BJT Switch - Circuit Simulation

5 replies · 4K views · last reply
dwn
Messages
165
Reaction score
2
I am reading The Art Of Electronics, and I realize this is more of an encyclopedia rather than a textbook. I have referenced other sources as this has mainly served as a compass for me to learn about each subject area.

My question is fairly simple and straightforward. I'm using multisim to replicate a circuit that was provided in the book. The author used a simple transistor switch to light an LED, to explain the function of a BJT. When I went to simulate the circuit, the LED lights up, even though it should not, at least until the SPST is closed.
What is causing the transistor to act like a short?

As far as I understand it, the collector is an open circuit, until the point in which the VB ≈ VE + VBE, at which point the collector would be saturated.
 
Attachments
  • Circuit schematic of an NPN BJT switch: 1V source through a key A switch and 5Ω resistor to the base, 10V supply to the collector, emitter to ground, and an output node labelled 10V.
    IMG_3688-1.JPG
    110.3 KB · Views: 802
dwn said:
My question is fairly simple and straightforward. I'm using multisim to replicate a circuit that was provided in the book. The author used a simple transistor switch to light an LED, to explain the function of a BJT. When I went to simulate the circuit, the LED lights up, even though it should not, at least until the SPST is closed.
What is causing the transistor to act like a short?

hi there
there is no LED in your circuit
also, because you have no resistance in either the collector or emitter circuit of the transistor, it's possible you have killed it with excess current
and it has failed in short circuit mode

so redo your circuit with the LED and it's current limiting series resistor, for a 10V supply it should be around 1k Ohm
cheers
Dave
 
dwn said:
As far as I understand it, the collector is an open circuit, until the point in which the VB ≈ VE + VBE, at which point the collector would be saturated.

As a general rule the bjt transistor will go into conduction with ~ 0.7 - 0.8V on the base
for any voltage higher than that, it will be in saturation
( caveat ... higher power bjt transistors require a bit more base voltage)Dave
 
dwn said:
I am reading The Art Of Electronics, and I realize this is more of an encyclopedia rather than a textbook. I have referenced other sources as this has mainly served as a compass for me to learn about each subject area.

My question is fairly simple and straightforward. I'm using multisim to replicate a circuit that was provided in the book. The author used a simple transistor switch to light an LED, to explain the function of a BJT. When I went to simulate the circuit, the LED lights up, even though it should not, at least until the SPST is closed.
What is causing the transistor to act like a short?

As far as I understand it, the collector is an open circuit, until the point in which the VB ≈ VE + VBE, at which point the collector would be saturated.
Here are a couple of BJT LED drive circuits that you can start simulating...

http://i.stack.imgur.com/OnVwa.png
Schematic of two BJT LED driver circuits side by side: left, PNP-style Q3 2N3904 with R6 1 kΩ base resistor, R5 500 Ω and LED D3 LTL-307EE from VDD; right, Q1 2N3904 with R2 1 kΩ, R7 500 Ω and LED D4 LTL-307EE to ground.


And a Common-Emitter amplifier stage like above will have a V-I characteristic like this:

http://sub.allaboutcircuits.com/images/quiz/02244x01.png
Graph of collector current I_C in mA against collector-emitter voltage V_CE in V, with seven blue curves for base currents I_B from 10 µA to 150 µA, rising steeply then flattening.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: davenn
davenn said:
hi there
there is no LED in your circuit
also, because you have no resistance in either the collector or emitter circuit of the transistor, it's possible you have killed it with excess current
and it has failed in short circuit mode

so redo your circuit with the LED and it's current limiting series resistor, for a 10V supply it should be around 1k Ohm
cheers
Dave
Thank you Dave, silly mistake thinking that the light probe was multisims version of the LED. After changing that and adjusting the components to their original values everything worked as expected.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: davenn
dwn said:
Thank you Dave, silly mistake thinking that the light probe was multisims version of the LED. After changing that and adjusting the components to their original values everything worked as expected.
cool :smile:

look at the variations that berkeman also posted