Derivative of a term within a sum

5 replies · 3K views · last reply
CricK0es
Messages
54
Reaction score
3

Homework Statement


[/B]
From the Rodrigues’ formulae, I want to derive nature of the spherical Bessel and Neumann functions at small values of p.

Homework Equations


[/B]
I'm going to post an image of the Bessel function where we're using a Taylor expansion, which I'm happy with and is as far as I got...

https://pastenow.ru/df043f5dc89214026a759bfd14e301b1
https://imgur.com/a/LmDovch
LmDovch


The Attempt at a Solution



I'm recovering some of the terms, but the jump from line 1 to 2 and 2 to 3 have me confused because I'm not recovering a similar answer.

I need to attempt it for the Neumann function at small p also, but I'm sure that a similar issue will arise and I'd rather fix it here and use the Neumann as practice for my newfound knowledge
 
Last edited by a moderator:
CricK0es said:
I'm recovering some of the terms, but the jump from line 1 to 2 and 2 to 3 have me confused because I'm not recovering a similar answer.
How about posting your work so far? You may have made a mistake that a pair of fresh eyes might be able to diagnose.
 
CricK0es said:

Homework Statement



From the Rodrigues’ formulae, I want to derive nature of the spherical Bessel and Neumann functions at small values of p.[/B]

Homework Equations



I'm going to post an image of the Bessel function where we're using a Taylor expansion, which I'm happy with and is as far as I got...[/B]

https://pastenow.ru/df043f5dc89214026a759bfd14e301b1
https://imgur.com/a/LmDovch
LmDovch


The Attempt at a Solution



I'm recovering some of the terms, but the jump from line 1 to 2 and 2 to 3 have me confused because I'm not recovering a similar answer.

I need to attempt it for the Neumann function at small p also, but I'm sure that a similar issue will arise and I'd rather fix it here and use the Neumann as practice for my newfound knowledge[/B]
I presume that the word "Derivative" in your title should be changed to some form of the word "derive" as in the context of a "derivation".

Boldface type should only be used for the three headings supplied by the Homework Template and in rare cases for items in your post which need emphasis.
(I realize that it is easy to include text in the supplied headings by mistake .​

Please use either the "Image" icon in the banner heading or the upload button found below - right of the Input Box. (See figure below.)

Forum reply editor toolbar with the Image insert icon circled in green and the UPLOAD button circled in red below the text box.


As for your Algebra question:
Here is your image displayed:

Handwritten-style typeset derivation of the series expansion of the spherical Bessel-type function j_λ(ρ) as a power series in ρ, with a final leading term ρ^λ 2^λ(λ!)/(2λ+1)! + O(ρ^(λ+1)).


So it seems that you want to know why
## (2n)(2n-2)(2n-4) \dots (2n-2\lambda +2) ##​
is equal to
## \dfrac {2^n (n!)} {(n-\lambda)!} ##​
Right?

Actually, it looks to me as if that last expression should be ## \dfrac {2^\lambda (n!)} {(n-\lambda)!} ## .

Try expanding ## \dfrac { (n!)} {(n-\lambda)!} ## and see what you get.

Added in Edit :

How many terms are in ## (2n) ,~ (2n-2),~(2n-4),~ \dots ,~ (2n-2\lambda +2) ~?##

(& fixed a typo)
 
Attachments
  • Forum reply editor toolbar with the Image insert icon circled in green and the UPLOAD button circled in red below the text box.
    Box to make Posts(Image).png
    6 KB · Views: 661
  • Handwritten-style typeset derivation of the series expansion of the spherical Bessel-type function j_λ(ρ) as a power series in ρ, with a final leading term ρ^λ 2^λ(λ!)/(2λ+1)! + O(ρ^(λ+1)).
    c49M8Jr.png
    19.7 KB · Views: 802
Last edited:
Handwritten derivation on lined paper: j_λ(e) = (−e)^λ(1/e ∂/∂e)^λ Σ(n=0 to ∞) (−1)^n e^(2n)/(2n+1)!, then (−1)^λ e^λ... (1/e^λ) Σ (−1)^n/(2n+1)! ∂^λ/∂e^λ(e^(2n)), then Σ(n=λ to ∞) (−1)^λ (−1)^n/(2n+1)! e^(2n−λ). A cloud labelled WELP! points to a factor (2n)(2n−1)(2n−2) with a question mark.


I can't see where the (2n)(2n-2)... term is coming from, and then from the solutions, I don't see how we go from line 2 to 3.

So, this final question has not gone well... at all ha! So there's some very key thing in my understanding that I'm missing here, as my original attempt above indicates
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten derivation on lined paper: j_λ(e) = (−e)^λ(1/e ∂/∂e)^λ Σ(n=0 to ∞) (−1)^n e^(2n)/(2n+1)!, then (−1)^λ e^λ... (1/e^λ) Σ (−1)^n/(2n+1)! ∂^λ/∂e^λ(e^(2n)), then Σ(n=λ to ∞) (−1)^λ (−1)^n/(2n+1)! e^(2n−λ). A cloud labelled WELP! points to a factor (2n)(2n−1)(2n−2) with a question mark.
    upload_2019-2-15_14-39-49.png
    82.2 KB · Views: 655
CricK0es said:
I can't see where the (2n)(2n-2)... term is coming from ...
If series confuse you, I recommend that you write out a few terms and see how things go together.

The series is ##S(\rho)=a_0+a_2\rho^2+a_4\rho^4+\cdots+a_{2n-2}\rho^{2n-2}+ a_{2n}\rho^{2n}+\cdots##
For ##\lambda=1##,$$\frac{1}{\rho}\frac{\partial S(\rho)}{\partial \rho}=\frac{1}{\rho}(2a_2\rho^1+4a_4\rho^3+\cdots+(2n-2)a_{2n-2}\rho^{2n-2-1}+ 2na_{2n}\rho^{2n-1}+\cdots)\\=2a_2\rho^0+4a_4\rho^2+\cdots+(2n-2)a_{2n-2}\rho^{2n-4}+ 2na_{2n}\rho^{2n-2}+\cdots$$For ##\lambda=2##, take the first derivative of the above and divide by another ##\rho## because you have already divided by one when you did ##\lambda=1##. Thus,
$$\frac{1}{\rho^2}\frac{\partial^2 S(\rho)}{\partial \rho^2}=4\cdot 2a_4\rho^0+\cdots+(2n-2)(2n-4)a_{2n-2}\rho^{2n-6}+ 2n(2n-2)a_{2n}\rho^{2n-4}+\cdots$$See how it works? If not, do ##\lambda=3## in the same manner.
 
Last edited:
I realized I forgot to say thank you! I got it sorted!