Comoving distance and redshift relationship derivation

6 replies · 7K views · last reply
DoobleD
Messages
259
Reaction score
20
Hello PhysicsForum,

There is something I don't get at the end of this course notes PDF file. In the last section, titled "Comoving distance and redshift", which I have copied below, we have a short derivation of the comoving distance and redshift relation.

Almost all is well, the only thing that troubles me is : why is there no minus sign after da has been replaced by -a2dz ?

Screenshot of course notes showing the derivation of comoving distance r as an integral of c dz over H(z), with a red arrow pointing to the sign change from da to -a^2 dz.


I have searched the web and found almost identical derivations in other courses or publications, but I never read the explanation for why the minus sign drops. I have found what seems to be the source material for most of those derivations : this paper from 93 (see section 6.3, "The General Redshift-Distance Relation" on 3rd page). It is referenced quite often by others when this comoving distance and redshift relationship shows up.

Maybe I am just missing some mathematical trick ? This is not super important of course, but it bugs me.
 
Could it be because the integration limits have been swapped? (consider what it means when the limits are ##a_e -> a_0##, where e stands for emission, and ##0 -> z##.)
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: DoobleD
Bandersnatch said:
Could it be because the integration limits have been swapped? (consider what it means when the limits are ##a_e -> a_0##, where e stands for emission, and ##0 -> z##.)
Yes. The change of variables leads to two minus signs which cancel one another: ##da = -a^2 dz##, and reversing the limits of integration.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: DoobleD
Thank you !

Thay's what I thought, but then it means that the ae limit corresponds to z when you do the change of variable, and a0 to 0 redshift ? Sounds weird, shouldn't it be the other way around ? Since a0 = a(t0) is the expansion when we receive the redshifted signal.
 
DoobleD said:
Thank you !

Thay's what I thought, but then it means that the ae limit corresponds to z when you do the change of variable, and a0 to 0 redshift ? Sounds weird, shouldn't it be the other way around ? Since a0 = a(t0) is the expansion when we receive the redshifted signal.
This is probably easiest to see if you look at the equation for the scale factor in terms of the redshift:
[tex]a = {1 \over 1+z}[/tex]

Here note that for ##z=0##, ##a=1##. That's the current scale factor and redshift. A far-away object, at, say, a redshift of ##z=2## is at a scale factor of ##a=1/3##. The integral above over ##da## would integrate from ##1/3## to 1, while the integral over ##dz## integrates from 0 to 2.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: DoobleD
DoobleD said:
Thank you !

Thay's what I thought, but then it means that the ae limit corresponds to z when you do the change of variable, and a0 to 0 redshift ? Sounds weird, shouldn't it be the other way around ? Since a0 = a(t0) is the expansion when we receive the redshifted signal.
Think of how far you need to look. Higher z is seen farther than lower z, while lower a is seen farther than high a.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: DoobleD
kimbyd said:
This is probably easiest to see if you look at the equation for the scale factor in terms of the redshift:
a=11+za=11+z​
a = {1 \over 1+z}

Here note that for z=0z=0z=0, a=1a=1a=1. That's the current scale factor and redshift. A far-away object, at, say, a redshift of z=2z=2z=2 is at a scale factor of a=1/3a=1/3a=1/3. The integral above over dadada would integrate from 1/31/31/3 to 1, while the integral over dzdzdz integrates from 0 to 2.

Bandersnatch said:
Think of how far you need to look. Higher z is seen farther than lower z, while lower a is seen farther than high a.

Makes sense now. Thank you !