Conceptual Question About Magnetism

In summary, Chris White argues that magnetism is just electrostatic forces with special relativity taken into account. Francisco Muller disagrees, and if magnetism were just electrostatic forces, then magnetism would not exist in individual stationary elementary particles.
  • #1
PurelyPhysical
31
0
I'm trying to get a handle on what magnetism really is. I know that charge in motion generates a magnetic field. I know that objects and particles can be permanent magnets when the magnetic fields of their elementary particles "line up." But how do stationary elementary particles have the own individual magnetic fields? I've heard some people make the case that magnetism is just electrostatic forces with special relativity taken into account. Is that true? I've heard that electricity and magnetism are the same thing. Some people say there is a clear distinction between the two. Which is it?

I know that charged particles can exist as monopoles and magnetism requires two poles. But what is at the poles? What makes the poles negative and positive? The answer I'm expecting is that the magnetic dipole moments at the poles line up to make them either north or south. But what is actually happening there? What would happen if you took away one of the poles? What are you left with? In electrostatics we work with charged particles, positive and negative. But magnetic monopoles haven't been proven to exist. I know that's why the magnetic field is defined differently than the electric field, but it doesn't conceptually mean anything to me. With the magnetic field being defined as the velocity vector of a moving charged particle when the force acted on it is 0, it's almost seems like it's just completely made up to describe something we observe, but don't really understand. But what are we observing? What is the observed difference between electricity and magnetism?

The top commenter of this thread, Chris White, makes the argument that magnetism is just electrostatic forces with special relativity taken into account.

http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/65335/how-do-moving-charges-produce-magnetic-fields

But several comments down Francisco Muller refutes him, and even if this were true, it doesn't account for the magnetism of individual stationary elementary particles.

At this point I'm completely lost. How is electricity and magnetism different? What is magnetism really?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I do not know whether this helps but let me try. Any concept in Physics should be tackled from the simplest level . Remember all great scientist were always trying to tell us that fundamental laws of nature are the simplest ones ( like F= ma or E = mc^2). Let me address some of your questions. What is at he poles? What are lines of force. To me they are just models to explain the behaviour of magnets. My take is that when scientista are trying to study the nature of unknown the first step is to find a model and test whether it is based on correct conceptions and agrees with experimental results. For example, if we want to study the nuclear reactions taking place in Sun we simply can not set up a laboratory there and conduct a test. So we device some model equations and verify it experimentally and tally with the observable facts.To me the idea of poles, field lines are all consequences of a model which agrees with observed facts. The origin of magentism is similarly explained by movement f charged particles in substance. The motion of electron in a n atom gives rise to magnetism. Since all substances contain electrons then why only certain substances exhibit the property? For that the model is spin up and down for magnetic moments.Well one could go on and on . My request is not to get entangled with too many concepts at the same time. One thing at a time may help. Happy studying Physics. It is a great subject.
 

1. What is magnetism?

Magnetism is a phenomenon where certain objects, such as iron and steel, have the ability to attract or repel other objects with the same property. This is due to the presence of a magnetic field, which is created by the movement of electric charges within the material.

2. How does magnetism work?

Magnetism works through the interaction of electric charges. When electric charges move, they create a magnetic field, which in turn can influence other objects with magnetic properties. This interaction is known as electromagnetism.

3. What is the difference between a permanent magnet and an electromagnet?

A permanent magnet is a material that has its own magnetic field and does not require an external source of electricity to maintain it. An electromagnet, on the other hand, is made by passing an electric current through a coil of wire, creating a temporary magnetic field. The strength of the electromagnet can be controlled by adjusting the amount of current flowing through the wire.

4. How can I demagnetize a magnet?

Magnets can be demagnetized by heating them to a high temperature, or by hitting or dropping them repeatedly. Additionally, storing magnets in a strong magnetic field in the opposite direction can also demagnetize them.

5. What are some practical applications of magnetism?

Magnetism has many practical applications, including electric generators, motors, and speakers. It is also used in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) machines for medical diagnostics, as well as in compasses for navigation. Magnetic materials are also used in everyday items such as credit cards, hard drives, and refrigerator magnets.

Similar threads

  • Electromagnetism
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
93
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
8
Views
795
Replies
4
Views
279
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
17
Views
1K
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
5
Views
785
Replies
24
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
4K
Replies
12
Views
12K
Back
Top