Electrical potential energy questions for a battery circuit

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around questions related to electrical potential energy in battery circuits, focusing on the behavior of current, potential differences, and the functioning of batteries. Participants explore theoretical concepts and practical implications within the context of simple electrical circuits.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant questions why current does not flow through the battery itself instead of through the connecting wire, suggesting a potential difference is necessary.
  • Another participant asserts that current does lose electrical potential energy when moving through the circuit, indicating that this energy is converted into thermal and light energy in devices like light bulbs.
  • Concerns are raised about why the potential drop across resistors in parallel is equal to the battery voltage, with a participant explaining that the wire acts as an equipotential region.
  • Questions about battery functionality are posed, including the source of charge and whether the voltage remains constant, with responses indicating that chemical reactions within the battery eventually deplete resources, leading to a loss of voltage.
  • A detailed explanation of the chemical processes in a battery is provided, describing how reactions at the anode and cathode create a potential difference and how equilibrium affects current flow.
  • Another participant emphasizes that the potential difference across connected components reflects the electrode potentials and that resistors in parallel see the same potential difference due to their direct connection to the battery terminals.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express multiple competing views regarding the behavior of current in circuits, the conversion of potential energy, and the functioning of batteries. The discussion remains unresolved on several points, particularly regarding the nuances of battery chemistry and the implications of potential differences in various configurations.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention limitations related to the chemical reactions in batteries, the effects of temperature, and the impact of current flow on battery performance. There are also references to the behavior of ions and the physical state of electrodes, which may influence the overall understanding of battery function.

Theonefrom1994
Messages
15
Reaction score
5
I’m trying to learn about simple circuits but I have a few questions because I don’t fully understand what’s going on .

1. If the reason current flows when a wire is connected to the ends of a battery is due to a potential difference across a battery , why can’t the current just flow through the battery instead of going around through the wire?

2. When the current goes from one end of the battery to the other does it lose all of its electrical potential energy ? Where does this energy go? Is The potential energy used to light a light bulb for example?
3. If you have resistors in parallel connected to a battery, why is the potential drop across each resistor the same as the Voltage of the battery?

4. Why do batteries stop working ? Where are they getting their charge from and is Voltage across the battery really always the same ?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Theonefrom1994 said:
1. If the reason current flows when a wire is connected to the ends of a battery is due to a potential difference across a battery , why can’t the current just flow through the battery instead of going around through the wire?
There is a chemical reaction in the battery that pushes current the usual way.

Theonefrom1994 said:
2. When the current goes from one end of the battery to the other does it lose all of its electrical potential energy ? Where does this energy go? Is The potential energy used to light a light bulb for example?
Yes. In your example the potential energy would be converted into thermal energy and light energy by the light bulb.

Theonefrom1994 said:
3. If you have resistors in parallel connected to a battery, why is the potential drop across each resistor the same as the Voltage of the battery?
Ideally, a wire has the same voltage everywhere. It is an equipotential region. So the wire connected to the + end of the battery has the voltage of the + end of the battery everywhere, and similarly with the - end. Since each resistor is connected to the same two wires the voltage across each resistor is the same and is equal to the voltage across the battery.

Theonefrom1994 said:
4. Why do batteries stop working ? Where are they getting their charge from and is Voltage across the battery really always the same ?
Eventually the chemical reaction I mentioned in the first part runs out. Then it loses voltage and cannot push any more power.
 
It's not voltage (i.e., potential difference) but electromotive force!
 
1 - Look at how a cell in a battery works. Eg. a Daniel cell. At the anode a zinc plate is put into the solution and some zinc atoms dissolve, leaving their electrons behind. At first this is easy. The Zn++ ions are attracted back by the electrons, but the water molecules are attracted to them and they are quickly surrounded by first 6, then more, distancing them and making them less attracted to the electrons on the anode. But as more Zn atoms dissolve, there are more electrons left behind and their combined attraction for the Zn++ ions becomes so strong that atoms no longer dissolve. The anode now has a negative charge.

At the cathode an opposite reaction is occurring with Cu++ ions coming out of solution onto the copper cathode. (The opposite behaviour of Cu here is related to its electron structure making it less attractive to water molecules and more to be part of solid copper. You'll have to ask Borek for better explanation of that.)
Again there is a limit to this. Once the cathode is positively charged sufficiently, it repels any further ions from depositing.

Now you have an equilibrium. Nothing more will change. The anode has excess electrons and the cathode a deficiency. The electrons can only get from one to the other by reversing the reactions That doen't happen because the reactions have reached their balance point, where it would require an input of energy to make it change.
Once you connect a wire between them, problem solved. Electrons can leave the anode and enter the cathode reducing the charge on both. But as soon as that happens, they have disturbed the equilibrium and the reactions carry on, at the rate allowed by the current. When you disconnect, the reactions stop because the equilibria are reestablished.

The potential difference between the electrodes reflects the difference in the charges on the electrodes at equilibrium with the solutions, which in turn reflects the chemical energy change of atoms going into or coming out of solution.

4- Chemical energy from the ionic reactions produces electrical PE. That causes a current which dissipates energy (produces heat) in the resistance of the circuit. Everything balances. Just the right amount of Zinc dissolves to maintain the electric potential at the electrodes and the current through the circuit. If you let more current flow, say adding bulbs in parallel, then the reactions go faster and more Zn dissolves.
When there is no more zinc left - or usually the remaining zinc has disintegrated and is no longer part of the electrode - it stops working.
On the way it may not work perfectly all the time. Ions can only react with the surface of the metals. If the concentrations get too upset from a lot of use, reactions slow down and limit the current or lower the PD. In some cells bubbles of gas (eg. hydrogen) form on the surface and reduce the reaction. Temperature will have an effect. As the electrode dissolves away, there may be less surface, its resistance may increase, less of the surface may be active due to exposing impurities or deposition of impurities from the electrolyte and the electrolyte composition will permanently change.
It may recover from short term heavy use when allowed time to recover (eg hydrogen bubbles to disappear, electrolyte to become more mixed), but will inevitably deteriorate from cumulative use.

3- The PD across anything connected from anode to cathode is the same. It is the difference between the electrode potentials. The internal reactions always tend to maintain that same potential.
Resistors in parallel are each connected to both electrodes directly, so each sees the same PD.
Resistors in series are not each connected directly to both electrodes, so do not each see the full PD.

Other batteries have different chemistries, but the general principle is the same. Copper and Zinc are just more familiar to me.
 
  • Informative
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Frigus, Dale, vanhees71 and 1 other person

Similar threads

  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
4K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
5K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
6K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 58 ·
2
Replies
58
Views
6K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
3K