Can Anyone Edit a Wiki Without Permission?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cyrus
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the editing capabilities of Wikipedia, highlighting concerns about the ease of making changes to articles. Users express surprise that anyone can edit content without needing a password, although recent changes may require users to create an account. There is acknowledgment of Wikipedia's vulnerability to vandalism, with a mention of a 2002 IBM study indicating that most vandalism is reverted within five minutes. Participants note that there are dedicated individuals who patrol the site to remove inappropriate edits and that vandalism is a common issue, albeit usually resolved quickly. One user shares their experience in a counter-vandalism unit, emphasizing the rapid response to such edits and expressing pride in their volunteer efforts. Overall, the conversation reflects both the accessibility of Wikipedia editing and the community's commitment to maintaining content integrity.
Cyrus
Messages
3,237
Reaction score
17
Heh,

I clicked on one of the edit tabs on wiki and all the text showed up. Then it said click to save changes! WTF! Can anyone go in there and actually change someone's work!? I didn't save any changes, but that was scary. I thought anyone can edit it, but they have to have a password or something given by an admin of some sort. Yikes, I'm surprised kids don’t go in there and just write things like 'wikipedia is for (expletive)'.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Anyone can edit wikipedia... at least they could up until a few weeks ago. I think they've put in some better regulations (but I think its only you needing to make an account real quick before doing it).
 
cyrusabdollahi said:
Heh,
I clicked on one of the edit tabs on wiki and all the text showed up. Then it said click to save changes! WTF! Can anyone go in there and actually change someone's work!? I didn't save any changes, but that was scary. I thought anyone can edit it, but they have to have a password or something given by an admin of some sort. Yikes, I'm surprised kids don’t go in there and just write things like 'wikipedia is for (expletive)'.
They have people who "patrol" the site to remove "vandalism" and others who check up on dubious or contestable edits.
 
Well Pengwuino, yesterday I edited a page just fine.

EDIT: We've had almost this exact thread a few times before BTW. Just search for wikipedia
 
...dough!
 
I believe they cache the whole site regularly in case something really bad happens.
 
Yes, you can read previous edits of a page.
 
Wikipedia is, in fact, vandalized regularly. Most of it doesn't last long, however:

A 2002 study by IBM found that most vandalism on the English Wikipedia is reverted within five minutes

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Vandalism

- Warren
 
TheStatutoryApe said:
They have people who "patrol" the site to remove "vandalism" and others who check up on dubious or contestable edits.
chroot said:
Wikipedia is, in fact, vandalized regularly. Most of it doesn't last long
Actually I am in the counter-vandalism unit. I hate those losers who are wasting their time deleting pages, spamming them, adding in obscene material, the list goes on :mad:. Sometimes we have to ban their IP, because all they do is mess it up.

I did some heavy vandal-fighting last week, and found that none of the articles' vandalisms lasted over two minutes. Most took only about 30 seconds or a minute until it was fixed. GO TEAM! I'm proud of my job. :smile: :biggrin: Too bad I don't get paid.

I got an angry comment from a vandal two days ago. :frown:
 
  • #10
...dough!
Actually, it's .[/URL] :biggrin:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #11
Kids, you tried your best and you failed miserably. The lesson is, never try. ~Homer
 
  • #12
D'oh!

Hurkyl said:
Actually, it's .[/URL] :biggrin:
You probably know where this expression came from. It was a favorite of Mr. Cucumber (played by James Finlayson) in the Laurel and Hardy movies (made from 1929-52). In slapstick exasperation, he would often exclaim Do-o-o-o! and slap his forehead for emphasis. If you're not familiar with these movies, you gottah catch some on DVD. :biggrin:
(Hmmmm i see this reference confirms my recall.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top