Clarification of stats question

  • Thread starter Thread starter nod32
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Stats
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on clarifying how to determine the deviation of four temperature measuring instruments from a gas thermometer across ten recorded temperatures. Participants express confusion over whether to calculate a single deviation value for each instrument or to find deviations at each individual reading. It is confirmed that each instrument will have its own standard deviation calculated from its ten data points. However, there is concern that simply calculating standard deviation does not adequately compare the instruments against the gas thermometer. The focus remains on accurately interpreting the question to ensure proper statistical analysis.
nod32
Messages
14
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


determine the deviation of each instrument from the gas thermometer at all recorded temperatures.

4 temperature measuring instruments were compared. readings were taken at 10 points (as temp was increased)

2. The attempt at a solution

the wording of the question is what's confusing me. Is each instrument going to have one value for deviation? Or is it asking for a deviation at each reading?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
You have four sets of data, each with 10 points? (One for each instrument)

If so, then each instrument will have a standard deviation which you can calculate using one set of data's 10 points. (There should be a formula you can use)
 
rock.freak667 said:
You have four sets of data, each with 10 points? (One for each instrument)
thats correct

rock.freak667 said:
If so, then each instrument will have a standard deviation which you can calculate using one set of data's 10 points. (There should be a formula you can use)

I thought about this, but it says "determine the deviation of each device from the gas thermometer". I could just calculate the standard deviation, but that doesn't compare it against the gas thermo.
 
Back
Top