Calculating Volume of a Cylindrical Wedge

3 replies · 3K views · last reply
unscientific
Messages
1,728
Reaction score
13

Homework Statement



The problem is attached in the picture.



The Attempt at a Solution



What bothers me is that they say the wedge is bounded by x + z = a. Doesn't this imply that the calculated volume should only be half of what is written in the answers? I'm aware that the plane x + z = a can refer to either the left (negative) side or the right (positive) side. Do we choose one or simply take both?

Limits for x: 0 to a
Limits for y: 0 to √4ax
Limits for z: 0 to a-x


However, in http://mathworld.wolfram.com/CylindricalWedge.html the wedge is given as the full volume.
 
Attachments
  • Sketch of 3D coordinate axes x, y, z with a black slanted line in the x-z plane, a blue segment labeled a on the z axis and a red curve in the y direction; a small dashed-outline triangle sketch to the right.
    wedge.jpg
    13.1 KB · Views: 533
  • Textbook page showing problem 6.1 on finding the volume of a curved wedge bounded by y^2 = 4ax, x + z = a and z = 0, with two equivalent integral calculations giving V = 16/15 a^3.
    wedge2.jpg
    40.2 KB · Views: 498
You have two possibilities: if a>0, then x>0 and z>0. If a<0, then also x<0 and z<0. No value of a works for both regions.
 
unscientific said:

Homework Statement



The problem is attached in the picture.



The Attempt at a Solution



What bothers me is that they say the wedge is bounded by x + z = a. Doesn't this imply that the calculated volume should only be half of what is written in the answers? I'm aware that the plane x + z = a can refer to either the left (negative) side or the right (positive) side. Do we choose one or simply take both?

Limits for x: 0 to a
Limits for y: 0 to √4ax
Limits for z: 0 to a-x

Assuming ##a>0##, the slanted plane is the "roof" of the solid. I see no reason to limit ##y## to only being positive.
 
LCKurtz said:
Assuming ##a>0##, the slanted plane is the "roof" of the solid. I see no reason to limit ##y## to only being positive.

I see! I initially thought that the x + z = a plane refers to the vertical plane i.e. the x-z plane. But now that you mention it, it actually refers to the plane that is sloping downwards from z = a to x = a, like a ramp.