- #1

- 54

- 0

e.g. df/dg=df/dx df/dy df/dz

Cheers!

Romeo

You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

- Thread starter romeo6
- Start date

- #1

- 54

- 0

e.g. df/dg=df/dx df/dy df/dz

Cheers!

Romeo

- #2

- 79

- 0

Are you really trying to find the derivative of one function with respect to the other function?

- #3

- 54

- 0

Are you really trying to find the derivative of one function with respect to the other function?

Is that not possible?

- #4

- 256

- 2

If f is not a function g, then you derivative equals 0, if I'm not mistaken.

- #5

- 79

- 0

Is that not possible?

If I remember correctly, it is possible, but somewhat difficult.

- #6

- 54

- 0

- #7

- 79

- 0

Is there a way that you can justify this?

I'm just wondering if you have more than your intuition.

- #8

- 256

- 2

Hey, e

- #9

- 54

- 0

Is there a way that you can justify this?

I'm just wondering if you have more than your intuition.

You're right - just intuition. Which is probably failing me.

- #10

- 79

- 0

You're right - just intuition. Which is probably failing me.

What is your mathematical background? Are you learning (or teaching yourself) calculus right now?

- #11

- 256

- 2

Are you guys ignoring my posts on purpose :( ?

- #12

- 79

- 0

Are you guys ignoring my posts on purpose :( ?

No, but I think that if you're trying to make a point, it is best done explicitly.

- #13

- 256

- 2

- #14

- 79

- 0

You answered a question with a question. (Granted that is what I did too.)

Let me think this through a little more. I didn't start with an answer in my head.

- #15

- 256

- 2

Did you take a look at my first post in this thread?

- #16

- 79

- 0

Did you take a look at my first post in this thread?

I did. I just missed when I was reviewing the thread. Sorry.

- #17

- 256

- 2

I did. I just missed when I was reviewing the thread. Sorry.

Chill, np. This threat got me thinking. Sometimes some concepts become so instinctive that thinking about them makes knots in your brain.

- #18

- 79

- 0

If f is not a function g, then you derivative equals 0, if I'm not mistaken.

Upon further thought, this is not true.

Since

However, with the proper assumptions made about

[itex]\frac{d(f(g^{-1}(x)))}{dx}=\frac{df}{dx}\frac{1}{\frac{dg}{dx}}[/itex]

- #19

Mark44

Mentor

- 35,230

- 7,048

This really doesn't make much sense. You don't calculate the derivative of a function with respect to some other function, but you do calculate the derivative of a function with respect to one of its variables. Here g is a function, not a variable, so df/dg is nonsensical.If I have two functions, f(x,y,z) and g(x,y,z), do I use the chain rule to calculate df/dg?

e.g. df/dg=df/dx df/dy df/dz

For another thing, both functions here have multiple variables, so instead of df/dx, df/dy, and df/dz, you would be working with partial derivatives,

[tex]\frac{\partial f}{\partial x}, \frac{\partial f}{\partial y}, \text{and} \frac{\partial f}{\partial z}[/tex]

Other notation for these partials is f

- #20

- 79

- 0

This really doesn't make much sense. You don't calculate the derivative of a function with respect to some other function, but you do calculate the derivative of a function with respect to one of its variables. Here g is a function, not a variable, so df/dg is nonsensical.

Except that is exactly what you do when you perform a variable transform.

- #21

- 256

- 2

What do you mean by variable transform?

What Mark44 said makes sense. If you want to derive something with respect to a function you need a functional.

What Mark44 said makes sense. If you want to derive something with respect to a function you need a functional.

Last edited:

- #22

Mark44

Mentor

- 35,230

- 7,048

- #23

- 79

- 0

Why does it not makes sense to define a derivative of a function with respect to another function?

- #24

chiro

Science Advisor

- 4,797

- 132

e.g. df/dg=df/dx df/dy df/dz

Cheers!

Romeo

Have you done Calculus III (Multivariable calculus)?

- #25

- 54

- 0

If f is not a function g, then you derivative equals 0, if I'm not mistaken.

I certainly wasn't ignoring you, however I found your next post valuable, with the example of taking the derivative of x^2 wrt e^x.

Share: