Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Did this guy state something wrong about evolution theory?

  1. Jan 26, 2017 #1
    i have found one article state something like this:

    """Any real evolution (macroevolution) requires an expansion of the gene pool, the addition of new genes (genons) with new information for new traits as life is supposed to move from simple beginnings to ever more varied and complex forms (“molecules to man” or “fish to philosopher”). Suppose there are islands where varieties of flies that used to trade genes no longer interbreed. Is this evidence of evolution? No, exactly the opposite. Each variety resulting from reproductive isolation has a smaller gene pool than the original and a restricted ability to explore new environments with new trait combinations or to meet changes in its own environment. The long-term result? Extinction would be much more likely than evolution."""

    what mistake is he making in the above sentence?thank

    <link to a pseudoscientific website deleted>
    Last edited by a moderator: Jan 26, 2017
  2. jcsd
  3. Jan 26, 2017 #2


    User Avatar
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member
    2017 Award

    I think his statement confuses the concepts "result of" with "evidence of". His fly interbreeding example may lead to the result of reduced evolution. But that may not imply that it is not evidence of the existence of evolution.

    He may have a point, but he should make it some other way.
  4. Jan 26, 2017 #3

    jim mcnamara

    User Avatar

    Staff: Mentor

    The person who wrote the quote has an axe to grind. First off, a priori logic is not how you figure out Biology or Evolution. Experiments establish that knowledge.

    [Logic 101]
    However. This kind of logic is extensively used in Apologetics. This discipline is essentially devoted to proving that your religion is correct and others are not.
    Christian apologetics (the proposed argument above) is more, um, adamant about defending the faith. When used by Biblical fundamentalists you get arguments like the one above. Conservative Christians view Evolution as an affront to their views.
    [/Logic 101]

    Importantly. Aside from all that, the quote conveniently ignores mutation, which occurs spontaneously. It is true that if a population of organisms gets cut off from the main one, it likely has a different set of gene frequencies and is missing some genes (alleles) as well. This is called the founder effect. The rate of mutation for the isolated population continues unabated. So new DNA becomes available.

    Note: when you read this remember that scientists use the word 'theory' to mean something well-tested and documented. It is nothing like when your friend comes up to you in casual conversation and says, 'I have a theory about why Jenny likes Billy' The two meanings are light years apart.

    So, a counterpoint based on experimental evidence starts with:

    - remember the the admonishment about 'theory'

    And Darwin's finches as well, but you have enough to read already.

    Living organisms acquire mutations "spontaneously". An example of this is environmentally induced cancers.

    Somatic and sex cells in organisms may develop changes in DNA (mutations, deletions, additions) from exposure to: heavy metals, many kinds of organic molecules, background radiation. If the DNA change affects the control of cell division or "turns on" a gene that should be off, it often affects cell division and cell differentiation in the tissue where the DNA change occurred. This anomalous growth is a tumor.

    @FactChecker - the quote does have a point and it is not about Evolution. It is about the correctness of certain theology.
    Last edited by a moderator: Jan 26, 2017
  5. Jan 26, 2017 #4


    User Avatar

    Staff: Mentor

    We do not allow discussion of pseudoscience, even to debunk it.

    Thread closed.
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook