Diff Eq Sign Error - Seeking Second Set of Eyes

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
10 replies · 4K views
Saladsamurai
Messages
3,009
Reaction score
7
!For The Love of GOD! Diff Eq

Homework Statement



I have done this problem 3 times. I am getting a sign error somewhere and I cannot find it.

When I solve this DE and then plug it back into the original, it is not checking out! Can anybody see my error? I would really appreciate a second set of eyes here. Clearly I am at that point where I just keep seeing what I think I am supposed to see!
Picture1-6.png

Re writing the solution to the DE with the new constants is

[tex]x=-3/2\cos4t+3\sin4t+7/2\cos4t+1/2\sin4t=2\cos4t+19/4\sin4t[/tex]
[tex]y=3\cos4t-7/2\sin4t[/tex]

But when I differentiate and plug back into either if the originals, I am coming up with two sign errors...
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
At one point in your solution you have:
[tex]4 k_1+ (-2- 4i)k_2= 0[/tex]
and then
[tex]k_1= \frac{-2- 4i}{4}k_2[/tex]
It should be
[tex]k_1= \frac{2+ 4i}{4}k_2[/tex]
 
HallsofIvy said:
At one point in your solution you have:
[tex]4 k_1+ (-2- 4i)k_2= 0[/tex]
and then
[tex]k_1= \frac{-2- 4i}{4}k_2[/tex]
It should be
[tex]k_1= \frac{2+ 4i}{4}k_2[/tex]

I do not understand why it should be positive? From the matrix I have [itex]4k_1+(-2-\lambda)k_2[/itex] where lambda=4i...unless I am interpreting matrices wrong??
 
Basic Algebra.

4K1 - (2+4i)k2 = 0
K1 = (2+4i)k2/4
 
Vid said:
Basic Algebra.

4K1 - (2+4i)k2 = 0
K1 = (2+4i)k2/4

Okay. Obviously I am misinterpreting how a matrix operates. Not how to do basic algebra.
I was just kidding, maybe that was inappropriate...my bad.
 
Last edited:
If the original equation was
x'=2x-5y
y'=4x-2y

To find the charectaristic equation I create this matrix thing...I don't know what it is called

[tex] \left[\begin{array}{cc}2-\lambda & -5 \\ 4 & -2-\lambda\end{array}\right]=0[/tex]

Now if I plug in [itex]\lambda= 4i[/itex] to the 2nd row, how do you suppose I will get anything positive?
 
Saladsamurai said:
If the original equation was
x'=2x-5y
y'=4x-2y

To find the charectaristic equation I create this matrix thing...I don't know what it is called

[tex] \left[\begin{array}{cc}2-\lambda & -5 \\ 4 & -2-\lambda\end{array}\right]=0[/tex]

Now if I plug in [itex]\lambda= 4i[/itex] to the 2nd row, how do you suppose I will get anything positive?

Can anybody see what I am doing wrong in this procedure? What am I misunderstanding?

If I plug [itex]\lambda=4i[/itex] into [itex]-2-\lambda[/itex] why would I get 2+4i ?

I have five more problems similar to this and cannot move on until I clear this up.

Any help would be great!
 
Saladsamurai said:
If the original equation was
x'=2x-5y
y'=4x-2y

To find the charectaristic equation I create this matrix thing...I don't know what it is called

[tex] \left[\begin{array}{cc}2-\lambda & -5 \\ 4 & -2-\lambda\end{array}\right]=0[/tex]

Now if I plug in [itex]\lambda= 4i[/itex] to the 2nd row, how do you suppose I will get anything positive?

Saladsamurai said:
Can anybody see what I am doing wrong in this procedure? What am I misunderstanding?

If I plug [itex]\lambda=4i[/itex] into [itex]-2-\lambda[/itex] why would I get 2+4i ?

I have five more problems similar to this and cannot move on until I clear this up.

Any help would be great!


Kind of desperate here...
 
Do you still not see the glaring algebra error in the bottom left...?
 
Vid said:
Do you still not see the glaring algebra error in the bottom left...?

Thank you. That's all I needed...
 
Your K1 value is where the sign error is. Change it to what Hallsofivy did and solve again from there.