Can electrons pile up in a conductor

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the behavior of electrons in a conductor when a positive charge is applied at one end of a copper wire. Participants explore the movement of mobile electrons, the effects of electric fields, and related concepts in electrostatics and electromagnetism.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • One participant questions whether electrons would pile up at the end of a wire if a positive force is applied, suggesting that only surface electrons might move.
  • Another participant asserts that electrons are attracted to the positive end, leading to a charge separation where the other end becomes positively charged.
  • Some participants argue that a constant electric field cannot exist inside a conductor, as any field would cause electrons to move to neutralize it.
  • A participant recalls a thought experiment about electrons dropping from a cut wire, linking it to the discussion of electric fields in conductors.
  • There is mention of skin depth and the decay of electric fields inside conductors, with some participants correcting earlier statements about potential and electric fields.
  • One participant emphasizes that the entire wire's electrons would move in response to an external charge, not just those at the surface.
  • Another participant discusses the calculation of potential charge and voltage in electrets, drawing parallels to capacitors.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the behavior of electrons in conductors under an electric field. While some agree that electrons will move toward the positive charge, others emphasize the inability of a static electric field to exist within a conductor. The discussion remains unresolved with multiple competing perspectives.

Contextual Notes

Some claims rely on assumptions about electric fields and charge distributions that are not fully explored. The discussion includes references to electrostatics and electromagnetism concepts that may require further clarification.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be of interest to those studying electromagnetism, electrostatics, or materials science, particularly in understanding charge behavior in conductors.

smiddleton
Messages
18
Reaction score
0
Hey All,
I'm new to the forum. I hope I put this in the right area of expertise. If not, I would appreciate it if you could direct me to the right place. I am just a curious person with a pretty good physics background but I came up with a question I couldn't answer. Hypothetically, if you had a 2 inch long straight copper wire, and some how created a positive force at localized at 1 end of the wire, would the electrons in the wire that are "mobile" move toward that end and sort of pile up in a large, well, pile, of electrons? Or would only the electrons on the surface of the wire move toward that point? I hope that makes sense. Thanks advance, I hope you don't mind me pondering physics as a hobby.

SM
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
I just join in the discussion. I believe it will. What you are asking is in any EM book where you put an +E field at one end of the wire. The electrons are attracted to that end of the wire. The other end is left with excess of protons and become +ve charged.

This should be same as a hollow conductor ball with a +ve charge in the middle. electrons will be pull the the inner surface and the outer surface has the +ve charge. The total +ve charge on the outer surface is equal to the charge inside the ball. The total charge in the conductor ball is neutral.
 
Last edited:
But there is no potential difference between the two ends of your 2" wire as any potential will cause electrons to move to neutralize the potential.
Any constant electric field accompanies a linearly varying potential field. Its seen from Poisson's equation.

would the electrons in the wire that are "mobile" move toward that end and sort of pile up in a large, well, pile, of electrons?
This reminds me of a question I was asked many years ago.
"Imagine a straight copper wire placed above a bowl. A current was flowing through the wire when the wire is suddenly cut in the middle. Will the electrons drop from one end of the wire into the bowl below?" :smile:
 
Kholdstare said:
Any constant electric field accompanies a linearly varying potential field. Its seen from Poisson's equation.


This reminds me of a question I was asked many years ago.
"Imagine a straight copper wire placed above a bowl. A current was flowing through the wire when the wire is suddenly cut in the middle. Will the electrons drop from one end of the wire into the bowl below?" :smile:

Not in a conductor, any field inside the conductor will cause electrons to move in direction to neutralize the potential. This is explained very clear in any of the EM textbook.
 
Oops! I overlooked this thing. Electric field decays inside a conductor and reduces to 1/e at skin depth. Roughly yungman is correct.
 
Kholdstare said:
Oops! I overlooked this thing. Electric field decays inside a conductor and reduces to 1/e at skin depth. Roughly yungman is correct.

It is more than that, you are referring to varying E field that has skin depth. Even in total static E, there cannot be E inside a good conductor as any E will cause the electrons to drift to neutralize any the field.

Actually I made a mistake in my first post also. It's not potential, it's E field cannot exist inside a good conductor. I edited my first post already to cover the evidence!:smile:
 
Well ! Years of lack of practice of EM is producing some effects. haha. Don't worry. I'll catch up.
 
Kholdstare said:
Well ! Years of lack of practice of EM is producing some effects. haha. Don't worry. I'll catch up.

That's how it is. I could have answer better a year ago when I was hot on the trod with studying EM. I have been off for like a year, I swear I really forgot a lot of things.
 
smiddleton, Welcome to Physics Forums!

Yes, a positive charge will attract free electrons in a conductor! You are exactly correct. If you Google "electrostatics" you can read all about this subject at the Wikipedia page. Especially check out the diagram about half-way down the page. It shows what you are describing graphically and clearly!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Electrostatic_induction.svg
 
  • #10
Wow, thanks for all the replies. I love physics, but I went into materials science so my electrical engineering background is pretty basic. This really helps though, thanks everyone!
SM
 
  • #11
Hey guys, I have another quick question. How do you calculate the potential charge, in coulombs, of an electret? I can't find that one anywhere. Thanks again.
SM
 
  • #12
Also, how do they calculate the voltage? I think my understanding of distance in parallel plate caps is making it hard for me to understand this. Thanks.
SM
 
  • #13
If you bring an electric charge close to a copper wire the electrons in the entire wire would start moving, not just at the surface. That's why the resistance of a wire depends on it's cross sectional area and not on it's circumference. As soon as the field inside the wire has dropped to zero the electrons stop moving. One end of the wire will then be charged positive and the other negative. btw. there can be a field inside a conductor if there is a current flowing.

An electret is similar to a charged parallel plate capacitor, just without the plates. So voltage is equal to field strength * thickness. The charge is field strength * electric field constant * area * dielectric constant.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
729
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
3K
Replies
10
Views
5K
  • · Replies 32 ·
2
Replies
32
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
5K
Replies
25
Views
4K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K