Additya
- 1
- 0
Can a wire be called a resistor? Also do all circuits require a resistor? If no then give an example of a circuit which doesn't have a resistor. Please thanks
The discussion revolves around whether a wire can be classified as a resistor and whether all circuits require a resistor. Participants explore the implications of wire resistance in various contexts, including theoretical and practical circuit scenarios.
Participants generally agree that wires have resistance, but there is disagreement on the classification of wires as resistors and the necessity of resistors in all circuits. Multiple competing views remain regarding the implications of wire resistance and the existence of circuits without resistors.
Participants note that the context of the circuit (theoretical vs. practical) affects the discussion of wire resistance and its significance. There are unresolved assumptions about what constitutes a resistor and the conditions under which wire resistance is considered negligible.

Additya said:Can a wire be called a resistor? Also do all circuits require a resistor? If no then give an example of a circuit which doesn't have a resistor. Please thanks
In most cases, wires have resistance. Some resistors are basically wires. Sometimes the resistance provided wires is important to the function of the circuit - in which case you would expect them to be in the circuit diagram.Additya said:Can a wire be called a resistor? Also do all circuits require a resistor? If no then give an example of a circuit which doesn't have a resistor. Please thanks
Talk to an Electrical Power Engineer. Despite the fact that their 'wires' tend to be very thick, they are also very long and their resistance accounts for a significant proportion of your Electricity Bill.Additya said:Can a wire be called a resistor? Also do all circuits require a resistor? If no then give an example of a circuit which doesn't have a resistor. Please thanks
Comeback City said:For the second question, I suppose you could have a circuit without a resistor, but I don't see what the point of it would be.