Can You Solve These Challenging Physics Word Problems?

  • Thread starter Thread starter GosuWaffles
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Physics
AI Thread Summary
A forum user seeks help with physics word problems involving a motor-pump system, specifically calculating the motor's kW input, horsepower, and running costs. Initial calculations indicate a power output of 34.0625 Watts, but confusion arises regarding the application of efficiency ratios. Another user clarifies that efficiencies should not be combined directly and explains the relationship between input and output power. The discussion emphasizes the importance of understanding the correct application of efficiency in solving the problems. The user requests further assistance to complete the calculations before needing rest.
GosuWaffles
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Hello gentlemen good afternoon, I'm a newbie on this forum I have been scratching my head all weekend on how to do these problems. I am wondering if someone could show me the right way.

Q1) A motor-pump set lifts 25m3 of water in 6 minutes through a vertical height of 5 cm. The efficiency of the pump is 75% and the efficiency of the motor is 85%.

1.) Calculate the kW input to the motor.
2.) Motor HP (Calc. value)
3.) Cost of running the system for 8 hrs (The cost per kWh is .10 cents)Q2) Will be revealed after the first one to avoid confusion :)

Homework Statement


Well I've given all known data I was given so that's met.

Homework Equations


Not sure, perhaps the word problem already encompasses the relevant equations already.

The Attempt at a Solution


Well my attempt was, for "1) Calculate kW input to the motor."
25,000kg * 9.81 = 245,250 N
245,250 * 0.05m / 360sec = 34.0625 Watts output to the motor
Multiplying both eff. to come up with a combined .75 * .85 = 0.6375 %
34.0625 / 0.6375 = 54.4314 Watts or 0.053 kW input to the motor

I'm not sure if this is correct, I haven't moved onto 2) and 3) because of said reason.

Regards,
Waffles
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
You need to post this in the proper format for a homework problem. Please read the forum rules.

EDIT: NOW you're looking good :smile:
 
Last edited:
phinds said:
You need to post this in the proper format for a homework problem. Please read the forum rules.

I hope this suffices what was required to ask a question on this subforum.
 
GosuWaffles said:
245,250 * 0.05m / 360sec = 34.0625 Watts output to the motor
Well, no, that's the power required to raise the water at the specified rate. Since the pump is only 75% efficient the output from the motor must be 34.0625/0.75 W. But you got the right answer at the end.
 
haruspex, thank you for taking interest in my thread.

Could you help me on the next one "2) Motor HP (Calc. value)"

My attempt was,

Combined the efficiencies 1.25 * 1.15 = 1.4375%
34.0625W Output * 1.4375 = 48.875W Input

48.875 / 746 = 0.065 HP
 
As it happens, I calculated the output power from the motor for you in my previous post.
Where do you get 1.25 and 1.15 from? You can't do that with efficiencies. An efficiency is a ratio. If A = B*75% then B = A*1/.75 = A*133%. Also, the two efficiency factors, 75% and 85%, are for going all the way from input to the motor to useful work done by the pump. The output from the motor (= input to the pump) sits between them.
 
Hello haruspex,

I'll be honest I can't say I follow what you meant, it's the price I pay for studying long period into the A.M. haha.., could you show me how you got "Motor HP" that means you'd just use the motor eff. right when it just simply asks for Motor Horsepower.

I just really need this problem solved before I get my much needed sleep. I like to work with the solutions in reverse is how I learn them better. Thank you
 
You have:
power input to motor, Pmi
power output from motor, Pmo = Pmi * motor efficiency = Pmi * 85%
power input to pump, Ppi = Pmo
effective power of pump in pumping water = Ppo = Ppi * pump efficiency = Ppi * 75% = Pmi * 85% * 75%
 
Back
Top