I Color and appearance of a "pile" of biological viruses

  • I
  • Thread starter Thread starter Skaperen
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion explores the optical properties of a hypothetical "pile" of biological viruses, questioning whether it would absorb or reflect light, and what color it might appear. It emphasizes that viruses are typically too small to be seen without an electron microscope, but if aggregated into a larger mass, their appearance could vary based on factors like thickness and crystallization. The color could range from black to white or even have distinct hues depending on the virus's chemical composition and the nature of light interaction. The conversation also touches on the complexities of light absorption and reflection in relation to the crystalline or powdered forms of materials, drawing parallels with other compounds. Ultimately, the consensus suggests that the color of such a virus pile would likely be influenced by its structural and chemical characteristics.
Skaperen
Messages
84
Reaction score
0
TL;DR Summary
If there is a "pile" of biological viruses where the pile is way large enough to be seen, optically, what color might this "pile" have?
Normally, an electron microscope would be needed to "see" a biological virus or other objects of this size scale because they are so much smaller than wavelengths of light we can see with our red/green/blue sensitive eyes (700 nm down to 400 nm) at any magnification of an optical microscope. What I have been wondering about is a "pile" of viruses (under a vacuum to avoid any "floating" away) of size, perhaps 1 cm by 1 cm is what the "pile" might look like. would it absorb light and thus look black or would it reflect light and look white? could it have color?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
A thin film of viruses, with thickness similar to the wavelength of light, would have a colour determined by the thickness of the film and the spectrum of the illumination.

If the film was thick, you would see the colour of the virus coat, or the hydroxides that would bond to it in air, so I guess a creamy yellow.
 
Baluncore said:
I guess a creamy yellow.

MailOnline went with olive oil style, while The Sun prefered sugar like:

 
Skaperen said:
TL;DR Summary: If there is a "pile" of biological viruses where the pile is way large enough to be seen, optically, what color might this "pile" have?

would it absorb light and thus look black or would it reflect light and look white? could it have color?
Just how you'd get hold of a teaspoonfull of 'viruses' could be a serious practical problem and require some degree of expertise. But optical spectroscopy is a way of detecting various chemical compounds. The visibe colour would probably (as with beef stock) be pretty non-descript, once the emerging light is passed through a spectrometer, there will probably be recognisable bands of absorbed wavelengths corresponding to common compounds.
 
Skaperen said:
TL;DR Summary: If there is a "pile" of biological viruses where the pile is way large enough to be seen, optically, what color might this "pile" have?

what the "pile" might look like. would it absorb light and thus look black or would it reflect light and look white? could it have color?
Depends upon if the virus clump is crystalized or not.
For example, sugar, salt are clear when crystalized, but white when seen as a powder.
In geology, the test for certain minerals is the color of the streak test, which is the color of the powder form, as opposed to the crystalized form.

The above are 'simple' compounds compared to the chemical nature of viruses, so it isn't clear what one would see of the viruses - a much more complex makeup of chemicals - in crystalized form, where transmission, absorption, and reflection ( internal from inside the body, as well as external from the surface ), or in powder form where the light coming back to your eyes is scattered. The terms are specular and diffuse lighting from a flat or rough surface.
Also important is the location of the lighting source. For a comparison, clouds normally look white or dark, but at a particular location of the light source, internal reflections of the light within the water droplet produces many colours known as a rainbow.

Nonetheless, viruses have been grouped together and studied for quite some time.
Some virus groupings can form crystals, while others not.

I take you to Wiki for more info.
The site does show a picture of the tobacco virus crystal in two forms. Both crystals appear metallic, with one having a more gold appearance, and the other more steel like in my opinion.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virus_crystallisation
Although, it should be said, the technique for study is uses X-ray crystallography, not visable light.
Even so, the pictures are of a virus crystal through a compound microscope.

Size of crystal.
Here they say up to 0.5 mm, and they all look similar to the salt crystals.
https://www.researchgate.net/figure...he-presence-of-either-a-high-PEG_fig2_6362485
I imagine some crystalizing solution to be be entrained within.
 
Last edited:
256bits said:
Nonetheless, viruses have been groped together and studied for quite some time.
The scientists responsible have been sacked.
 
  • Haha
Likes sophiecentaur
DaveC426913 said:
The scientists responsible have been sacked.
Not sure what you mean.
 
256bits said:
Not sure what you mean.
There's a typo in the sentence of yours that Dave quoted.
 
Ibix said:
There's a typo in the sentence of yours that Dave quoted.
Fixed,:DD
A new batch of scientists hired replacing that nasty bunch.
 
  • #10
Skaperen said:
TL;DR Summary: If there is a "pile" of biological viruses where the pile is way large enough to be seen, optically, what color might this "pile" have?

Normally, an electron microscope would be needed to "see" a biological virus or other objects of this size scale because they are so much smaller than wavelengths of light we can see with our red/green/blue sensitive eyes (700 nm down to 400 nm) at any magnification of an optical microscope. What I have been wondering about is a "pile" of viruses (under a vacuum to avoid any "floating" away) of size, perhaps 1 cm by 1 cm is what the "pile" might look like. would it absorb light and thus look black or would it reflect light and look white? could it have color?
I think that the strongly coloured crystals are of ionic compounds, such as Copper, Iron and Cobalt. This seems to be because the ions are electrically charged and so will respond to a passing EM wave, which can induce electron resonances. On the other hand, co-valent compounds are often not coloured, and their response to an EM wave would then be due to asymmetry, such as with the water molecule, or CO2. Some metals are coloured, due to electron resonances. As a virus is a piece of DNA, and DNA is, so far as I know, a co-valent compound, I would expect it to be largely colourless. Of course it will disturb a passing light ray because its permittivity will differ from that of free space, but I would not expect to find significant resonance effects to create colour.
 
Back
Top