Crazy Theory: Using Fabric to Explain Space/Time

  • Thread starter FawkesCa
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Theory
In summary, the conversation discusses a theory involving the concept of fabric and surface tension in relation to the movement of objects in space. The theory is debated and ultimately deemed against forum rules.
  • #1
FawkesCa
43
0
i know this is probably REALLY stupid, but i guess i just have a need to be ridiculed...so here goes.

What if, through all the hard work and strain, everyone has forgotten one simple aspect of the fabric matter: surface tension.
Imagine a large piece of fabric held tight at all ends. When a nine pound bowling ball (a star) is rolled onto the fabric (space/time), a depression is made. When small marbles (planets) are placed on the fabric, they gravitate toward the larger ball. If enough speed and fabric is used, you can create an orbit like that of Earth, Mars or Even Pluto (I’d like to see you try that one). Now, if one removes the nine pound ball and replaces it with a ball the same weight, but only smaller, like a shot-put ball, the depression it makes is greater because the pounds per square inch increases tremendously. To make the point even greater, place a nine pound molecule on the fabric. Chances are that the thin piece of fabric won’t hold up under the pressure the molecule exerts on the small area in which the nine pounds rests.
The fabric stretches when the molecule is put onto the fabric. Eventually, the molecule strains so much against the surface tension of the fabric, it rips through the sheet, creating a bounce back effect, making a ripple through the fabric, just like a super nova does through space/time, leaving a hole. Here comes the tricky part. With that hole left in space/time, a distortion is made in space that makes its presence known to the surrounding object, just like it’s still there, if not greater. As other objects fall into the newly made hole, it continues to grow and grow and grow until, after billions of years, it has sucks so many stars in that other stars have lined up to go on a one way trip into the forth dimension.
I may be crazy or just not informed enough in my studies to understand this type of physics. But at some point, every hypothesis should at least be looked at to test its validity? And besides, you never know until you ask.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
In before the lock :biggrin:
 
  • #3
Your theory fails because we all know a molecule would pass trough a sheet off fabric without making a hole.The distance between the individual strings of the sheet is much greater then a molecule.Duh :rolleyes:
 
  • #4
You need to learn the difference between an analogy for how something works and a description of how something works.
 
  • #5
bp_psy said:
Your theory fails because we all know a molecule would pass trough a sheet off fabric without making a hole.The distance between the individual strings of the sheet is much greater then a molecule.Duh :rolleyes:

its an analogy. of course a molecule would fall between the fabric of a sheet. imagine the theads of the sheet are tighter than a molecule if you like.
 
  • #6
FawkesCa said:
its an analogy. of course a molecule would fall between the fabric of a sheet. imagine the theads of the sheet are tighter than a molecule if you like.

the irony...
 
  • #7
The essence of your theory is what? That's the single question you've failed to answer.
 
  • #8
FawkesCa said:
its an analogy. of course a molecule would fall between the fabric of a sheet. imagine the theads of the sheet are tighter than a molecule if you like.

Well that would be a really damn good quality sheet and it would not break only because 9 pounds of force. Considering that the fibers are flexible the the nine pound molecule would still pass trough the sheet without making a hole. Another important factor is what exactly is the nine pound molecule.Does it contain carbon or oxygen? Does it react chemically with the the sheet? . Is the sheet blue or orange?
 
  • #9
Discussion of Personal theories is against PF rules.

Thread locked.
 

Related to Crazy Theory: Using Fabric to Explain Space/Time

1. What is the "crazy theory" about using fabric to explain space/time?

The "crazy theory" suggests that space and time can be visualized as a fabric, similar to a bedsheet or a trampoline, with mass and energy causing it to warp and bend. This theory is known as the "fabric of space-time."

2. How does the fabric of space-time explain gravity?

The fabric of space-time explains gravity as the result of objects with mass creating a curvature in the fabric. This curvature causes other objects to be pulled towards the center of the curvature, creating the effect we perceive as gravity.

3. Is the fabric of space-time a proven concept?

While the fabric of space-time is a widely accepted concept in the field of physics, it is still considered a theory and has not been proven definitively. However, it has been supported by numerous experiments and observations, including the bending of light by massive objects.

4. How does the fabric of space-time relate to Einstein's theory of relativity?

The fabric of space-time is a key component of Einstein's theory of relativity. It explains how space and time are intertwined and can be affected by the presence of mass and energy. This theory has greatly influenced our understanding of the universe and has been confirmed by various experiments and observations.

5. Can the fabric of space-time be visualized in everyday life?

While the concept of the fabric of space-time may be difficult to visualize in everyday life, there are some analogies that can help. For example, think of a bowling ball on a trampoline. The weight of the ball creates a curvature in the fabric, causing smaller objects (like marbles) to roll towards it. Similarly, the curvature of space-time caused by massive objects affects the movement of smaller objects around it.

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
23
Views
5K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
18
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Cosmology
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
13
Views
3K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
16
Views
5K
Back
Top