Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the optical properties and potential appearance of a "pile" of biological viruses, particularly focusing on whether such a pile could absorb or reflect light, and what color it might exhibit if it were large enough to be seen with the naked eye. The scope includes theoretical considerations, optical properties, and the challenges of visualizing viruses.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- Some participants propose that a thin film of viruses could exhibit color based on its thickness and the spectrum of illumination.
- One participant suggests that a thick film might show the color of the virus coat or associated hydroxides, speculating a creamy yellow appearance.
- Another participant notes that the color of a virus pile could depend on whether the viruses are crystallized, comparing it to how sugar and salt appear differently in powdered versus crystalline forms.
- There are discussions about the complexity of the chemical makeup of viruses and how this might affect their optical properties, including absorption and reflection of light.
- One participant mentions that the visible color of a virus pile might be non-descript, similar to beef stock, when analyzed through optical spectroscopy.
- Another participant discusses the potential for viruses to form crystals and how this might influence their appearance, referencing specific examples of virus crystallization.
- There is a mention of the role of electron resonances in colored ionic compounds versus covalent compounds like DNA, suggesting that viruses may be largely colorless.
- One participant points out that colored images of viruses could result from the use of polarized light apparatus, indicating that impurities might also play a role.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express a variety of views on the potential color and appearance of a pile of viruses, with no consensus reached. There are competing hypotheses regarding the effects of crystallization, chemical composition, and the influence of light on their appearance.
Contextual Notes
Limitations include the dependence on the definitions of color and appearance, the complexity of the chemical nature of viruses, and unresolved aspects of how light interacts with different forms of viruses.