Can a horseshoe magnet without separated poles still function as a magnet?

In summary, if you fuse the north and South Poles of a horseshoe magnet together without destroying the magnetic field, you will have a ring of magnetized material with very little external field. The interior will likely be at saturation magnetization and it will be otherwise unremarkable. This is because the horseshoe magnet is made up of tiny magnetic atoms/molecules that are aligned North to South, creating a complete circuit of magnetic flux. By bending the magnet, you are essentially creating a smaller version of this circuit, making the whole magnet act like the center section did before it was bent. The availability of the magnetic flux can be tested by seeing how well the magnet attracts different materials, and can be controlled by using different materials to channel
  • #1
Steven Ellet
85
3
If you take a horseshoe magnet and fuse the north and South Poles together (without destroying the magnetic field) would you have a “pole-less” magnet? And if so, what special properties would it have(other than other magnets)?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Steven Ellet said:
Summary:: Any special properties of a circular magnetic field?

fuse the north and South Poles together (without destroying the magnetic field)
You will have a ring of magnetized material with very little external field. Likely the interior will be at saturation magnetization. It will be otherwise unremarkable.
 
  • Like
Likes Vanadium 50 and Steven Ellet
  • #3
That horseshoe magnet is really made up of innumerable tiny magnetic atoms/molecules, ferromagnetic things like FE, Ni, Co, Nd... Each of these tiny magnets is aligned N-pole to S-pole. The magnetic flux they create is channeled through all of that magnetic material until it ends at the N and S poles of the horseshoe. Then in order for the magnetic flux to make a complete circuit (which is what magnetic flux always has to do) it has to travel through the air to get to the opposite pole. So, the thing that makes that appear like a magnet to you is that you, or other materials, have access to the unrestrained magnetic flux. So if you bent the magnet until the N & S poles were touching, the whole magnet would act like the center section did before you bent it. It's still a magnet, the flux is still in there, you just can't get to it very easily.

You can try some experiments to see this. You can test the availability of the flux by seeing how well it attracts iron/steel objects. See if you can extend the N pole of the magnet by putting a steel bolt on the end; are other bolts attracted to the original N pole, or the new one you created at the end of the bolt? This is like what the atoms in the middle of the magnet are doing too. Then attach the magnet to a long iron/steel bar that connects the N & S poles and test how well it attracts other objects this way. In this case you have contained the flux through it's entire path so very little is available to travel through the air. Now try some of these experiments with aluminum, wood, or plastic and see if that works too. Magnetic flux travels more easily through iron than air (this is a material property called permeability or reluctance), so you can control where it goes with different materials, kind of like electrons in a circuit.
 
  • Like
Likes diogenesNY and hutchphd

Related to Can a horseshoe magnet without separated poles still function as a magnet?

1. Can a horseshoe magnet without separated poles still attract metal objects?

Yes, a horseshoe magnet without separated poles can still attract metal objects. The magnetism is still present in the entire magnet, not just at the poles.

2. Will a horseshoe magnet without separated poles have the same strength as one with separated poles?

No, a horseshoe magnet without separated poles will not have the same strength as one with separated poles. The separated poles allow for a stronger concentration of magnetic field, making the magnet stronger.

3. Can a horseshoe magnet without separated poles be used to pick up heavier objects?

Yes, a horseshoe magnet without separated poles can still be used to pick up heavier objects. The magnet's strength may be slightly weaker, but it can still attract and hold onto heavier objects.

4. Is there a specific way to use a horseshoe magnet without separated poles?

No, there is no specific way to use a horseshoe magnet without separated poles. It can be used just like any other magnet, by placing it near the object you want to attract.

5. Can a horseshoe magnet without separated poles be demagnetized?

Yes, a horseshoe magnet without separated poles can be demagnetized. This can happen if the magnet is exposed to high temperatures or strong magnetic fields, or if it is dropped or hit with force.

Similar threads

  • Electromagnetism
Replies
10
Views
969
Replies
6
Views
833
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
11
Views
1K
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
32
Views
1K
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
863
Back
Top