Confusing ROTATIONAL RIGID BODY QUESTION problem conceptualizing

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on a physics problem involving a cylinder wrapped in cloth, with a focus on understanding the forces and torques at play. Participants emphasize the importance of applying Newton's second law to analyze the tension in the cloth, which prevents the cylinder from falling. The conversation highlights the confusion between linear and rotational dynamics, particularly in calculating angular acceleration and the relationship between work, torque, and distance. Participants suggest using kinematic equations to relate angular speed and distance unwound, while clarifying that work is defined as force times distance. Overall, the thread aims to clarify the conceptual framework necessary to solve the problem effectively.
avenkat0
Messages
59
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


A piece of cloth with irrelavent mass is wrapped around a 67.5 kg cylinder of radius 0.167 m. Joe holds the free end of the cloth. The cylinder is released from rest, and Joe pulls the tape upward at a speed that just prevents the center of mass of the cylinder from falling as the tape unwinds. Assume:
- the cylinder is always parallel to the floor
- the tape is always perpendicular to the radius of the cylinder
- the tape does not slip over the cylinder

a) Find the magnitude of the tension in the tape as the cylinder turns.

Homework Equations


29bac02573ea5d0bbf08a7506e4e9b37.png

The Attempt at a Solution


I have no idea where to start... I don't think i quite understand it conceptually... like i don't quite see the picture in my head

Thank you for your help
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
If the cloth isn't pulled up, it will just unwind as the cylinder falls. (Imagine a heavy log rolled up in a carpet and you let it unwind.)

To answer the question, apply Newton's 2nd law. What forces act on the cylinder?
 
is it kind of like the logs that are floating on the water while people run on it... thus in turn staying in the same place?...
so the cloth is giving the cylinder a torque to equal its fall? making the center of mass stay at the same place?
 
avenkat0 said:
is it kind of like the logs that are floating on the water while people run on it... thus in turn staying in the same place?...
Something like that.
so the cloth is giving the cylinder a torque to equal its fall?
The cloth is certainly exerting a torque on the cylinder.
making the center of mass stay at the same place?
Yes, the cloth is being pulled up fast enough that the center of mass doesn't move.
 
should the tension in the cloth equal mg down since the tension keeps it from falling down?
I keep confusing linear qualities with rotational qualities!...
 
avenkat0 said:
should the tension in the cloth equal mg down since the tension keeps it from falling down?
Sounds good to me.
 
Thank you so much... One more thing...
c) Find the length of the cloth that has been unwound when the cylinder reaches an angular speed of 28.3 rad/s

I found the work done was 376.92 J...
Now i set Delta Theta = 376.92/Tourque...
i.e 376.92/I(alpha)
but how would i go about finding alpha?

because if i find alpha can't i find Theta and then 2pi (Theta) should be the length the cloth unwinds right?
 
To find alpha, use Newton's 2nd law for rotation. Then you can use kinematics to find theta and then the length. (No, 2pi(theta) is not the length.)

But if you've already found the work done, there's no need to find alpha or theta.
 
hmmm work done is torque(distance)... But I don't have the tension either how would I go about findig the distance?

I tried using I(alpha)=torque and then omega final and omegia0 is 0 but I'm missing theta time and alpha so I wasn't able to find alpha using kibematics...

Have I overlooked something??

Again Thank you
 
  • #10
avenkat0 said:
hmmm work done is torque(distance)...
Careful. Work is force*distance (or torque*angle).
But I don't have the tension either how would I go about findig the distance?
Sure you have the tension. That was the first thing you solved for.
I tried using I(alpha)=torque and then omega final and omegia0 is 0 but I'm missing theta time and alpha so I wasn't able to find alpha using kibematics...
Look for a kinematic formula that relates speed and distance, not time.
 
Back
Top