Components of a magnetic field in a uniform wire

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves determining the x and y components of the magnetic field B inside a straight wire carrying a current I, with a specified radius and centered at coordinates (α,β). The context includes the presence of another wire, parallel but carrying current in the opposite direction.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Mathematical reasoning

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the uniform current density J within the wire and its implications for calculating the enclosed current I_enc. There are attempts to evaluate the integral in Ampere's Law while maintaining component separation. Questions arise about the assumptions made regarding the configuration of the wires and the effects of the opposing current.

Discussion Status

Some participants have made progress in deriving expressions for the magnetic field components, while others are exploring the contributions from both wires. There is an acknowledgment of the complexity involved in integrating the magnetic field components and a search for more elegant solutions. The discussion remains open with various interpretations being explored.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the presence of two wires, one with current I and the other with current -I, and question how this affects the magnetic field calculations. There is also mention of the need to clarify the setup and assumptions regarding the wires' positions and currents.

ItsFootballNo
Messages
4
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



A straight wire, of current I, radius a is centred at (α,β). What are the x and y components of the magnetic field B inside one of the wires?

Homework Equations



∮B.dl = μ I_enc
∫∫J.dS = I

The Attempt at a Solution



Any point (x,y) in the wire has a constant current density J.

Hence:
∫∫J.dS = J pi r^2 = J pi ((x-α)^2 + (y-β)^2)

The wire has total current I and the current density J is uniform, hence:
J = I / (pi a^2)

Therefore:
I_enc = ∫∫J.dS = I ((x-α)^2 + (y-β)^2)/a^2

Therefore:
∮B.dl = μ I ((x-α)^2 + (y-β)^2)/a^2

It is from here that I get stuck, mostly how to evalutate the integral without it becoming one big equation without staying in its components. If I was just looking at magnitude of the magnetic field, I know we could show:
∮B.dl = B (2 pi r)
=> B = μ I r / (2 pi a^2)

But looking at the answers, just the y component comes out as:
B_y = μ I (x-α) / (2 pi a^2) - μ I x / (2 pi [(x+α)^2 + (y+β)^2])

Am I going about this the wrong way or are there any tips on how to get to the next step? Any help is greatly appreciated!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
ItsFootballNo said:

Homework Statement



A straight wire, of current I, radius a is centred at (α,β). What are the x and y components of the magnetic field B inside one of the wires?

Homework Equations



∮B.dl = μ I_enc
∫∫J.dS = I

The Attempt at a Solution



Any point (x,y) in the wire has a constant current density J.

Hence:
∫∫J.dS = J pi r^2 = J pi ((x-α)^2 + (y-β)^2)

The wire has total current I and the current density J is uniform, hence:
J = I / (pi a^2)

Therefore:
I_enc = ∫∫J.dS = I ((x-α)^2 + (y-β)^2)/a^2

Therefore:
∮B.dl = μ I ((x-α)^2 + (y-β)^2)/a^2

It is from here that I get stuck, mostly how to evalutate the integral without it becoming one big equation without staying in its components. If I was just looking at magnitude of the magnetic field, I know we could show:
∮B.dl = B (2 pi r)
=> B = μ I r / (2 pi a^2)

But looking at the answers, just the y component comes out as:
B_y = μ I (x-α) / (2 pi a^2) - μ I x / (2 pi [(x+α)^2 + (y+β)^2])

Am I going about this the wrong way or are there any tips on how to get to the next step? Any help is greatly appreciated!
Hello ItsFootballNo. Welcome to PF !   (I see that you posted in PF once before without getting any reply.)

Your first sentence indicates to me that there is more than one wire. What can you tell us about that?
 
Apologies, the other wire is centred at (-α,-β), also with radius a.
 
The other wire also has current -I (that is, it is parallel but running in the opposite direction)
 
I have been working on it for the past hour or so, and seem to have come up with some sort of solution, but it isn't the most elegant one.

I looked at the case of the magnetic field inside just one of the wires (say, in this case, the one to the right, centred at (α,β) and solved for the magnitude of B. I assumed that:
vec(B) = (B_x, B_y, B_z) = (-B sin(t), B cos(t), 0) = (-B(y-β)/r, B(x-α)/r, 0) = (-μI(y-β)/(2 pi a^2), μI(x-α)/(2 pi a^2), 0)

I then looked at the contribution of the other wire which, as the point we're inspecting is outside of the wire, is:
B=-μI/(2 pi r) [The negative sign arising from the current being negative in this wire]

Again looking at the effect at a point (x,y)
vec(B) = (B_x, B_y, B_z) = (-B sin(t), B cos(t), 0) = (-B(y+β)/r, B(x+α)/r, 0) = (μI(y+β)/(2 pi ((y+β)^2 + (x+α)^2)), (μI(x+α)/(2 pi ((y+β)^2 + (x+α)^2)), 0) [y+β and x+α arising from the new centre of (-α,-β)]

Finding the sum, using the superposition principle, of these gives a correct looking solution.

I just have a problem in that I've just used: vec(B) = |B| theta-hat and subbed in from there. Does this represent a satisfactory means to solve the solution or is there a better method when doing the integral in Ampere's Law?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
11
Views
5K
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
1K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K