(theta)

Or arctan(mu_s) = theta

The Attempt at a Solution



The second situation is different. We need to know the radius, and that is only involved when we have the centripetal force (F_C).

In this case, we are worried about having enough F_C to keep the car from veering off. Now the force of friction is equal, but going in the opposite direction (the same direction as the parallel component of gravity):

F_C * cos(theta) = F_f + F_g * sin(theta)

We already have F_f = mu_s * m * g * cos(theta), and F_g * sin(theta) = m * g * sin(theta). Also, since we're dealing with centripetal force, the proper equation for acceleration is:

m * a = m * (v^2 / R)

So that gives:

F_C * cos(theta) = m * (v^2 / R) = mu_s * m * g * cos(theta) + m * g * sin(theta)

Cancelling m and dividing by cos(theta):

(v^2 / R) = mu_s * g + g * tan(theta)

Since tan(theta) = mu_s:

(v^2 / R) = 2 * mu_s * g

This equation makes sense, to me, because previously we requires the parallel gravitation component to be equal (and opposite) to force of friction. Now we require that both of those forces act together to keep the car on the road, thus giving 2 * mu_s * g.

Solving for R:

R = v^2 / (2 * mu_s * g)

Which is dimensionally correct. Punching the values into my calculator gives:

v^2 / (2 * mu_s * g) = (50/3)^2 / (2 * 0.15 * 9.81) = 94.38592517

But this was rejected :(

Any idea where my mistake is at?


When a car is traveling around a banked track, the Normal reaction force is higher than when it is parked on the track [a similar thing happens when a car is driven through a dip rather than parked in a dip]. This increases the frictional force, an Fn is bigger.