Derivatives with pictures (problems 3-4)

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around the application of derivatives in calculus, specifically focusing on implicit differentiation and the use of the chain and product rules. Participants are addressing problems related to derivatives of functions involving products and compositions of variables.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants explore the differentiation of products and compositions of functions, questioning the application of the chain rule and product rule. There are attempts to clarify the steps involved in implicit differentiation and the subsequent use of the point-slope formula for finding tangent lines.

Discussion Status

Several participants are actively engaging in checking each other's work and providing guidance on differentiation techniques. There is a mix of correct and incorrect reasoning, with some participants expressing confusion about algebraic manipulations and the application of calculus rules. Productive dialogue is ongoing, with hints and suggestions being exchanged.

Contextual Notes

Participants are working under the constraints of homework assignments, which may limit the information available for problem-solving. There are indications of uncertainty regarding the correct application of differentiation rules and the handling of algebraic expressions.

asdfsystema
Messages
87
Reaction score
0
2gv1mz6.jpg


6oevrq.jpg


Help me out please ! for #4 I'm preeeetty sure i did it correctly but it wouldn't hurt having someone double check it. for #5 , I'm not sure if i took the second derivative correctly

Will be on for the next couple hours trying to understand calculus ... :(

Thanks in advance ^^
 
Physics news on Phys.org
You are pretty good on 4), the other two are an absolute disaster. I don't think you quite get the chain rule. Let's just take a part. What's d/dx(x*y)? Use the product rule also.
 
Thanks for answering

d/dx(xy) = (y)+(x)(dy/dx)

but i don't see where I am supposed to apply the chain rule
i'm having trouble with the second part...

d/dx(xy^3)= (y^3) + (3y^2)*(dy/dx)*x

d/dx(10)=0

then I got [y^3+x*3y^2*dy/dx] + [y+x*dy/dx] = 0

EDIT: wait is d/dx (xy^3) = y^3+x3y *dy/dx
 
Now you've got it right. Good job. That's different from what you wrote in the post. Now what is dy/dx?
 
[(y^3+x3y*dy/dx)] = [-(y+x*dy/dx)]

how do i cancel the dy/dx ?since I'm almost done, i'll try to work on the other problem too. btw, is my #4 correct?

#5 f(x)= -2ln[sin(x)]

f'(x)= -2cos(x)/sin(x) --> -2cos(x)/sin(x) . b/c ln(u(x))' = u'(x)/u(x)

f"(x)= quotient rule ? sin(x)*2sin(x)+cos(x)(2cos(x)) / sin(x)^2

Thanks a lot ! ^^
 
You don't cancel dy/dx. You solve for it. Move all the dy/dx parts to one side of the equation, factor dy/dx out and move everything else to the other side. And, yes, I think you are doing ok with part 4 as well. You could also say f'(x)=-2*cot(x) and go from there.
 
Haha I think I'm doing this wrong but ...

#3. -y^3-y / x3y / x and then i have to use tangent line equation after this. but i'll do it after you confirm its correct or wrong#5. I took your advice f'(x)-2*cot(x)

f"(x) = -2csc^(x) is the answer ?
 
I get +2csc(x)^2, but you might want to check that, it's late here. For the first one, the numerator looks good, but what's going on the denominator? x3y?
 
Last edited:
Yup, you were correct but it's f"(x) 2csc^2(x)

and for this one...

asdfsystema said:
Thanks for answering

d/dx(xy) = (y)+(x)(dy/dx)

but i don't see where I am supposed to apply the chain rule
i'm having trouble with the second part...

d/dx(xy^3)= (y^3) + (3y^2)*(dy/dx)*x

d/dx(10)=0

then I got [y^3+x*3y^2*dy/dx] + [y+x*dy/dx] = 0

EDIT: wait is d/dx (xy^3) = y^3+x3y *dy/dx


Wait, was the one in the "EDIT" correct or incorrect?

but if its correct, -y^3 -y / 3y after cancelling out the x's
 
  • #10
You can't cancel that x, now can you?
 
  • #11
i don't understand this at all . its confusing me , I'm not even sure if I'm supposed to look at

1. d/dx (xy^3) = y^3+x3y *dy/dx

or

2.d/dx(xy^3)= (y^3) + (3y^2)*(dy/dx)*x

assuming its 1. this time i got (-y^3-y)(x) / x3y ....after i use the implicit differentiation, to find the tangent line to the curve , i use point slope formula right ?
 
  • #12
It's 2. d/dx(y^3)=3y^2*dy/dx. Chain rule. You had it right when you said "I got [y^3+x*3y^2*dy/dx] + [y+x*dy/dx] = 0". Solve that for dy/dx. I'll repeat what I already said. "Move all the dy/dx parts to one side of the equation, factor dy/dx out and move everything else to the other side." By dividing by it. Like this: if x+y=x*dy/dx-y*dy/dx, dy/dx=(x+y)/(x-y).
 
Last edited:
  • #13
okay this time i got -y^3-y / 3y^2 . damn i hope this is right .

with all these "y's" how can i use the point slope formula to get y=mx+b for question #3 (the one dealing with implicit differentiation)
 
  • #14
Look at your correct differentiation in the preceding post. Where did the term x*dy/dx go? And what happened to the x in x*3*y^2? You'll finally use (x,y)=(5,1) and figure out dy/dx which is m in your point slope form. Can you show exactly how you solved for dy/dx?
 
  • #15
okay i am getting really confused .

here's what i did so far :

an09yu.jpg


I thought you told me to just leave the 2 dy/dx's on the left side and then I could cancel out the x if i bring it to the right side x/x = 1
 
  • #16
Take your second line from the bottom. That becomes (x*3y^2+x)*dy/dx=(-y^3-y). So dy/dx=(-y^3-y)/(x*3y^2+x). You can't move the 3y^2 over all by itself, and you can't just 'cancel' the x. There's nothing to 'cancel' it. Those aren't calculus problems, those are algebra problems.
 
  • #17
Thanks. the next thing I have to do is find the tangent line to this...

i need to find the slope first. Do i need to take derivative again? I don't think so because i already did implicit differentiation...

so the next step is to plug in the x value (5,1) so i plug in 5 ... into all the x's.

I haev a question, do I get y alone on one side of the equation and then plug in the x ?
 
  • #18
Yes, find the slope first. That's dy/dx. You have a formula for dy/dx. Put x=5 and y=1 into it.
 
  • #19
after plugging in, i get dy/dx = -1/10 which is the slope

then i use point slope formula y-y0 = m (x -x0)

y-(1) = -1/10x-1/2

i get y= -1/10x + 1/2 so m= -1/10 and b= 1/2 ?
 
  • #20
Your problems with algebra are killing you. -1/10*(x-5)=(-1/10)*x+1/2 NOT (-1/10)*x-1/2. You should also practice checking yourself. If you think y=(-1/10)*x+1/2, check it. If you put in x=5, you should get y=1. You don't.
 
Last edited:
  • #21
asdfsystema said:
after plugging in, i get dy/dx = -1/10 which is the slope

then i use point slope formula y-y0 = m (x -x0)

y-(1) = -1/10x-1/2

i get y= -1/10x + 1/2 so m= -1/10 and b= 1/2 ?
oops lol ok i see it . -1/10x + 1.5 hahahahah
 
  • #22
Really, practice your algebra, man. It more than half of your problem. You are better at calculus than algebra. But you can't do one without the other.
 

Similar threads

Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K