Conservation of Momentum of a body of mass

  • Thread starter Eugbug
  • Start date
  • #1
21
0
If a body of mass m and velocity u collides with another body of mass m which is stationary,
and then the two bodies move off together, then conservation of momentum suggests that the since the combined mass is 2m, the new velocity will be 1/2 u.

Total momentum before collision = mu + m0 = mu
Total momentum after collision = m(1/2u) + m(1/2u) = mu

However energy before collision = 1/2mu2
and energy after collision = 1/2m(1/2u)2 + 1/2m(1/2u)2 = 1/4mu2

So it seems the energy is halved or am I making an error in the calculations ?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
A_B
93
1
If, as you say, the object stick together after collision, then indeed kinetic energy is lost. The energy has gone to internal energy of the colliding masses. A collision where the objects move away together is NOT elastic. In an elastic collision (one that does conserve kinetic energy) with two equal masses, one of which is stationary, the incoming object will hit the stationary one and come to rest while the stationary object moves off at a speed equal to that of the incoming object.

some info and nice graphics: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elastic_collision
 
  • #3
21
0
Does conservation of momentum only take place with elastic collisions ? If the collision is inelastic and the masses stick together, the combined mass is 2m so to conserve momentum, the velocity would be half and energy after collision = 1/4mu2 or exactly half the energy before the collision.
 
  • #4
AlephZero
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
6,994
292
Does conservation of momentum only take place with elastic collisions?
From your OP you seem to understand the difference between energy and momentum, so I think you make a typo there.

ENERGY is only conserved with perfectly elastic collisions. In fact that's the definition of what a perfectly elastic collision is. There are no PERFECTLY elastic collisions in real life.

MOMENTUM is always conserved, in any sort of collision, because the forces acting on the two objects are always equal and opposite to each other.
 
  • #5
Andrew Mason
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
7,652
383
ENERGY is only conserved with perfectly elastic collisions. In fact that's the definition of what a perfectly elastic collision is. There are no PERFECTLY elastic collisions in real life.
Not trying to be picky, but ENERGY is always conserved too. It is just not conserved as KINETIC energy.

AM
 
  • Like
Likes gracy
  • #6
21
0
Going back to the original example, the body with velocity u and mass m strikes the stationary body of mass m. The collision is inelastic and the bodies stick together.
Am I correct that in saying that the total momentum before the collision is mu and after the collision (2m)(1/2u) = mu and energy before collision is 1/2mu2 and after collision 1/2(2m)(1/2u)2 or 1/4mu2 ? Does exactly half of the energy remain as kinetic energy ?
 
  • #7
Andrew Mason
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
7,652
383
Going back to the original example, the body with velocity u and mass m strikes the stationary body of mass m. The collision is inelastic and the bodies stick together.
Am I correct that in saying that the total momentum before the collision is mu and after the collision (2m)(1/2u) = mu and energy before collision is 1/2mu2 and after collision 1/2(2m)(1/2u)2 or 1/4mu2 ? Does exactly half of the energy remain as kinetic energy ?
On those facts, yes. In the centre of mass frame, both masses are approaching the centre of mass at speed u/2. The energy before the collision is 2 x .5m(u/2)^2 = mu^2/4 and after the collision it is 0.

AM
 
  • #8
476
0
If a body of mass m and velocity u collides with another body of mass m which is stationary,
and then the two bodies move off together, then conservation of momentum suggests that the since the combined mass is 2m, the new velocity will be 1/2 u.

Total momentum before collision = mu + m0 = mu
Total momentum after collision = m(1/2u) + m(1/2u) = mu

However energy before collision = 1/2mu2
and energy after collision = 1/2m(1/2u)2 + 1/2m(1/2u)2 = 1/4mu2

So it seems the energy is halved or am I making an error in the calculations ?
Total momentum after collision = m(1/2u) + m(1/2u) = mu = MV

where M = 2m and V = u/2 are mass and velocity of the composite body.

energy after collision = 1/4mu2 = 1/2 2m (u/2)2 = 1/2 MV2

Everything is right.

What happens is that your collision is not elastic and does not conserve kinetic energy (total energy is still conserved). It can be showed that for a system of particles with the same mass, an elastic collision interchange the velocities. That is your stationary particle would acquire velocity u and the moving particle would stop. This is not the case which mean that your collision is not elastic
 
Last edited:

Related Threads on Conservation of Momentum of a body of mass

Replies
40
Views
540
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
14
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
936
Replies
4
Views
863
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
3K
Top